Let’s not overcook this one: The Pirates had exactly one catcher on their 40-man roster Monday morning, and the day ended with them trading that guy, Jacob Stallings, to the Miami Marlins for three prospects.

Although the Pirates drafted Henry Davis first overall this past summer, they really don’t have anyone capable of replacing Stallings in any meaningful way for 2022.

Michael Perez is the best available option, assuming he doesn’t refuse his minor league assignment, and it’s hard to see that inspiring confidence. Perez hit .143 and was 33rd among the 47 catchers who logged at least 400 innings in 2021 at -1 Defensive Runs Saved (DRS), per FanGraphs.

Seriously, who the heck is gonna catch?

Advertise with us

The Pirates can go a couple of routes here, and it should be noted that this isn’t a particularly good year to snag a catcher in free agency, which could be one of the reasons why Stallings attracted the interest that he did.

It’s also tough to think general manager Ben Cherington was willing to part with Stallings without some sort of backup plan in the works.

OK, some names

The top catcher available was Yan Gomes, who spent last season with Oakland and Washington and hit .252 with a .722 OPS, 14 home runs and 52 RBIs in 2021. Only 11 catchers were worth more DRS, among the 400-innings-and-over crowd, while the 34-year-old slashed .252/.311/.426 over the past four years and threw out 31% of runners in 2021.

Unfortunately for the Pirates, he’s headed to the Cubs on a two-year, $13 million deal.

Advertise with us

Here’s an intriguing (and much more realistic) option: Roberto Perez, formerly of the Guardians. After Cleveland decided against picking up his $7 million option, Perez became a free agent.

The recent production has been terrible, mind you. He hit .149 and .165 the past two years, plus an OPS of .564 and .480. Perez has also dealt with multiple shoulder injuries and has struggled to get and stay healthy.

But two years ago, Perez played 119 games, socked 24 home runs, had 63 RBIs, hit .239 and produced a .774 OPS. That was the first of two back-to-back Gold Glove years for him.

It seems all Perez needs is an opportunity. If he’s indeed healthy, might be worth the risk.

The other options, well, wouldn’t call ‘em great. Robinson Chirinos had a three-year stretch from 2017-19 where he hit a total of 52 homers and his OPS didn’t dip below .757. Yet he’s also now 37, which could obviously be problematic.

Advertise with us

Luke Maile is out there, for anyone feeling nostalgic about 2020. He was slated to be Stallings’ backup before a fractured right index finger ended his season before it started. A defense-first veteran who put up a 2.1 WAR with Toronto in 2018, Maile played 15 games with the Brewers last season and hit .300 with an .816 OPS.

The sample size is tiny, but so is the list of options here.

Austin Romine? Perhaps. He did hit .244 with a .713 OPS in 77 games in 2018 with the Yankees, then followed it up with .281/.748 in 72 games the next season. But Romine has largely disappointed the past two seasons while playing for the Tigers and Cubs.

Perhaps Pirates can execute a trade or sign someone who has been designated for assignment or non-tendered. They could also seek out a catcher in the Rule 5 draft, as a couple of intriguing ones are available.

The Rays have four on their 40-man roster, making No. 15 prospect Blake Hunt expendable. Hunt, who arrived in Tampa in the Blake Snell trade, defends well but wouldn’t appear to be capable of adding much offensively, having hit just .205 with nine homers in 76 games at High-A and Class AA this past season.

Advertise with us

The Yankees are exposing their No. 18 prospect, Josh Breaux, a backstop who requires some defensive polish but hit .249 with 23 home runs in 90 games this past season at High-A and Class AA.

And Houston isn’t protecting Yainer Diaz, its 13th-best prospect, after he hit .324 with 17 home runs and 90 RBIs in 98 minor leagues games this past season, finishing at High-A.

Again, the Rule 5 thing would be weird. But perhaps the Pirates actually sign a catcher and pair him with a Rule 5 selection. We’ll see. Anything is better than the current option of making Cole Tucker or Hoy Park do it.

Why now?

Because the Pirates drafted Davis, pretty much everyone expected Pittsburgh to turn the page on Stallings at some point. Just not yet.

Advertise with us

It also wasn’t an overwhelming return. Had Cherington netted a top 100 prospect or anything even remotely close, maybe it would’ve made sense to trade your Gold Glove-winning catcher now, when you literally have no one else on the 40-man roster to replace him.

Cherington was not available to media Monday but is expected to talk at some point Tuesday. It’ll be interesting to hear what he has to say about the timeline on the Stallings deal and why he felt he had to move right now.

Who’s next?

Lost in a crazy Monday is the fact that we’re inching closer to the non-tender deadline, and the Pirates have two candidates remaining.

Chad Kuhl and Kevin Newman are eligible for arbitration and projected to make more than $5 million. Given what else the Pirates have done, it’s hard to see either one getting tendered a contract for 2022.

Advertise with us

It’s also difficult — if they couldn’t move Colin Moran or Steven Brault — to see the Pirates executing a trade with Kuhl or Newman. Kuhl will surface somewhere, and Newman could easily have a long career as a reliable glove man up the middle. But Pittsburgh’s recent business decisions simply suggest those two will be goners.

Veteran leadership? Anyone?

Stallings was hardly the rah-rah type. Brault sort of was, but more in a fun way. Moran made statues seem lively and libraries feel like rock concerts.

The point: The Pirates have very few players with any miles on the tires. Seriously, if they non-tender Newman and Kuhl, Bryan Reynolds and Cole Tucker — yes, seriously — would become their longest-tenured players. Others are older, but we’re talking strictly in Pittsburgh.

No matter what else happens, someone will have to assume and grow into that role.

Advertise with us

How about fan faith?

Had Cherington simply non-tendered Moran, Newman, Kuhl and Brault and said he didn’t believe the Pirates had to pay more than $11 million to get that level of production, it’s hard to imagine anyone would throw a fit. (He likely wouldn’t be wrong.)

It also seems like fans are on board with the built-it-from-the-bottom stuff that we’ve seen lately, the 2021 MLB draft, the increased importance placed on prospects and development. Could be wrong, but fans seem genuinely excited to watch Oneil Cruz, Roansy Contreras and anyone else who might earn a promotion.

The Stallings move makes you scratch your head. Nothing against the three players the Pirates got back, but that’s the return Cherington felt so moved to pursue? Meanwhile, the Pirates’ rail-thin pitching staff lost its safety blanket, a player whose value was immensely proven every time Perez squatted behind home plate.

Trading Stallings in no way makes the Pirates better for 2022, and it will be tough to convince fans to pay major league prices after the mass exodus of major league players cast aside in favor of hope. Winning will cure it, but that’s … well, not terribly likely in 2022.

Advertise with us

Bottom line, it’s hard to blame fans for running with the Pirates-don’t-pay-their-players narrative when a guy wins a Gold Glove, blossoms into one of the team’s most respected players, earns a bit of a raise and is promptly shipped out of town, especially when we’re talking about someone as likable as Stallings.

If there’s someone who’s ready, fine. Fans need to get over that. That’s why it’ll be interesting to see if Cherington has something else up his sleeve that would explain why he was willing to part with Stallings.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG