This story was updated on Saturday, Dec. 17, 2022, at 8:50 p.m.

RALEIGH, N.C. — Same former team. Same profile, too. But the Pirates seem to be hoping Austin Hedges will produce a different result than Roberto Perez last season.

Nothing against Perez, a two-time Gold Glove winner who quickly gained the trust and respect of Pittsburgh’s pitching staff, but he’s played in just 51 games over the past three seasons, including 21 in 2022.

Seeking defense and more certainty than Perez provided, and perhaps willing to sacrifice on the offensive end, the Pirates on Saturday again dipped into free agency by signing Hedges to a one-year deal worth $5 million, multiple sources confirmed to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.

Advertise with us

Hedges, 30, was traded to Cleveland in August 2020 and caught 192 games for the Guardians the past two seasons, eventually snatching the starting job from the oft-injured Perez, who won a pair of Gold Gloves in Cleveland.

The Pirates’ move to sign Hedges ultimately prioritizes defense, pitch-framing and the handling of a pitching staff over offense, an area where the 2011 Padres second-round pick has certainly struggled.

Hedges produced a .163/.241/.248 slash line last season, contributing seven home runs and 30 RBIs in 338 plate appearances. His wRC+ (100 is average) sat at 42, the fourth consecutive season it was 49 or worse.

When it comes to OPS, nobody fared worse than Hedges (.489) among hitters who logged at least 300 plate appearances last season, while he’s a career .189 hitter who has a .578 OPS over eight MLB seasons.

The clear reason the Pirates signed Hedges is … well, everything else.

Advertise with us

Since making his MLB debut in 2015, nobody has more defensive runs saved than Hedges (75), according to FanGraphs. That includes eight last season, which ranked eighth among all catchers. It was more than twice as many as Perez (3).

Pitch-framing has been one area where Hedges has really excelled. He accounted for 4.4 framing runs saved in 2022, per FanGraphs, which was 17th among catchers. When looking at the history of the stat, only 13 catchers have punched up more framing runs than Hedges (64.7), who ranks seventh all-time among catchers in DRS.

Hedges threw out 22% of runners trying to steal against him in 2022, which was actually a relatively down year for him. He’s been at 33% better in five of his eight major league seasons.

With Hedges in the fold, the Pirates’ succession plan at the position becomes a little more clear. He will catch most days and will probably wind up paired with someone like Jason Delay or Tyler Heineman, familiar names who are expected to battle it out for the backup job during spring training.

Meanwhile, the focal points are Endy Rodriguez and Henry Davis, top prospects who should begin the season at Triple-A. If one or both enjoy strong starts, the Pirates will be forced into a decision.

Advertise with us

They could and probably will promote one.

If that player is defensively capable, they can easily swap out Delay or Heineman and pair the youngster with Hedges, who should have plenty to share when it comes to the defensive side of the game and handling a pitching staff.

That strategy was also in play with Perez, who was terrific early on, then tore his hamstring in early May. The Pirates had maintained interest in bringing back Perez, perhaps on a deal that would come in under what Hedges was paid, but it would’ve also brought with it less certainty.

The Pirates wanted to see Perez play winter ball and demonstrate he was healthy, although to this point, that had not happened. Whether that’s independent of the Pirates’ interest in Hedges really doesn’t matter at this point.

Needing someone to guide a young pitching staff and clearly preferring defense over offense, at least behind the plate, the Pirates signed someone who, if nothing else, isn’t a liability back there.

Advertise with us

The wildest stat on Hedges might be this: He’s allowed just 18 passed balls in his career, including three over the past two seasons. That’s really good.

If the Pirates could get anything close to what Hedges did at the plate in 2017, when he hit .215 with 17 doubles, 18 home runs and 55 RBIs while catching a career-high 120 games with San Diego, it could actually be a decent fit.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.