Those following the business of baseball would tell you that the hard part is over. A new collective bargaining agreement has been reached, and spring training workouts — at long last — start this week. But as Pirates fans know all too well, the roughest ride is probably only starting.
Many questions frame the Pirates’ biggest issues coming out of the MLB lockout, from how to fix a wobbly starting rotation in 2021 to injecting life into an offense that has been the sport’s worst by far over the past two seasons.
So, without further delay — because we’ve had enough of that already — let’s examine five of the most important questions the Pirates will face.
Flurry of activity
Baseball enjoyed an avalanche of roster moves before the expiration of the previous CBA, and the same sort of increased activity is expected during this 72-hour window before on-field workouts start.
The Pirates obviously aren’t signing Carlos Correa, Kris Bryant or Freddie Freeman, three of the top free agents remaining. But they shouldn’t be sitting on their hands, either.
Read More
Chris Stratton and Kevin Newman are two logical trade candidates, if the Pirates decide to go that route.
Stratton appeared in a career-high 68 games and ranked sixth among all MLB relievers with 79⅓ innings pitched in 2021. He also led the Pirates in wins (7), converted seven of eight saves and had a 3.63 ERA while striking out more than a batter per inning.
It’s not sexy, but it could fetch something.
As for Newman, the Gold Glove finalist showed he can add value with the glove; his .993 fielding percentage led all MLB shortstops and was the second-best for someone at his position in National League history.
Newman will make $1.95 million and plays a position where either Oneil Cruz or Liover Peguero is clearly the future. If a reasonable deal comes along, the Pirates would be wise to take it.
Areas to add
While general manager Ben Cherington won’t be shopping at Bloomingdales — or Walmart or Target, for that matter — there are certain areas where he should, and will, look to add.
The three biggest are pitching, outfield depth and perhaps a backup catcher to complement Roberto Perez … and probably play a little more than a normal No. 2 given Perez’s recent shoulder issues.
As of now, Perez is the only catcher on the 40-man roster. The Pirates’ next-best option is Michael Perez, who hit just .143, struck out nearly 30% of the time and was worth -1 Defensive Run Saved per Fangraphs; only 11 NL backstops fared worse. Behind Perez is probably Jamie Ritchie, a 28-year-old career minor leaguer.
Aside from catching depth, the Pirates would be wise to gird themselves pitching-wise against another non-traditional spring training, where innings counts will be monitored closely and traditional starters — at least in Pittsburgh — are hardly used.
Steven Brault and Chad Kuhl are two pitchers the Pirates non-tendered last year. Might be a stretch to bring either back, but if they accepted minor league deals, maybe. It could also make sense to stage a Tyler Anderson reunion or add someone like Brett Anderson or Mike Foltynewicz — guys with something to prove who need an opportunity.
The Pirates had pre-lockout interest in a Richard Rodriguez return and that, too, would make sense; their bullpen is very much in need of reinforcements.
Offensive uptick?
The biggest move for the Pirates this offseason was bringing in Andy Haines as hitting coach, hiring the 44-year-old after he was let go by the Brewers at season’s end.
Haines’ tenure in Milwaukee did not end well, but did have success in his first season there, when the Brewers hit a franchise-record 250 homers (seventh in MLB) and posted a .767 OPS (12th) in 2019.
Manager Derek Shelton’s team could use a similar injection of life and power.
As of now, the Pirates figure to rely on Bryan Reynolds, Yoshi Tsutsugo and a bunch of question marks.
Although Roberto Perez hit 24 home runs in 2019, he hasn’t hit his weight the past two years (.165 and .149) while posting the two highest strikeout rates of his career (34.8% and 34.5%).
Infielder Michael Chavis looked good in a small sample size before he got hurt. The same could be said of Ke’Bryan Hayes dating back to his September 2020 mixed with a hand/wrist issue that persisted and zapped much of his pull-side pop.
Cruz certainly teased in his 2021 cameo, although it was just two games and the Pirates clearly aren’t paying Newman nearly $2 million to sit.
Who plays right field?
Once spring workouts start, this might be the most intriguing battle to watch aside from who nails down spots in the starting rotation.
With Gregory Polanco gone, the three contestants — for now — are Anthony Alford, Greg Allen and Cole Tucker, with Cruz transitioning there a long-shot possibility depending on how ready he is for regular work.
Alford had stretches and bursts of power where he looked like a five-tool regular who probably profiles better in left (pushing Ben Gamel to right). There were also times — like when Alford went hitless in his first 19 at-bats with 15 strikeouts — where he looked lost, his confidence clearly lacking.
Tucker, too. Offense has remained elusive for much of his career … until a 16-game stretch at the end of 2021 where he seemed to figure something out and hit .308. Related: The Pirates need a leadoff man with some position versatility, and Tucker fits that bill. He’s also a lifetime .270 hitter (.799 OPS) while batting first.
Allen is a speedy outfielder with 236 games of MLB experience, including a .257 average and 21 steals in 91 games for the Guardians in 2018. A switch-hitter, Allen thrived at Class AAA (Yankees) last year and hit .326 in 73 games before getting another MLB shot, responding with a .270 average, .849 OPS and five more steals in 15 games.
Could Allen thrive with regular work? Is Alford truly the five-tool guy we saw glimpses of in 2021? Is this the year Tucker legitimately looks like a first-round pick? We’ll find out.
It all comes down to …
Yep, you guessed it: pitching. Same as it ever was in baseball. And that could be a scary proposition for the Pirates. For while Cruz, Reynolds, Hayes, Tsutsugo or Roberto Perez might turn out to be fine, the starting rotation comes with questions.
A lot of them.
Like the should-be ace, Mitch Keller, spending time in the minors last year and producing a 6.17 ERA, part of a 6.02 career ERA over 39 starts. JT Brubaker led the group in innings (124⅓) and strikeouts (129) a year ago but also coughed up 28 home runs — only two NL pitchers allowed more — while sporting a 5.36 ERA.
Wil Crowe took the ball every time, but the Pirates need more than his 5.48 ERA.
Pittsburgh must hope these three are challenged by a second cut featuring Roansy Contreras, Bryse Wilson, Max Kranick, Miguel Yajure, Dillon Peters and Zach Thompson, who was acquired from the Marlins in the Jacob Stallings trade.
Oh, and Jose Quintana — who had a 6.43 ERA in 29 games (10 starts) with the Angels and Giants last season — could take the ball on Opening Day in St. Louis. Meaning the Pirates should probably say extra prayers that they get the 2010s Chicago version of the veteran lefty.
Bottom line, the starting rotation is a crapshoot right now and a spot the Pirates would be wise to address via free agency. Also look for Shelton to keep starts short, play matchups and cobble together a group of guys capable of throwing three or four innings at a clip.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.