With the bases loaded and no outs in the top of the third inning, a first pitch fastball delivered from Bailey Falter would alter Saturday’s contest in a dramatic way.
Rather than serving up a hittable pitch to Mets’ cleanup hitter Pete Alonso, Falter’s offering arrived low, well beneath the zone. It was what took place after the pitch, however, that impacted the game, and possibly the remainder of the series.
As home plate umpire John Tumpane made his call behind the plate, Falter could be seen walking off the mound in obvious discomfort. The Pirates training staff quickly rushed to examine Falter and he was removed from the game. His early exit put Derek Shelton’s club in a pinch, ultimately leading to a 5-2 loss at PNC Park.
"I just obviously wanted to try to stay in the game as much as possible, just to give the bullpen a little break,” Falter said after the loss. “I noticed a little discomfort in the warmup pitches in the third. Didn't really throw too many strikes. It kind of flared up after that and I kind of just lost feel for it."
Falter was replaced by Dennis Santana, who after striking out back-to-back batters, surrendered a bases clearing double to Luis Torrens, giving the Mets a 3-0 lead. Santana threw two frames before handing the ball over to Ryder Ryan, who was recalled prior to the start of Saturday’s game due to Daulton Jefferies being placed on the 15-day IL.
Ryan allowed the Mets to score a pair of crucial runs in the top of the fifth inning, once again building their lead back up to three runs. The 29-year-old rookie did, however, deliver a bulk effort for his team, giving a career-high three innings of work.
Read More
"Yeah, I mean they did a good job,” Shelton said of his relievers. “Ryder hadn't been up three times I don't think all year, even in Indy. The fact that with where we were at, he had to give us three. And, when you lose a starter in the second or after the second, it's challenging to cover. And I thought our guys did a good job. And I think like we pointed out, we had some opportunities to score and just didn't capitalize on it."
The Pirates were presented with a few scoring chances to claw their way back into the ballgame but ultimately fell short, allowing New York to hang on for a victory. Jose Butto was the game’s winning pitcher, improving to 3-3. Edwin Diaz recorded the save, his eighth on the year.
ON THE MOUND
Falter’s injury creates a void in what has been the Pirates’ biggest strength all season: starting pitching. Rookie right-hander Jared Jones was placed on the 15-day injured list Thursday with a Grade 2 lat strain. Should Falter join Jones on the injured list, the Pirates will be tasked with filling two of their five rotation spots for their final eight games heading into the All-Star break.
“I think we'll have to figure that out depending on where we're at and what the severity is of it,” Shelton said. “I mean, we know Jared's going to be out cause he's not throwing for the next two weeks. So, I think we'll figure it out. And then the fact that we have the break coming up, too, I think is something. But we just need to figure out how we're going to get through probably the next 10 days."
Luis Ortiz will likely fill one of those rotation spots. The 25-year-old righty is slated to start Sunday afternoon for the Pirates. Quinn Priester and Marco Gonzales, who are both currently in the midst of rehab stints at Triple-A Indianapolis, serve as other viable options.
AT THE PLATE
Oneil Cruz put the Pirates on the board with a towering two-run homer off Mets’ starter David Peterson in the bottom of the fourth inning. Cruz's homer is the 77th to reach the Allegheny River in PNC Park's history. The blast marked the fifth time Cruz himself reached the river, and the fourth time this season.
The Pirates’ best chance to tie the game in the late going came in the bottom of the seventh inning, when a single from Rowdy Tellez and back-to-back walks from Andrew McCutchen and Bryan Reynolds loaded the bases with one out. Ke’Bryan Hayes connected on a ball that would have plated at least one run, but was instead robbed on a fine defensive effort by Francisco Lindor, who raced to snag a Hayes’ line drive hit up the middle for a key second out.
Following Hayes’ out, Shelton pinch-hit Jack Suwinski with hopes to take the lead on one big swing. On a 3-1 count, Suwinski correctly watched a pitch located low, outside the zone. The pitch, however, was called for a strike, leading Shelton to argue the call and eventually get ejected from the game.
Suwinski struck out the following pitch, ending the Pirates’ big opportunity. The shortcoming marked the second time in the game where the Pirates left the bases loaded, with the first time occurring in the bottom of the second inning.
"We had opportunities to score,” Shelton said. “We had the two bases-loaded situations and weren't able to capitalize on it. So yeah, that's frustrating 'cause we had an opportunity to break the game open and we just didn't get the big hit."
THEY SAID IT
"From my vantage point, I think you pretty much saw what I thought and I should probably stay away from any further comment,” Shelton said when asked about the call that led to his ejection. “You guys saw it and you saw my reaction to it. I mean, Jack never reacts. I mean, he's probably one of the calmest guys we have. So for him to react like that and then for the clock to start that quick, I don't think I was extremely happy about it as you can tell by the tone of my voice or the raspiness of my voice right now."
UP NEXT
Sunday: Pirates vs. Mets, 1:35 p.m., PNC Park.
TV, radio: SportsNet Pittsburgh, KDKA-FM (93.7)
Probable pitchers: LHP Sean Manaea (5-3, 3.67) for Mets; TBA for Pirates.
Key matchup: Jack Suwinski has swung a hot bat this homestand, going 5-for-12 with a double and two home runs in his last four games.
Hidden stat: The Pirates have hit six grand slams this year, which ranks second in all of MLB. The Brewers lead baseball with seven.
Monday: Pirates vs. Mets, 12:35 p.m.
Probable pitchers: RHP Christian Scott (0-2, 4.32) for Mets; RHP Mitch Keller (9-5, 3.48) for Pirates.
Noah Hiles: nhiles@post-gazette.com and @_NoahHiles on X





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.