Predicting how the Pirates would construct their minor league rosters this season took a lot more guesswork than usual.
There was no 2020 minor league season. A select few players got to spend time at the Pirates’ alternate training site in Altoona during the approximately two months that it existed, but a vast majority of the prospects in the system were left to their own devices.
General manager Ben Cherington said Saturday that one of the benefits of minor league spring training this season was that those in the organization could take stock of the physical shape of the prospects, given that they hadn’t seen a fair amount of them since COVID-19 shut the 2020 season down.
Minor league spring training also gave the Pirates the ability to see some games, gaining data on how players’ individual work over the last year translates into live action. Mix it all together, and the Pirates now have their Low-A, High-A, Class AA and Class AAA rosters ahead of the start of their minor league season on May 4.
Our Young Bucs take the field next week! pic.twitter.com/udamORdcIT
— Young Bucs (@YoungBucsPIT) May 1, 2021
“[There were] two things mostly we were focused on,” Cherington said. “One is, you always want guys to be at a level where they're challenged, where it's not easy, but also where they're not going to dominate nor be overwhelmed. You're trying to kind of find that sweet spot. You've also got to consider how do you create as many as much opportunity as possible. So there's a spacing element to it, as well, and you balance that. In some cases there may be particular circumstances with a particular player that might be working on something specifically where we feel like being at a certain level might be better to start.
“And then, of course, we've got to remind each other all the time that opening day gets a lot of attention and then the rosters are going to change quickly after that, anyway. So most important is that guys are playing and improving, and there's always a chance to move up.”
Read More
There is no tried and true formula for where each player was placed, even based off where they last played in the minors in 2019. Outfielder Travis Swaggerty, for instance — the No. 9-ranked prospect, according to MLB Pipeline — last saw action in High-A. Now, he’s been placed on Class AAA Indianapolis’ roster, meaning if all goes well he may skip Class AA Altoona altogether in his career.
Part of the reasoning for that, Cherington says, was that the Pirates observed strong development from Swaggerty while at the alternate training site last season, in major league spring training this season, and at the alternate training site in Pittsburgh to start 2021.
Meanwhile, the Pirates’ No. 4 prospect, infielder Oneil Cruz, spent time in Altoona during 2020 and joined the big-league club for spring training this year but will start in Class AA Altoona. The No. 2 prospect and 2020 first-round draft pick, Nick Gonzales, was also in Altoona and Pirates spring training. He and fellow infielder Liover Peguero, the No. 5 prospect, are in High-A Greensboro to start the year.
So there is no exact way to say how much value a player got out of time spent at the alternate training site or in spring training in March. It’s entirely on a case-by-case basis.
“I don't know what [alternate training site time is] equivalent to, but I think it's meaningful,” Cherington said. “You are facing upper-level, or in some cases even major league pitching, and you're being challenged every day with that. It's not the same as playing nine-inning games, of course, so I don't know how to make the equivalence. But I think it's meaningful experience.”
What is convenient about the announcements of the rosters is that it makes it easy to track the hopeful future of the Pirates and makes for some intriguing pairings at different levels of the organization.
Swaggerty will form an outfield with former Pirates big leaguers Anthony Alford and Dustin Fowler in Class AAA Indianapolis. Offseason signee, and MLB veteran Brian Goodwin wasn’t listed on the roster and has an opt-out clause in his contract, but Cherington said he hopes the Pirates and Goodwin reach a resolution soon, which may mean Goodwin joins that roster, as well.
Cruz, No. 14 prospect Ji-Hwan Bae, No. 15 prospect Mason Martin and Rodolfo Castro, who made his MLB debut earlier this season, could form a tantalizing infield at Class AA Altoona.
Gonzalez and Peguero will be defending behind some of the top-ranked prospects like Quinn Priester, Tahnaj Thomas and Carmen Mlodzinski on the mound in High-A Greensboro.
Those pairings are nice, but Cherington says they’re not purposeful, even if the resulting relationships and trust built by minor-league teammates could benefit the Pirates down the road.
“I don't think it was really about keeping any pair or group together in terms of, like, relationships or things like that,” Cherington said. “They just ended up at the level that we think was best. That being said, we do hope those relationships form over time. That's important, too, and we certainly hope we have young players who are developing, coming through the system together and developing those strong relationships and trust so when they get to the big leagues, that bond is even tighter.”
Mike Persak: mpersak@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDPersak





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.