It almost feels like some sort of a bizarro world — in the same apartment but with everything flipped, habits unrecognizable and friends functioning opposite ways.
In Pittsburgh, the Kansas City Royals’ impressive turnaround probably isn’t a terribly familiar story. But it should be.
Two years ago, the Pirates lost 100 or more games for a second straight season. First time that’s happened since the 1950s. Total number of losses: 201.
The Royals, meanwhile, matched their franchise-worst season with 106 losses in 2023, a two-season stretch where Kansas City dropped 203 games.
Now look.
The Royals are 75-64, in possession of the final American League wild-card spot and on pace to win 87 games. The Pirates are 64-73, 10 games out of the postseason and on pace to win 76 games, same as last season.
Read More
How did this happen?
We’ve covered plenty from a Pirates standpoint, whether that’s been poor free agent spending, lackluster fundamentals, offensive struggles, the bullpen imploding or questionable managerial decisions.
What I found fascinating was taking a deep dive into what the Royals did this offseason, which starts in a familiar place when it comes to baseball success stories: ownership spending money to improve the on-field product.
“It sucked,” Royals owner John Sherman said back in March, talking about losing 106 games. “But that’s what motivates you. Sometimes you need that slap upside the head, right?
“We don’t know what’s going to happen, but we cannot tolerate something like that again for our fans.”
’Do what you got to do’
I love the plain, relatable language and obvious emotion. But Sherman’s solution was even better: The Royals committed $110 million to eight free agents this winter, including two former Pirates in Adam Frazier and Chris Stratton.
The biggest move — though it was strategic to get there — involved the Royals bolstering their starting rotation by signing Seth Lugo (2 years, $45 million) and Michael Wacha (2 years, $32 million).
Will Smith ($5 million), a three-time World Series champion, was the bullpen addition and a catalyst of a move.
Frazier, Hunter Renfroe, Garrett Hampson and Austin Nola became bats added, though many of the Royals’ top offensive players are younger and homegrown, the opposite of how the Pirates have been able to help guys transition from Triple-A to the big leagues.
Bobby Witt Jr. is the obvious headliner, but young talent creating a young nucleus in need of support was part of why Sherman authorized the offseason spending.
Keep in mind, too, that the Royals are considered a small-market team due to their market size, in many ways (TV, population) smaller than Pittsburgh.
Sherman wasn't content with where things stood. Despite uncertainty on the TV side due to Kansas City's regional sports network (Bally Sports) going bankrupt, Sherman told the team's second-year executive vice president of baseball operations and general manager J.J. Picollo to fix the problem.
"He said go ahead and do what you got to do, which was nice to hear,” Picollo told ESPN in April. “This is his fifth season as the owner, and we haven't had good seasons. I think his desire to win was very evident, very supportive."
I do sort of get the Pirates’ side here.
They’ve grown major league payroll coming out of a rebuild while trying to use a model with a higher floor and lower ceiling, a tighter band to promote some level of competitiveness every year.
They’ve done long-term extensions with Ke’Bryan Hayes, Bryan Reynolds and Mitch Keller the past three offseasons while spending nearly $65 million in free agency the past two years; it just hasn’t been very good.
But you can’t tell me the Pirates have shown a $100-plus-million-in-five-days type of desire. It’s also not just money. There’s more to what Kansas City has done that worries me compared to what we’ve seen in Pittsburgh.
Keep the pressure on the market
• Much like actual math, the order of operations matters.
Remember this past offseason when the Pirates said they offered multi-year contracts to starting pitchers … but couldn’t get anything done? Same as I said then, it’s a two-way street.
Players have a choice. Pittsburgh, like Kansas City, wasn’t a preferred destination.
While the Pirates continued to play chicken or engage in a staring contest, the Royals went a different, smarter route. They targeted relievers first because they’d be easier to swing financially. They could be used to show starting pitchers the blueprint of how the turnaround might look.
“We wanted to show that we’re trying to improve the team,” assistant general manager Scott Sharp told MLB.com. “The way to do that was to be aggressive, try to sign players early and keep the pressure on the market.”
The Pirates, meanwhile, never pivoted off the starting pitching market. At least not until Jan. 22, when they signed Aroldis Chapman to a one-year, $10.5 million deal that represented a gigantic overpay.
In Kansas City, Picollo got the ball rolling with Smith, who helped recruit Stratton. The vision then became easier to sell to Lugo, who was also friends with Smith.
When the Marlins insisted on getting prospect Vinnie Pasquantino back for Jesus Luzardo, Picollo told Sherman they could preserve a key piece of the team by spending a little more in free agency.
Sherman was cool with it, and the Royals used the momentum generated and the proper amount of money to convince Wacha.
“I was very aware of what their vision was,” Wacha said.
Raise the expectations
But again, it's not just about the money.
The Royals traded Chapman last year for Cole Ragans, an oft-injured starter who blossomed into an All-Star with a 3.46 ERA in 28 starts and 197 strikeouts in 161 1/3 innings this year.
James McArthur was a 12th-round pick the Phillies designated for assignment. The Royals have turned him into an effective closer (18 saves). Pasquantino, an 11th-round pick in 2019, had 19 homers, 97 RBIs and a .760 OPS. Homegrown pitcher Brady Singer (5.52 to 3.36 ERA) has enjoyed a massive turnaround.
That rotation Picollo set out to fix ranks third in MLB in quality starts (67) and ERA (3.64). Kansas City’s offense has been seventh in batting average (.254) and runs (.665) and 12th in OPS (.730).
This, again, from a team that lost 106 games and scored fewer runs than the Pirates (692 to 676) last season.
The Royals also play the type of baseball the Pirates should — and need to — play.
Per Baseball Savant, the Royals lead MLB in outs above average (34) in the field. They’re fifth in FanGraphs’ calculation of defensive runs saved (45) and have made 70 errors (just 8 with fewer).
The Pirates are 25th in OAA (-19), 24th in DRS (-13) and have made 73 errors.
None of it should be acceptable, honestly.
There’s a real chance, barring something crazy, the Pirates advance just seven wins in five years, their farm system (at least based on the most recent rankings) perhaps worse than when this group took over.
The Royals, meanwhile, could more than quadruple that if the current pattern holds.
It starts at the top, and spending obviously matters. But it’s also the trickle-down effect those dollars should create, the requirement and execution of a coherent plan that simply hasn’t been good enough around here.
“If we’re going to be more demanding of our major league players, and the expectations are going to be raised, then we need to raise the expectations by putting a better roster together,” Picollo said.
“We've got to constantly be thinking about how we can improve the major league team: free agency, waiver claims, trades, anything that will allow us to be competitive. Just trying to get people to understand that there is a sense of urgency.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.