The video made its rounds on Twitter, the Pirates’ team account posting an inside-the-clubhouse look at how and when manager Derek Shelton told Adam Frazier he would be starting at second base for the National League on Tuesday for the MLB All-Star Game in Denver.
That moment, with Shelton jokingly calling a team meeting and Frazier looking surprised because he just got out of the shower, was only half the story. The first part came last season, after the Pirates’ 5-1 victory over the Cardinals on July 26 — Shelton’s first win as a major league manager.
To commemorate that occurrence, Frazier actually gifted Shelton a bottle of the same bourbon that Shelton gave him — Old Fitzgerald. It wasn’t a case of Tim Whatley regifting a label-maker, either. The same as many baseball players, Shelton and Frazier are both bourbon fanatics, and it was just an appropriate way to celebrate a milestone.
The love of bourbon is a unique dynamic to baseball, as it’s not nearly as prevalent in hockey or football, two other sports I’ve covered in Pittsburgh. It’s a great way to unwind after a long day. It’s also a way to cultivate sources. And for players, it’s often about the collection.
“I’ve gotten to the point now where I collect it more than I’m drinking it,” Frazier said. “But it’s fun.”
We live for these moments. pic.twitter.com/xRg1WP3doM
— Pittsburgh Pirates (@Pirates) July 4, 2021
Frazier doesn’t remember exactly how he got into bourbon. It’s just one of those things that’s grown over time, helped along by recommendations by older teammates and a passion for trying new bottles that tends to permeate most major league clubhouses.
Read More
Among the more advanced collectors on the team, Frazier said he has around 150 bottles. They include everything from Elmer T. Lee, Blanton’s Gold and Weller C.Y.P.B. to Japanese brands that Frazier also really likes.
“We’re always talking about it,” Frazier said. “We find good bottles we send to each other, send pictures of our collections, that sort of stuff. The longer you’re in the league, you start to figure out who on other teams collects stuff.”
One example there comes from another bourbon drinker on the team, Wil Crowe. In the Nationals organization, pitcher Patrick Corbin was one of the go-to sources for bourbon intel, the same way it used to be guys like Trevor Williams, Joe Musgrove and Jameson Taillon here.
Taillon was especially passionate about it. His love for bourbon was a close second to his coffee obsession, and Taillon was always eager to give bourbon recommendations to someone who never really got into it much before. Shelton, too.
“It’s kind of like wine, but I think bourbon is more of an acquired taste,” Frazier said. “Then once you start tasting nice bourbons, it’s like, ‘Wow, that’s way better than Jack Daniel’s or whatever it may be.’ That’s how to get started.”
That’s sort of what hooked Kevin Newman, who was never really that into bourbon before but has recently taken up the hobby. Now, Newman’s collection has grown to a modest 20 or so bottles, while some of his favorites have been E.H. Taylor, Smoke Wagon and 1792.
When Newman expressed his interest in bourbon to Shelton, the Pirates skipper bought him a bottle of Stagg Jr., which became another key part of his collection.
“You find rare bottles, you collect ’em, slowly drink ’em, try ’em out,” Newman said. “I think it’s just a fun little hobby, honestly.”
The entanglement between baseball and bourbon has always fascinated me. I had never had a drop of it until I started covering baseball, and now it’s one of my favorite things to drink. After starting out with Woodford Reserve and Basil Hayden’s, I’ve advanced a little. Buffalo Trace remains my favorite so far, and I’m always looking for decent recommendations. “Neat: The Story of Bourbon” is a tremendous documentary if you have the time.
But, why? Why is bourbon so prevalent around baseball culture? I have two theories. One, it’s uniquely American and extremely prevalent in the south, the same as baseball. It’s also not anything you can enjoy quickly.
Part of what makes baseball great — and sometimes also drives me up a wall — is the time commitment required. In practice. Covering it. The length of games. The number of games. It’s great because it’s hard. But very little in baseball happens fast, the same as a night spent drinking bourbon with friends.
“I think it’s just the times you have when you drink bourbon,” Frazier said. “It’s a good time with the company you’re with. You have a nice bottle, you like to have good company around when you’re drinking it. Baseball players like to drink, too.”
THREE UP
• This MLB draft is so odd. Very likely we won’t know who the Pirates are going to pick until it happens. At the same time, I think it’s good for them. One of the things Baseball America’s Carlos Collazo said that really stood out involves how teams with a sound process can take advantage. Assuming Ben Cherington doesn’t suddenly become stupid, this should play in their favor.
• Have written this before, but it’s probably warranted once again after what happened recently. Mason Martin is the Pirates’ first baseman of the future, and he’s going to be a good one. With seven homers in his past seven games entering play Thursday, Martin leads the Class AA Northeast league in dingers (16) and slugging percentage (.613). He’s tied for first in extra-base hits (32) and second in RBIs (46).
• I’m glad Major League Baseball got it right when it comes to Bryan Reynolds and the All-Star game. Reynolds isn’t flashy, doesn’t say a lot, and the Pirates are one of the worst teams in the league; however, it’s the right call. Entering Thursday’s games, only six outfielders in MLB had a better OPS than Reynolds (.904).
THREE DOWN
• Is this the inglorious end for Gregory Polanco? His stint on the 10-day injured list for a bilateral adductor strain takes us to July 16. Polanco is hitting .199, has a .640 OPS and has struck out in nearly 30% (74 of 252) of his plate appearances. A trade will be tough. Can’t imagine Pirates will stay committed to playing him after July.
• It was mostly good news on Oneil Cruz and Roansy Contreras, who will miss between 2-4 weeks with forearm muscle strains. However, the frequency of injuries to Pirates prospects has been depressing. They’ve had those two, Miguel Yajure, Brennan Malone, Travis Swaggerty, Cody Bolton, even Nick Gonzales for a stretch. Enough already.
• The flip side to the odd draft thing is that somebody will be mad. Some group of fans is going to feel that the Pirates did something wrong or screwed up the draft in some way. I get it. They’ve made some poor decisions and have to live with that. But taking Marcelo Mayer or Henry Davis over Jack Leiter does not make this draft a failure.
ON DECK
KEEP IT UP: Frazier and Reynolds will have a standard to maintain this week in Denver. Pirates position players are hitting .308 (4 for 13) in five All-Star games since 2014, highlighted by Andrew McCutchen going deep against Chris Archer back in 2015.
DEGROM, DEGOAT: The Pirates actually missed Mets ace Jacob deGrom this past week at Citi Field, but they won’t be so lucky coming out of the All-Star break. How good was deGrom in the first half?
He posted a 1.08 ERA, which is the second-lowest at the All-Star break since the game was first played back in 1933 (minimum 10 starts). Only Bob Gibson (1.06 ERA) in 1968 was better.
He allowed two homers Wednesday. He’s allowed more than one home run just six times in his past 59 starts dating back to 2019.
Oh, and deGrom has allowed just 16 hits in 206 at-bats this season when getting two strikes on a hitter, striking out 146. That’s crazy.
FRONTRUNNERS: New York has been in first place since Saturday, May 8, a span of 63 consecutive days. Overall, they’ve been in first place for 79 days, the most of any MLB team in 2021 (entering play Thursday).
NUMEROLOGY
.795: That’s the Mets’ winning percentage when scoring first, best in MLB (35-9 entering Saturday’s doubleheader). The Pirates, meanwhile, are just 21-13 (.618). New York has also played an MLB-high 32 one-run games, going 18-14 in those contests.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.