Welcome to the Pirates mailbag, where the Post-Gazette reporters Andrew Destin and Noah Hiles answer all of your questions about the ball club. If you have a question, tweet them at @AndrewDestin1 and @_Noahhiles or email them at adestin@post-gazette.com and nhiles@post-gazette.com. Andrew and Noah will answer your questions in full length each Thursday. Below are this week’s top questions.
M.E.: When does Matt Gorski get a look?
Destin: The issue here is fairly straightforward, and it’s that Gorski is not on the 40-man roster. To add him, in my opinion, would mean parting ways with an outfielder, and the prime candidate there is Joshua Palacios, who is currently rehabbing in the minors and has yet to play in MLB this season. Even though Palacios’ season has been derailed by injury and he didn’t crack a spot on the opening day roster, I have to imagine what he demonstrated last season as a left-handed spark plug off the bench still holds value for the Pirates. Let’s revisit this conversation when Palacios — and Ji Hwan Bae, for that matter — is healthy.
Hiles: I think we see him at some point this year, but I don’t believe getting him to the majors is the Pirates’ top priority. Gorski is putting up strong power numbers, but it would be fair to assume that production will dip off at least a little bit in the big leagues. I think he should have been called up this week ahead of Suwinski, who still needs more time to fix his struggles at the plate, but the fact that he wasn’t shows where Gorski stands within the organization. If I had to guess a timeline, I would go with September.
Penn: At this point, what is the path, if there even is a path, for Jake Lamb to get onto the Pirates roster? On the topic of Tellez, do we think he's truly out of the year-long slump? Or was Game three in Toronto a fluke?
Destin: I was adamant for a while that a path for Jake Lamb was quite unlikely, and I don’t think much has changed. The Pirates would like to avoid a sunk cost when it comes to Rowdy Tellez — they’re paying him $3.2 million, and designating him for assignment feels like a worst-case scenario. If Tellez can start to figure it out after the Blue Jays series, that would be as impactful an addition to the Pirates lineup as anybody they can trade for. And perhaps even better considering how well Connor Joe has played, Tellez could hypothetically be flipped for a low-level prospect, or at the very least cash considerations to offset how much the Pirates are on the hook for.
Read More
Hiles: I’m starting to think the Jake Lamb hype train is coming to an end. He is still at just three home runs in Triple-A and is hitting only .233 in his last 21 games. I’m still not convinced he would be worse than Rowdy, but at this point, they’d probably be better off finding a replacement outside the organization. As far as Rowdy is concerned, I was impressed with how he looked Sunday. That’s the most comfortable I’ve seen him in a batters box this year. However, it was one game. I need to see a lot more, soon, in order to believe he will be “back.”
Mols: What does Andy Haines actually teach or do specifically? Each player has their own style/stance, so what does he help with?
Destin: From my conversations with various individuals in the organization, Haines’ role is to oversee the operation. For instance, integrated baseball coach Jonny Walker was working very closely with Michael A. Taylor before he went on the paternity list to try to get the outfielder in a better place to hit. That’s not to say there isn’t guidance from Haines, but more so that he’s delegating work. As it pertains to each player having their own style/stance, Haines and the coaching staff are constantly evaluating whether players need to make “quick fixes” or “longer-term fixes.” Sometimes it’s as simple as tweaking one’s setup, other times it’s building the swing back up a little bit more from scratch.
Hiles: While we unfortunately don’t have access to every second of training and instruction within the Pirates clubhouse, I can assure you Haines does plenty of work. I think a large part of his job is developing a strategy based on the data he receives on the upcoming opposing pitchers. Each matchup comes with its own game plan. In addition to working with individual players to fix mechanical errors, he is also responsible for ensuring the entire team knows what is coming when they step into the box.
Ed: How embarrassing is it to the Pirates organization for having one of its players gambling on baseball? And what’s worse, gambling on baseball or being 10 for 231 with those bets?
Destin: I’d like to take this conversation and extrapolate it to being embarrassing for MLB. It’s a shame that not only Tucupita Marcano, but four other players affiliated with MLB clubs got caught up in this to varying degrees. Marcano is certainly the most egregious example, considering he is banned for life, but this is not a great look for the league. I am all in favor of legalized sports betting — regulating the vices of society, in my opinion, is a good thing. However, that comes with some inherent risks. If we think Marcano and the four other players mark the end of sports betting from professional athletes, I’d say we’re lying to ourselves.
Hiles: I’d argue it’s a bad look on the individual, not the organization. I will happily hold the Pirates accountable whenever they are in the wrong, but what could they have done to prevent this? Take Marcano’s phone? Track every second of his life? The Pirates made the rule clear to every player in the organization. They did their part of this. You can’t blame them for one of their players deciding to break the law. As for Marcano’s gambling record ... let's just say it makes me feel a bit better about how things went for me last NFL season. I seriously hope the young man gets the help he needs.
Zach: On Friday, Triolo ran on a ground ball hit in front of him at 2nd base when he wasn't forced and proceeded to get tagged out. Obviously, this is a big mistake. Immediately after the play, the camera panned to Shelton and he had the same blank expression he always has. If that was any other level of baseball that coach would have been screaming/benched his player etc. Why does this not happen in the Major League? Is there a player association policy that you aren't allowed to scold players. Are they scolded in the clubhouse after the game? Why do you very rarely see a manager talk to players at all, during a game?
Hiles: The main reason is because these are grown men. The relationship dynamic between player and coach is different at the professional level. There is still a hierarchy, but it’s unlike what exists in high school, college and even the minor leagues. These are people who are paid big money to play baseball. They know when they mess up. They also know they’re on camera from the very beginning to the very end of the game. Any sort of yelling in the dugout will be all over social media, which opens a different can of worms. I am sure there are times Shelton expresses frustration, but he’s not a fool. He knows when and where to do it.
Destin: Not many notes to add here to Noah’s points. The days of managers chewing out players publicly, or really in any scenario, have long since passed for obvious reasons. The players make much more money than they did decades ago, and cameras are everywhere. Also, it’s worth noting in the Triolo example that it came in the 14th inning, and he was a late-game substitution. The Pirates’ bench was pretty thin by that juncture, so even if Shelton wanted to bench Triolo, it’s not like the manager had many options.
Robbie: What is your all-time favorite view from a seat where you've made a "I suppose this seat will do" tweet? (This question was for Noah, but Andrew can answer it, too).
Destin: Kudos to Noah for this ritual, and prompting a question that really hits home for me. My father chose a comfortable career in corporate finance, which afforded me a simply wonderful childhood growing up in the Bay Area. I’m eternally grateful for the career paths both he and my mother took in working at Hewlett-Packard for as long as they did. But my dad adores sports, specifically baseball, unlike anybody I’ve ever been around — players, coaches and reporters alike. He encouraged me to do what he didn’t, and that’s pursue a passion and make a career out of it. For me, that meant going into sportswriting, something my dad would have loved to do. So my answer is obvious: the view from Oracle Park when I went back home at the end of April to cover Giants-Pirates games. Many family members and friends were there, but perhaps none more important than my dad, who was born in San Francisco the same year the Giants came to town in 1958. Seeing him take photos of me writing, cheering me on and texting me throughout— yeah, that’s a feeling I will never forget.
Hiles: Man, that’s a fun question. My favorite view will always be my seat at PNC Park. I knew I wanted to work in sports media since middle school. I remember going to Pirates games in high school, pointing to the press box and telling my friends, “I’ll be watching games up there one day.” I originally wanted to be an announcer, the next Greg Brown. But writing ended up being my lane into the industry. I started the “I suppose this seat will do,” trend when I was covering high school sports for the Beaver County Times. I just wanted to show my followers that I was excited to be there, covering the game. This is a fun job and I hope to never lose sight of that. From “The Pit” in Aliquippa, to Notre Dame Stadium, to March Madness, to the many amazing parks throughout MLB, it’s really cool to look back on all the amazing seats I’ve had for a work day.
Thank you all for following along! Please subscribe to our FREE daily all-sports newsletter and YouTube channel: @PGSportsNow.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.