There’s nothing set in stone. They’re just projections.
But the potential salary figures for a few Pirates, released Monday night via MLB Trade Rumors, could point to even more roster shuffling for the club this winter.
Same as ever, they’re calculated by Matt Swartz, a baseball economist who has performed this task for about a decade and a half. His success rate is very good. So much so that that much of the industry routinely relies on (and cites) the projected amounts players will earn via arbitration.
On paper, that involves nine Pirates who are eligible for arbitration, including Oneil Cruz for the first time. Despite hitting .200 with a .676 OPS, Cruz is projected to earn $3.2 million in 2026 because arbitration also revolves around service time, not just production.
It’s still a reasonable number for the Pirates to pay. Although if they didn’t want to, they could non-tender Cruz — essentially saying they didn’t want to go through the entire process with him. The deadline for that stuff is Nov. 21.
As far as Pirates who are eligible for arbitration and now have a projected salary next to their name, here’s the list:
Read More
• Dennis Santana, $3.4 million
• Johan Oviedo, $2 million
• Joey Bart, $2.7 million
• Justin Lawrence, $1.2 million
• Yohan Ramirez, $1.2 million
• Colin Holderman, $1.7 million
• Oneil Cruz, $3.6 million
• Dauri Moreta, $800,000
• Jack Suwinski, $1.7 million
As frustrating as Cruz might be, it’s worth $3.2 million to see if he’ll figure it out in 2026. This has to be a big offseason for the Pirates and Cruz, the organization somehow getting through to him and upping the focus in his game.
There’s a different level of certainty, or less confidence in the Pirates agreeing to pay Jack Suwinski, whose number is really high for someone who hit just .147 with a .534 OPS this past season.
If Suwinski wouldn’t agree to a smaller salary, it certainly makes sense to part ways. And it might anyway, considering how Suwinski has seemingly stagnated with his development.
With Tommy Pham soon a free agent, the Pirates have a gigantic hole in left field and need to fill it aggressively. Suwinski had his time, his opportunities and did not deliver. He’s certainly not worth paying $1.7 million.
Bart is another tricky one. After hitting 13 homers and posting a .799 OPS in 2024, the catcher went backwards in 2025, producing a .696 OPS and struggling defensively.
If the Pirates are going to prioritize Henry Davis, because he’s more comfortable with their young pitchers, they might not want to pay Bart that kind of money.
They’re also short on bats, especially a right-handed hitter to complement Spencer Horwitz at first, and keeping Bart and hoping he finds his 2024 form isn’t a crazy expensive gamble.
Santana and Oviedo are no-brainers. Same for Moreta, who should be a consistent member of their bullpen in ‘26 and has found success before in a fireman role.
The questionable ones are probably Lawrence, Holderman and Ramirez, who could all be replaced for cheaper.
They’re cut from a similar cloth, too: Relievers with tantalizing stuff … who’ve also lacked consistency, either because of injuries or the ability to find the strike zone often enough.
Lawrence, with a devastating sweeper, would be the pick here. You can find Ramirez types anywhere — and the Pirates have. Holderman, whose struggles date back to 2024 and are not small, probably needs a change of scenery. Moreta has the most upside of the bunch.
Again, however, these are projections. The majority will avoid arbitration by agreeing to contracts with the Pirates, typically a shade under the number Swartz is projecting.
Arbitration cases are fairly unlikely, where the two sides exchange figures and a neutral panel picks one or the other. That’s down the road.
The headliner here is Cruz, how it’s time to put it all together.
No longer is he on a team-control salary, the way baseball players are for the first three years. It’s time for Cruz to produce. If he does, there’s plenty of money to be made.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.