All but two of the Pirates’ six arbitration-eligible players came to terms with the franchise on contracts before Thursday’s deadline.

Per sources, closer David Bednar, catcher Joey Bart, left-hander Bailey Falter and right-hander Colin Holderman all settled and agreed to one-year deals with the Pirates on Thursday. Right-handers Johan Oviedo and Dennis Santana, meanwhile, did not come to a settlement with the Pirates before the deadline. Both sides will exchange arbitration figures.

Bednar, who is coming off a down season, inked the most lucrative contract of the bunch at $5.9 million, sources told the Post-Gazette. The two-time All-Star was slowed by injury and poor performance, ultimately losing his closer job before finishing last season with a 5.77 ERA.

Using arbitration estimates from MLB Trade Rumors as a guide, Bednar came to an agreement that was roughly $700,000 less than expected.

Advertise with us

Similarly, Bart signed for less than expected, although only slightly. Sources told the Post-Gazette that Bart and the Pirates settled at $1.75 million, which is only $50,000 less than what MLB Trade Rumors expected of the former No. 2 overall pick. Bart set career highs in home runs, doubles and RBIs with the Pirates after coming over from the Giants in April.

Falter, though, settled with the Pirates at a figure far lower than expected by MLB Trade Rumors. The left-hander was expected to receive $2.8 million but settled for $2.222 million, according to a source. Falter set career highs in starts, wins, innings pitched and strikeouts in 2024.

Holderman was an exception to the rule of signing below perceived market value. While MLB Trade Rumors expected Holderman to settle for $1.4 million, the right-handed reliever and the Pirates agreed to a bit more at $1.5 million, per a source.

Even with a challenging late July/early August stretch last season, Holderman was one of the Pirates’ best relievers and compiled a 3.16 ERA across 51⅓ innings. While the Pirates succeeded in locking up that quartet of players, such wasn’t the case with Oviedo and Santana, whose respective situations are significantly different.

It’s a somewhat surprising move for Oviedo and his camp, considering the right-hander missed all of 2024 due to Tommy John surgery and was expected to make roughly $1.5 million this season. When healthy in 2023, however, Oviedo was one of the backbones of the Pirates rotation and was worth 2.1 wins above replacement, per Baseball Reference.

Advertise with us

Santana, meanwhile, really came into his own with the Pirates. After being designated for assignment by the Yankees in June, Santana compiled a 2.44 ERA with 50 strikeouts in 44⅓ innings for the Pirates. He was expected to make $1.8 million in 2025.

Both Oviedo and Santana remain members of the Pirates franchise despite their failing to settle with the club. After figures are exchanged between the Pirates and each player’s representative, hearings will be scheduled for later this winter.

If no one-year or multiyear settlement can be reached by the hearing date for each player, their cases will be brought before a panel of arbitrators. After hearing arguments from both sides, the panel can select the salary figure of either the player of the club — but not one in between — as the player’s salary for the upcoming season.