Clichés exist for a reason — typically because they’re true. Around the Pirates, it’s less of a cliché and more of a frustrating narrative, but the song remains the same. As good as gone? More like if he’s good he’s gone.
There are several reasons why the Pirates seem to always trade productive players, and they’ve been far too frequently connected to finances. On the flip side, it’s also something fans of a small-market team should probably accept, at least to some degree, where MLB’s drunken financial structure requires non-rich teams to mortgage their highest-paid players like hotels in Monopoly.
Unfortunately for the Pirates and their fans, that game has lasted longer than anyone would like, the result of years of rebuilding and stalled five-year plans.
With a new group in charge and an ongoing, full-scale rebuild that cuts deeper than anything Pirates fans have seen in years, some familiar questions have surfaced over the past few days thanks to general manager Ben Cherington sending Jacob Stallings to the Marlins for three prospects.
What has to happen for the Pirates to actually keep their best players?
There’s no perfect answer, mind you. It's also hard to rip the Pirates for moving Adam Frazier when his stock was sky high; getting five prospects for Joe Musgrove, including the Low-A Southeast League Player of the Year (Endy Rodriguez), future closer David Bednar and possibly more; Roansy Contreras, Miguel Yajure and two more ranked prospects for Jameson Taillon; plus two rostered players (Hoy Park and Diego Castillo) for Clay Holmes.
Read More
Aside from the Josh Bell trade, which looks bad right now, the Pirates turned replaceable, higher-earning assets into three times as many prospects shortly before those older players would've reached free agency, at which point they almost assuredly would've pursued a more competitive situation.
“We need lots of good players,” Cherington said. “When we make trades, it’s because we see an opportunity to get more players and potentially more good players.
“But if we already have players performing at that level and have a chance to be here when we believe we can win, we’re going to be pretty motivated to hold onto those guys.”
Timing here is big. Without explicitly using this term, Cherington made several references to the Pirates’ competitive window opening and seemed to say it’s barely cracked at this point; when someone can feel an actual breeze — other than from a player’s swing — then things will finally change.
This happening now — again, timing — seemed to irritate fans because it felt forced. Cherington really traded Stallings without another catcher on the 40-man roster? Yep, although the Pirates are hoping Roberto Perez can rediscover his 2018-19 Cleveland form and keep it.
But what if he gets hurt? Their current backups are Michael Perez and Jamie Ritchie. Sounds like two 80s rock stars. Secondarily, it's highly unlikely Henry Davis will be ready in 2022, meaning they’ll need to sign someone next offseason and hope the 2021 top overall pick replaces him at some point during the season.
There’s also an element here that has nothing to do with batting average, OPS or WAR. Something unquantifiable.
The Pirates, like all pro sports teams, are an entertainment entity. Fans support their existence. Regardless of whether something makes sense on paper, the consumer’s voice should matter. And those folks are flat-out sick of seeing good players traded. Either stop doing it, win or (preferably) both.
On a positive note, it was interesting to hear Cherington discuss this stuff from a broader perspective. How trades change shape once winning starts. How getting there in a sustainable way can prevent the valleys from getting too deep.
And how it’s ideal to have your best player working toward that goal.
"If you look at teams around the league that might be in similar markets that are succeeding right now, that are winning at a strong level at the major league level, they’re still making trades,” Cherington said. “But the calculus behind those trades might change over time. I would expect that would happen to us, too.
"We’re spending every ounce of energy that we can to get to winning as fast as we possibly can. It’s certainly going to be a lot easier to do that with Bryan Reynolds on the team."
The Pirates should certainly hope so, if they want fans to trust them and believe things are going to be different, which is why trading Stallings wasn't necessarily about replacing stats.
Thanks to his dad, Stallings was known in Pittsburgh before he ever played a game at PNC Park. His story of twice being designated for assignment yet working his butt off to stick around and win a Gold Glove resonated with fans. For a franchise that loves talking about club culture, he was a walking, talking example of what his teammates should aspire to be.
And just like that, a few months after a draft that seemed to spur confidence in this entire process, after a season in which development was both changed and celebrated, that same stone in the shoe surfaced.
What has to happen for the Pirates to actually keep their best players?
While discussing how other small-market teams are forced to function, Cherington bought up another interesting point in that the three he cited — Tampa, Cleveland and Oakland — all endured prolonged periods of struggle before implementing processes that prevented the type of backslide the Pirates experienced after 2015.
By drafting and developing, sure, but also by winning the inevitable veteran-for-prospects deals that sunk the former regime. Which means for the Pirates to keep their best players, they need not make stupid trades when it involves some of the really good ones.
“Those franchises might have smaller dips or downturns, but once they established that base, they've been able to make decisions they give them a chance to sustain that over time,” Cherington said. “That's what we want to do. We want to get to winning and we want to figure out a way to sustain that."
Cherington is right. It would be a real shame to hear in two years why it made sense to send Reynolds or Ke'Bryan Hayes to Miami.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.