For a brief moment, it truly seemed as though Derek Shelton’s club had the mighty Dodgers’ number.
After watching Bailey Falter allow the first four batters of the game to score, the Pirates came storming back, tallying a run in the bottom of the second and three more the following inning to tie the score up.
With a series victory already secured, a sweep seemed to be within grasp. That was until the fifth inning arrived. That is when a once winnable game quickly got out of hand, as the Dodgers rallied to score six runs en route to a 11-7 victory Thursday evening at PNC Park.
"It's a great lineup,” Falter, who was the game’s losing pitcher, said. “It's a good team. They win a lot of games. I just need to be a little bit better. The position players did their job really well tonight, I just need to do mine. I need to get better for them."
After locking in to throw a scoreless second, third and fourth, Falter’s day came to an end following a lead off homer from Teoscar Hernandez. Falter was then relieved by Ben Heller, who in his first outing as a Pirate, had an evening to forget.
“Too many balls in the middle of the plate,” Shelton said. “With the exception of the first night, you leave balls in the middle of the plate against this lineup, and it looked like the sweeper and the cutter just were not very effective. The sinker, I mean 96, 97, had some action to it, but the other breaking balls just too in the middle left up.”
Read More
Heller’s poor evening began by hitting Andy Pages with a cutter. Back to back hits from Miguel Rojas and Enrique Hernandez extended the Dodger lead to 6-4. After recording his first out of the inning, Los Angeles scored again on a throwing error from Henry Davis, who in an attempt to catch a runner stealing second, sailed his throw into center field.
Mookie Betts then doubled the Dodgers lead with one swing of the bat, smashing a three-run homer into the shrubbery atop the center-field fence. Heller retired the next two batters, but by then, it didn’t matter. Four-and-a-half innings remained to be played, but the game was all but over.
Los Angeles scored once more before the game came to an end, while the Pirates plated three runs in the bottom of the eighth on a home run from Oneil Cruz. Michael Grove, the first of five relievers the Dodgers used for the final six innings, was the game’s winning pitcher, improving to 3-2 on the season.
ON THE MOUND
While Jared Jones and Paul Skenes for the most part had no issue retiring the trio of MVPs atop the Dodgers lineup, Falter had no such luck in the first inning.
Mookie Betts started the game with a single. Shohei Ohtani followed with a flair to right, which was originally ruled as a catch, but overturned as a base hit upon review. Just one pitch after the call was changed, the Dodgers took a 3-0 lead on a three-run homer from Freddie Freeman.
"I just wasn't executing pitches,” Falter said. “That's all it was."
Hernandez followed the big fly with a double, and came around to score, making it 4-0 before the Pirates came to the plate. But after escaping the disastrous first inning, Falter, for the next three frames, returned to his old self.
The 27-year-old lefty battled to retire Betts, Ohtani and Freeman in order in the top of the second, striking out the latter two. Los Angeles put runners on in the third and the fourth, but twice more, Falter put up a zero.
“He did kind of bounce back and readjusted his sight,” Shelton said. “That’s a challenging lineup with all the right-handers.”
Hernandez’s homer to lead off the fifth was enough for Shelton to end Falter’s day. The outing is just the second time he failed to go at least five innings, with the other being his first start of the season.
“I've had some rough first innings in the past,” Falter said. “I just gotta find a way to limit that damage and get these guys back in there as soon as possible."
AT THE PLATE
Perhaps the silver lining the Pirates took from Thursday’s blowout defeat was a strong day at the plate from both Ke’Bryan Hayes and Nick Gonzales. Hayes ended the night 3-for-5 with three singles, a stolen base and a run scored.
Gonzales, meanwhile, had the Pirates’ biggest hit of the day, sending a letter-high 1-2 fastball from Dodgers’ starter Walker Buehler over the left-field wall for a two-run homer that tied the game 4-4 in the bottom of the fourth inning. Gonzales notched one more hit before the game ended, finishing his day 2-for-5.
“The one at-bat, he had to grind through,” Shelton said. “I think he fouled off five or six pitches and just kept going. I think we keep seeing Nick get better which is really encouraging.”
As for Cruz’s homer, the blast came on a 2-1 sweeper left over the middle of the plate by Dodgers’ reliever Evan Phillips. Cruz connected on the pitch, smashing it 462 feet to right-center field, exiting the ballpark at 117.7 mph. The ball reached the Allegheny River on a few hops.
“I thought the base hit he hit to left earlier and then the swing off Phillips there,” Shelton said. “Better at-bats tonight from him.”
THEY SAID IT
Following the overturned call on Ohtani’s first inning single, Shelton had a discussion with the umpires about the result.
“The explanation is once it goes to replay it’s their call,” Shelton said. “My question on I felt Mookie was moving back before the call was made and replay would adjust the runners and they didn’t see it that way.”
UP NEXT
Friday: Pirates vs. Twins, 6:40 p.m., PNC Park.
TV, radio: Apple TV+, KDKA-FM (93.7 The Fan)
Probable pitchers: RHP Joe Ryan (4-4, 3.38) for Twins; RHP Mitch Keller (7-3, 3.42) for Pirates
Key matchup: Keller struck out 12 batters in six innings in his lone career start against the Twins.
Hidden stat: The Pirates are now 9-19 in games where their opponents score first.
Saturday: Pirates vs. Twins, 4:05 p.m., PNC Park.
Probable pitchers: RHP Simeon Woods-Richardson (2-0, 3.05) for Twins; TBA for Pirates
Noah Hiles: nhiles@post-gazette.com and @_NoahHiles on X






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.