DENVER — When Ben Cherington took over as general manager, he did not inherit a single catcher among the Pirates’ top 30 prospects, according to MLB Pipeline.

While the entire farm system had slipped, that downfall was even more pronounced behind the plate, a position where Russell Martin and Francisco Cervelli had given the Pirates a decided advantage during their last brush with competitive baseball.

The Pirates’ continued need for catching presents an interesting question for the start of the MLB draft on Sunday. Although there will likely be a record number of high school shortstops taken within the first 10 picks, it could make some sense for the Pirates to zig while others are zagging.

Henry Davis from Louisville is the best catching prospect in the draft. He’s considered the best college hitter available, and he’s very much among the players the Pirates are considering with the top pick.

Advertise with us

But is that smart?

In other sports, this would probably be easy. Endy Rodriguez (MLB Pipeline No. 25) at Low-A Bradenton represents the Pirates’ best and only legitimate catching prospect. They do not otherwise have a succession plan after Jacob Stallings, who’s 31 years old at a position that rarely ages gracefully.

Draft Davis, and you should seemingly be set. Except in baseball, where there’s a hugely incongruent path between the minor and major leagues, it’s hardly a sure bet. It’s also not necessarily true that Davis warrants such selection.

At the beginning of the college season, Miami’s Adrian Del Castillo was viewed as a better option, although he had a down 2021 — hitting just .281 and compiling more strikeouts (28) than walks (25) — and tumbled from the top to the bottom of the first round.

The numbers Davis produced are terrific. In 50 games, he slashed .370/.482/.663, with 15 home runs, 48 RBIs, 45 runs scored, 31 walks and 24 strikeouts. He also did it in the ACC, which is absolutely legitimate baseball competition.

Advertise with us

However, scouts have concerns over the mechanics of Davis’ swing and whether it will effectively translate to the next level. Those involve the length of it, as well as its lack of athletic movement.

Critics have also pointed to Davis’ defense being unrefined and needing work to reach a truly elite level. While Davis’ arm gets a 70 grade on the 20-to-80 scale, his weaknesses are believed to be blocking and pitch framing.

To build himself into a Gold Glove finalist, Stallings — a former pitcher and current strong-armed catcher — went to work on the same things, improving his pitch framing and blocking enough to blossom into one of the best defensive catchers in baseball.

The point here is that these things don’t have to be mastered by draft day. In baseball, more so than other sports, you’re drafting based on projection or predictability nearly as much as you are past precedent.

If Davis is a good kid and a hard worker — and there’s ample evidence that he’s both — then the Pirates could do a lot worse than drafting someone who has to work on some stuff.

Advertise with us

Selecting Davis would give the Pirates a quality player with sizable upside who would also allow current prospects such as Liover Peguero or Oneil Cruz to have a shot at becoming the club’s shortstop of the future. Meanwhile, they’d be adding an offensive stalwart at a position where that’s often rare.

The last important component here involves price. Not only is Davis consistently projected to go below Mayer or even Jordan Lawlar — the other shortstop in the top half of that talented foursome — he also doesn’t have someone competing for the same market.

Put another way: pretend you’re Mayer or Lawlar, who are routinely projected to go higher than Davis. If Mayer doesn’t want to take a discount to go to the Pirates, it’s hard to see him slipping terribly far down draft boards. It may be worth the gamble to play hardball.

Conversely, if Davis feels like his market is in those fifth or sixth spots, the Pirates could go significantly under slot and still give Davis more than he was otherwise expecting.

The breakdown here, the line of thought that could prevent this from happening, involves two things: logic and how Pirates scouts have evaluated Davis, Mayer and even Lawlar.

Advertise with us

Because while Davis does some things well, in baseball, you don’t draft for need. You draft for upside and what makes the most sense for your organization in the bigger picture. If the Pirates can get Mayer or Lawlar for a reasonable price and use that money later, then that’s probably a better strategy.

It’s also really hard to pass on Mayer and the player he could be, according to those who’ve seen him play. Scouts have drawn comparisons to Dodgers shortstop Corey Seager. Mayer is a former soccer player with outstanding speed and athleticism, inspiring the belief that he’ll stick at shortstop.

The guts and mechanics of Mayer’s swing are also sound; the only knock is some power that should theoretically come as he matures. Still only 18, Mayer is listed at 6-foot-3, 185 pounds.

And if the Pirates for whatever reason don’t take Mayer, they have a terrific fallback plan in Lawlar, who played in the same high school program as Josh Bell and has a similar skill set to Mayer.

So while the Pirates under Cherington have never not known a dearth of catching prospects, the MLB draft could be forcing them to wait. After all, if this is a historic draft for shortstops, is it really the best time to take a catcher?

Advertise with us

That’s why the prediction here is Mayer. There’s just too much there to pass up; figure the rest out later. At the same time, the Pirates do have the good fortune of going a couple different routes at the top.

And there’s only a couple more hours until we find out.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.