Welcome to the Pirates mailbag, where Post-Gazette reporters Andrew Destin and Noah Hiles answer all of your questions about the ball club. If you have a question, tweet them at @AndrewDestin1 and @_NoahHiles or email them at adestin@post-gazette.com and nhiles@post-gazette.com. Andrew and Noah will answer your questions in full length each Thursday. Below are this week’s top questions:
Adam: I think the team moving on from Shelton and his staff is almost a forgone conclusion after the season ends, which is a reasonable thing to do. What do you think the odds are they will move on from Cherington, who I would argue is much more responsible for this mess?
Destin: If I were to arbitrarily put a figure out there, which I will, I’d put the chances of Ben Cherington returning as general manager at least at 70%. For as much as this club has come up short of expectations and the rebuild has taken quite a long time, I have to figure there are other wholesale changes to be made before a general manager is relieved of his duties.
Hiles: I’m not so sure Shelton is guaranteed to be let go. I think a good finish to the year could save his job, based on what I’ve heard. But he certainly has a better chance of getting fired than Cherington. I think Ben is safe for at least another year.
Josh: Have there been any rumblings within the organization about extending Oneil Cruz? His continued development is key for their success and his tools could price him out of Pittsburgh really quickly. Is there any urgency to sign him before then or is their main focus his recovery?
Destin: Nothing appears to be imminent on that front. Midseason extensions are naturally rare across professional sports, and Cruz’s situation being a unique one complicates matters a bit. He played all of nine games last season and in 2024 played shoddy enough defense to be moved from shortstop to center field. With these factors in mind, in addition to an excellent offensive season, I have to figure the likelihood of Cruz inking an extension soon isn’t particularly high.
Read More
Hiles: I haven’t heard much on this as of late. I know that talks of this were rather unsuccessful in the past. His move to center field could make that effort even harder, but that’s speculation. Overall, I think there are just a handful of reasons, some known, some unknown, that would make it difficult for this team to extend Cruz.
Mols: What’s your catcher pecking order for next year?
Destin: In order: Joey Bart, Henry Davis and then Endy Rodriguez. There remains work to be done defensively for Bart, who has provided an above-average arm but is only a serviceable framer and blocker. Davis, meanwhile, should have the leg up going into spring training by virtue of his playing most of the 2024 campaign at catcher either in the big leagues or minors. Rodriguez is coming off of a pretty serious arm injury, and I see no reason why the Pirates should hurry a former top prospect back to his position sooner than is necessary.
Hiles: Joey Bart is my No. 1. After that, it’s a competition between Henry Davis and Endy Rodriguez for the second spot. Davis has to show some sort of sign that he can actually hit against major-league pitching. Quite frankly, I’m not sure if that can happen during spring training. Rodriguez, meanwhile, just needs to show he’s healthy. If his throwing arm looks good and the bat is serviceable, I likely put him at No. 2. But if he seems rusty in Bradenton, I might consider starting Rodriguez in the minors and having Davis be the backup on opening day.
JKam: Why did Skenes seemingly ditch the splinker for a more conventional changeup [Tuesday]?
Destin: For as talented as Skenes is, sometimes there are games where the entire arsenal isn’t at his disposal. Such was the case against the Cubs, who have also faced Skenes four times this season. With that last point in mind, in conjunction with the changeup looking as effective as it’s been all year, it made a good deal of sense for Skenes to pivot. While the splinker has been a more effective pitch by nearly all metrics this season, the changeup was a trick an eager Cubs lineup didn’t look remotely prepared for.
Hiles: Just an adjustment they made in the game. The changeup was working, and the splinker was not. Good pitchers are able to recognize what’s taking place in the early going and adjust. We’ve seen Skenes do this during other starts — sometimes going away from the fastball or leaning more heavily on the slider. Tuesday’s outing was the splinker. When I asked him about it after the game, he said he still feels good about the pitch and plans to keep throwing it often.
The Inside Answer: If there is any chance that the team might make changes after the year, why in the world would players like Triolo, Bae, and Taylor be on the active roster while a 25-year-old Cook is in the minors? They might win some games if they tried to improve the offense.
Destin: I’d personally be pretty surprised if Ji-Hwan Bae or Michael A. Taylor were on the Pirates roster at any point next season; the former hasn’t looked the part of a big leaguer at any juncture in his career, and the latter is wrapping up a one-year contract. As for Jared Triolo, I personally think his offensive contributions are somewhat irrelevant in comparison to what he provides as an above-average and versatile defender. That being said, I see no reason why neither Billy Cook nor Nick Yorke shouldn’t get some extended MLB action this season.
Hiles: Well, Taylor is gone because he’s on a one-year deal. Bae and Alika Williams are a few guys I could see getting designated for assignment to clear room on the 40-man roster for other younger, unproven players. Triolo is probably a guy they keep around because of his glove, although I think we learned that as of now, he’s best used as a bench guy rather than an everyday player.
The Pittsburgh Kid 412: May be too early for this but what are 3 of the positions u want the bucs to target in FA and 1 player at each
Destin: I’ll extend this beyond just position players because I think the bullpen has to be addressed. That unit was expected to be a legitimate strength in 2024, and instead was arguably the Pirates’ greatest Achilles’ heel. Considering the lack of legitimate bullpen options in the minors, I have to imagine a handful of external candidates will be brought in next spring. In addition to adding a few relievers, I figure the Pirates’ greatest needs will end up being a corner infielder and a corner outfielder. Much of that is dependent on whether the likes of Ke’Bryan Hayes, Rowdy Tellez and Connor Joe return, but upgrading the offensive contributions at the corner infield spots feels like a must. In a similar vein, getting better outfield defense is a must considering how long the Pirates have operated with Bryan Reynolds in left field. Not to mention, Jack Suwinski struggled mightily in center field this year before being sent down to the minors.
Hiles: First base is the obvious answer because it’s seemingly always a need for the Pirates. Bringing Rowdy back might be a decent option, but they should still get a better right-handed option to platoon him with if he does return. After that, I would look at shortstop. Isiah Kiner-Falefa is a good defender, but his value is versatility. I would rather him be someone that bounces around the field rather than locking him into one spot. Finally, my last pick would be left field. I would debate moving Reynolds to either designated hitter or first base, depending on what happens with Andrew McCutchen. Getting a solid defender in left will make Cruz’s transition easier in center field. I also think that’s a position that has more than a few attractive, affordable players that can be signed or traded for compared to other spots around the diamond.
Thank you all for following along! Please subscribe to our FREE daily all-sports newsletter and YouTube channel: @PGSportsNow.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.