The Pirates 2024 campaign featured a handful of good moments, but even more disappointment.

Entering a season viewed by many — including those running the organization — as the beginning of a competitive window, Pittsburgh collapsed following the trade deadline and finished with a 76-86 record for the second straight year.

Although a talented rotation and the further development of young bats such as Oneil Cruz and Nick Gonzales are noted positives for the club entering a new year, a relatively inactive offseason also has many raising questions. Are the Pirates, as they currently stand, good enough to take the next step and compete for the postseason?

A little over a month remains before the Pirates report to Bradenton, Fla. With spring training quickly approaching, it’s hard for one not to wonder what the 2025 season will look like on the North Shore. As Ben Cherington and his front office look to put their finishing touches on the roster for the road ahead, the Post-Gazette will take a few cracks at how we see the journey unfolding. Here are five bold predictions for the Pirates’ 2025 season:

Advertise with us

Suwinski will not be on opening day roster

Rumors surfaced this week connecting the Pirates to corner outfielders Randal Grichuk and Alex Verdugo. Cherington himself expressed a desire to upgrade the outfield this offseason, so the idea of inking either of those two aforementioned names — or making a trade for Taylor Ward — makes plenty of sense. And while it would be in the best interest of the club to add a proven bat in right field, the acquisition would create more than a few questions for the Pirates’ future plans with Jack Suwinski.

Once viewed as a key piece of the core Cherington assembled, Suwinski had a disastrous year in 2024, batting just .182 with nine home runs over 88 games. Suwinski was optioned to Triple-A Indianapolis twice last season and did not return to the major leagues after his second demotion on July 29.

If the Pirates repeat last year’s strategy and go into spring training still searching for additional outfield help, all eyes will be on Suwinski to see if he can return to his 2023 form (26 home runs, 110 OPS+, 2.2 bWAR). However, if Cherington makes a move before the team reports to Bradenton, Suwinski could likely be slated to start his 2025 campaign in Indianapolis, regardless of his efforts in the preseason.

What hurts Suwinski’s chances to make the opening day roster — aside from his dreadful performance in 2024 — is the fact that he still has one remaining year of minor league options. Joshua Palacios, meanwhile, is out of minor league options, meaning if he does not make the Opening Day roster, the Pirates will be forced to designate him for assignment.

The idea of choosing Palacios as the fourth outfielder over Suwinski makes sense in the short term. Suwinski would receive regular at-bats in Triple-A, a similar approach the team took with Nick Gonzales at the start of last season. And while the Pirates hope Suwinski can build momentum in the early weeks of the regular season, Palacios will provide a left-handed bench bat who can play center field if Oneil Cruz needs a day off.

Advertise with us

Peguero will become everyday shortstop

Oneil Cruz’s move to center field last August created an unexpected hole at shortstop for both the present and future. Isiah Kiner-Falefa replaced Cruz at shortstop for the final month of last season and is slated to be the everyday starter in that spot heading into spring training. But despite the organization’s continued praise for Kiner-Falefa, more than a few factors point toward him being just a temporary solution.

While Kiner-Falefa is known to have a strong, versatile glove, his defensive metrics are less favorable at shortstop, boasting a negative run value in each of the three seasons he has logged more than 300 innings at the position. Combine that with the fact that he is in the final year of his current deal, and the Pirates — who are always thinking long-term — will likely be looking to find a more permanent solution to their middle infield.

Unlike the corner outfield spots or the bullpen, the current free agent market offers little opportunity to improve the position. And while the Pirates could always make a trade, this writer is willing to bet they will attempt to fix the issue internally. The simple answer for the Pirates would be giving Liover Peguero an everyday opportunity.

Last season, Nick Gonzales established himself as the club’s everyday second baseman, taking the job from Jared Triolo, who originally won the position in a three-way battle — which included Peguero — in spring training. Should Gonzales regress in 2025, Nick Yorke, rather than Peguero, would likely be next in line at that spot.

Peguero, meanwhile, spent the near entirety of 2024 in Triple-A, serving as the Indians’ primary shortstop in his first full year at the highest minor league level. Both Cherington and manager Derek Shelton noted Peguero’s defensive improvement in the late months of last season, leading to him getting a big league callup in the final week of September.

Advertise with us

The key for Peguero will be further development at the plate. If he can show improvement as a hitter — during both spring training and in the early months of the minor league season — the Pirates will have to give him his first real shot in the major leagues. While further time for development might be required, Peguero has just one remaining year of minor league options.

This is the year the Pirates must figure out if Peguero has a future in the organization. Giving him an everyday opportunity at shortstop will not only help them decide what to do at the position moving forward but also provide more flexibility with Kiner-Falefa, who can either be used as a super-utility man — which was his intended purpose when acquired — or moved at the deadline before his contract expires.

Pirates will be in first place at MLB All-Star break

How about that for a hot take? That’s right, this writer is predicting the Pittsburgh Pirates will be at the top of the National League Central Division at the All-Star break.

A notably weak division, the average winning percentage for the NL Central leader at the All-Star break is .559. The Pirates are scheduled to play 97 games prior to the midsummer classic, meaning a 54-43 showing should put them at the top.

Pitching will be the obvious key to Pittsburgh’s strong start. A full season with Paul Skenes on the mound, along with a more experienced Jared Jones, will give Shelton one of the game’s best one-two punches. Mitch Keller and Bailey Falter will once again have their best months of the season in the first half, with the former putting together another All-Star caliber stat line.

Advertise with us

The unit will become even stronger thanks to the return of Johan Oviedo and the arrival of Bubba Chandler, who will make his debut in late June. And while the bullpen and offense will remain inconsistent, David Bednar’s return to old form will ensure the team can win more close games than the year prior.

The team’s success will fill the city with excitement. Bucco fever will spread rapidly on the North Shore. The Pirates will arrive in Atlanta for the All-Star game as one of the league’s best stories. Paul Skenes will be one of the favorites for not only Cy Young but also the National League’s Most Valuable Player award — while Oneil Cruz, Jared Jones and David Bednar join him in the Peach State as All-Stars.

Skenes will win 2025 National League Cy Young

In most cases, claiming a 23-year-old will win a Cy Young in his first full major league season would seem rather ambitious, but regular logic and reason do not apply to Paul Skenes. Following one of the most dominant rookie seasons we’ve seen from a pitcher in the modern era, Skenes enters 2025 as the favorite to win the National League’s top pitching honor.

DraftKings, FanDuel and BetMGM all give Skenes 3-to-1 odds (+300) to take home the award, which are better than the American League favorite Tarik Skubal (+400), who will be looking to repeat. Skenes boasts a notable gap from his top challenger, which for now is Zack Wheeler (+750).

Skenes’ first full season in the big leagues will serve as the most obvious story to follow for the Pirates in 2025. If the club is going to have any sort of success this year, it will come from him leading the charge. And even if the rest of the club underperforms, it’s more than safe to assume he will still deliver.

Advertise with us

While it should be mentioned that MLB hitters have now had a full offseason to game plan for Skenes, the simple counterpoint would be that he, too, has had time to adjust and improve. With fewer restrictions to hinder his performance, a year of experience under his belt — and the addition of Brent Strom to the coaching staff — Skenes will establish himself as the unquestioned best pitching talent in the sport.

Cherington will remain general manager despite postseason drought

Still riding high from that All-Star break prediction? Now it’s time for a return to reality. While the Pirates will get off to a hot start, another slide in the final months — along with an underwhelming series of moves at the trade deadline — will result in the club missing the postseason for the 10th straight year.

As other teams with more experienced, established talent grow stronger in August and September, the Pirates will once again run out of gas, albeit in a far less catastrophic fashion compared to what occurred in 2024.

The lack of offense and bullpen depth will finally catch up to them, as will the team’s inexperience. While the assembled roster will be good enough to win close games early on, the grind of playing 162 meaningful games will be too much for some to handle, resulting in a few key pieces suffering a slump or untimely injury.

The Pirates will remain in the mix for a National League wildcard spot but will finish the final week of September on the outside looking in. And while the devastating end to 2025 could spark some change on both the roster and coaching staff, Cherington, the man at the top, will remain safe.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh’s winning record — which will be just its fifth since 1992 — will be enough for ownership to believe that the franchise is still trending upward. Attendance will have increased, Skenes will be one of the faces of the league, and few, if any, key contributors will be set to depart for the upcoming offseason.

The year will be looked at more fondly than any other in the Cherington-Shelton era, but it will still end with fans being more frustrated than satisfied. Pirate nation will spend another October watching the rest of the league compete for the commissioner's trophy, wondering when — if ever — their turn will come.