Mitch Keller is the biggest loser in Major League Baseball.

The Pirates’ veteran right-hander has pitched 14 times this season. His team boasts a 3-11 record in those games. Keller’s record on the year is 1-9. He has lost in each of his last nine decisions. Those nine losses were the most of any pitcher in MLB entering the weekend.

On the surface, Keller’s record indicates he is in the midst of a season to forget, which, in a way, is true. But a glance beyond the record tells the true story. Keller’s statistics display failure — but the bulk of that failure does not fall on him.

“I feel like I’m throwing the ball well,” Keller said Tuesday following his most recent start. “I feel healthy and I feel like my stuff’s coming out. I feel like it’s getting better as the year goes on, so that’s always a positive.”

Advertise with us

Keller boasts a 4.15 ERA, 3.32 FIP and 1.28 WHIP. All three of those figures are better than his career averages. He entered the weekend ranking within the top 25 of MLB’s qualified pitchers in both walks per nine innings (2.19) and home runs allowed per nine innings (0.66).

Keller has already logged 10 quality starts this season, tied for third most in MLB. His quality start percentage (71.4%) is on pace to shatter his career-best mark (56.3%) from 2023, a year he was an All-Star. Yet, in nine of his 14 outings, Keller was the loser.

The true explanation for Keller’s losing ways can be found through one simple metric: run support.

The Pirates have scored just 19 runs when Keller is on the mound this year, the lowest total for any qualified pitcher in MLB. Their average runs scored per nine innings (RS9) during Keller’s starts is 2.08, which is also the lowest for any qualified big-league starter.

Keller has received one run or zero runs of support in nine of his 14 starts. The Pirates have scored four or more runs only once while he was on the mound. That effort came on March 28, his first start of the season, which also happens to be his only win of the year.

Advertise with us

While an ugly record can be frustrating, the true issue is the Pirates are wasting what Keller has consistently provided. Not only are they failing to score runs while he’s in the game, but they’re also continuing to do so after he exits.

Keller isn’t the only Pirates starter whose record has suffered from the Pirates’ offensive woes, but his best efforts have been squandered far more than others within the rotation.

Paul Skenes entered the weekend with an MLB-leading 11 quality starts. The Pirates won six of those 11 games, a disappointing metric but still an above-.500 showing. They boast a 4-2 record in the six quality starts provided from both Andrew Heaney and Bailey Falter. That success, however, has not applied to Keller.

Tuesday marked the seventh time the Pirates have lost a game when Keller provided a quality start. So even when Keller is at his best, his team has just a .300 winning percentage.

“It’s tough, man,” Pirates manager Don Kelly said after Tuesday’s loss. “He’s pitched well enough to win some ballgames. He’s done a great job, like he did tonight, with giving us a chance to win. Unfortunately, there’s been a lot of times where we haven’t been able to come through in those instances. Just hoping in the ninth inning he doesn’t get the loss. He doesn’t get the win either, but we’d get the team win, and that’s ultimately what we’re after.”

Advertise with us

To his credit, Keller has handled himself well throughout this frustrating campaign. He has had every opportunity to call out his teammates or at the very least voice some disappointment but has remained a pro instead.

“It’s not a challenge,” Keller said. “The challenge is going out there every night trying to not give up runs against other lineups. That’s the challenge for me and that’s the challenge I’ll always take out there. I try to control what I can control.”

Keller will likely continue to uphold his end of the bargain. While he has regressed during the second half in each of the last two seasons, overall, he still remains one of the most consistent starting pitchers in the National League.

More often than not, Keller gives the Pirates a solid chance to win each time he takes the mound. His efforts make life easier for his teammates. It’s about time they start returning the favor.

Three up

• Start me up: Pirates starters entered the weekend having recorded at least 10 outs in 70 straight games this season, joining Tampa Bay (68) as the only major league teams to have done that this year. That stretch is the longest of its kind in franchise history since at least 1901.

Advertise with us

• Donnie ball: After getting outscored 175-118 in their first 38 games of the season, the Pirates entered the weekend having outscored opposing teams 109-105 since May 9, the first game Kelly took over as the club’s manager.

• Attaboy, Adam: Adam Frazier entered the weekend hitting .344 with five doubles, a home run, eight RBIs and seven runs scored in his last 18 games. Frazier’s batting average over that stretch ranks second best among National League hitters with at least 60 at-bats, trailing only Ronald Acuna Jr. of the Atlanta Braves.

Three down

• Tommy’s tough times: Tommy Pham, the Pirates’ opening day starter in left field, entered the weekend hitless in his last 11 at-bats. Pham has yet to hit a home run as a Pirate and is batting just .197 on the year.

• Canario cooled off: After taking Pham’s spot last month as the everyday left fielder, Alexander Canario has gone on a cold streak of his own, entering the weekend hitless in his last 12 at-bats. Canario’s playing time has regressed because of this slump, as he had started only four games in June entering the weekend.

• Mr. June no more: While Bryan Reynolds has had tremendous success in June over the past few seasons, this year, at least so far, hasn’t followed that pattern. Reynolds entered the weekend hitting just .184 in 11 games this month, having just one fewer strikeout (13) than walks and hits combined (14).

Advertise with us

On deck

• Mighty mighty Tigers: Pittsburgh’s next opponent, the Detroit Tigers, entered the weekend with the best winning percentage in the American League (.643)

• Tarik is terrific: The Pirates are expected to face reigning AL Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal during their trip to the Motor City. Skubal has once again been elite, entering this week with a 7-2 record and 1.99 ERA.

• Howdy, partner: After facing the Tigers three times in Detroit, the Pirates will return home to host the Rangers for a three-game weekend series at PNC Park. The Rangers have had a disappointing season so far, entering the weekend with a record of 33-36.

Bottom of the ninth

Don’t look now, but Oneil Cruz is quietly becoming a solid center fielder. Cruz’s struggles in the outfield were on full display throughout the opening month of the season. He finished April having minus-10 defensive runs saved (DRS), the worst of any player in baseball, per Fangraphs. But since that ugly start, he has quickly become one of the Pirates’ best defenders. From the start of May to the beginning of his team’s four-game series against the Cubs, Baseball Savant valued Cruz’s defense at three outs above average (OAA), a figure first noted by MLB.com. Only Ke’Bryan Hayes has been a more valuable glove in that stretch by OAA. While Cruz’s offense will likely always be the primary story, his ability to also contribute in the field will make the Pirates’ top position player even more valuable moving forward.

Numerology

1.88 — The ERA of the Pirates bullpen during their recent nine-game homestand, when it finished 4-0 with five saves over 28⅔ innings of work.