Austin Hedges

There’s been plenty written and said about what Austin Hedges can’t do since news of the 30-year-old catcher signing with the Pirates broke on Saturday night.

How he hit just .163 last season and had a .489 OPS, worst among the 277 MLB hitters who logged 300 or more plate appearances. Or Hedges’ career wRC+ of 54 (100 is average) since making his MLB debut in 2015 ranking last among the 242 men with 2,000 or more trips to the plate during that time.

Yeah, not great. Signing Hedges for $5 million has provided a full basket of low-hanging fruit for Pirates fans because the facts are there, and it’s not pretty. But there are probably a couple of realities worth combatting at this point.

One, no matter who the Pirates signed to catch, the offense juiced out of that position was never going to have a huge effect on the overall product. Seriously, would Tucker Barnhart or Roberto Perez have been better? Until the Pirates fix this, top-tier guys will always have better options.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, the area where the Pirates do legitimately need help involves mentoring young players, making the best out of what they have and creating a culture that includes heightened expectations.

In other words, so what if Hedges doesn’t hit? It’ll matter much more if he does what he talked about doing during an introductory session Tuesday at PNC Park — handling a pitching staff the way he did last season in Cleveland and also serving as a mentor to young backstops Henry Davis and Endy Rodriguez.

“If I can help them be who they are and stay who they are from the get-go, I’m really looking forward to that being part of my job,” Hedges said.

Finding a way to figure this out is something Hedges discussed a lot on Tuesday, from his decision to sign with the Pirates, how Pittsburgh reminds him of what he experienced with a young Guardians group that broke out in 2022 and how impressed he’s already been with the pitching staff. Hedges also talked about his offense and how he genuinely feels like there’s more to offer.

When it comes to signing with the Pirates, surely the contract and path to playing time didn’t hurt. He also has a connection here. His mom, Pam Opar, grew up in Upper St. Clair. Hedges remembers about a 20-year stretch where he’d visit Pittsburgh once a year, stay with his uncle and attend Pirates games with his grandfather.

Advertise with us

Jason Bay, Francisco Liriano and Russell Martin were some of his favorites. A San Diego, Calif., native, Hedges said he loved how much the city bonded over its sports teams.

“To be able to call [PNC Park] home now, it’s really special,” he said.

But this is obviously about much more than returning to familiar digs. In Cleveland, the young Guardians enjoyed a boatload of MLB debuts last season and rode a young and talented pitching staff to the postseason.

A big reason was because Terry Francona’s bunch learned its identity early and built on it. From Hedges’ perspective, the foundational steps toward that breakout happened in 2021, and he believes he’s walking into a situation where the Pirates experienced similar things in 2022.

“What Cleveland did last year with a young staff and getting to the playoffs, I see no reason why Pittsburgh can’t be that club this year,” Hedges said.

Advertise with us

Early impressions of the Pirates pitching staff have been very good for Hedges, who also leads all catchers in defensive runs saved since his debut season with 75.

“I like the pitch characteristics,” Hedges said. “I know the arm talent is there. Now, with some game-calling philosophy and trusting one another and disregarding the hitter a little bit, I think it will help get guys to the next level.”

Once again, look past the (lack of) offense. The Pirates need Hedges to make the pitching staff better, the way Roberto Perez did for a short stretch last year. They also need him to stay healthy, which Perez — a teammate of Hedges and close friend in Cleveland — wasn’t able to do.

The easy part with Hedges is he clearly gets it. His personality feels a little like Michael Chavis’ in that he’s high energy and affable. He’s also cognizant of separating his hitting struggles from how he carries himself, arguing a positive attitude will rub off on his teammates and set an important tone in the clubhouse.

That matters for the Pirates. So does study and preparation, another of Hedges’ strong suits.

Advertise with us

For while it would be great if he hits — he went to Driveline this offseason and will visit Titleist Performance Institute in Oceanside, Calif., next year for help — it’s not essential. The best thing Hedges can do for the Pirates is be himself.

The one who has experienced failure in the major leagues and found a way to stick around. The guy who’s good friends with Joe Musgrove and Gerrit Cole and knows how good pitching looks. The guy who has the positivity and perspective to endure the criticism he’s already faced due to his lack of offense.

“I’ve always taken pride in being a leader,” Hedges said. “As a leader, you have to do a little bit of teaching. The only way to be a good leader is hold yourself accountable to what you know you have to learn at, and the only way to really learn is to fail.

“I’ve failed a lot in the big leagues. I’ve hit under .200 multiple years, and that’s not easy. But if I can show up and be the same guy every day, that has a positive reaction on my teammates.

“I know you don’t just learn the big leagues immediately. If I can help speed that up, it’s a passion of mine that will carry on even when I’m done playing.”

Advertise with us

Castillo DFA'd

To make room for Hedges on the 40-man roster, the Pirates designated Diego Castillo for assignment. Castillo, acquired along with Hoy Park in the Clay Holmes trade, hit .206 with a .633 OPS in 96 games this past season while making his MLB debut.

After a torrid spring, he had 13 doubles, 11 home runs, 29 RBIs and 28 runs scored while playing shortstop, second base, right field, first base, third base and even pitching a couple times.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.