With MLB hoping to return soon, the Post-Gazette’s Jason Mackey and Mike Persak will analyze 20 issues related to the Pirates — think 20 Thoughts or questions about the team. They’ll run each weekday online through May 22 and will appear in print (or via other PG digital platforms) on Sunday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.

First-year manager Derek Shelton said last week that he’s been spending time watching Pirates games from last year and managing along with them.

It’s given him an opportunity to view how his current players were used under former manager Clint Hurdle, while also observing some of their strengths and weaknesses to give him an idea of how he might manage them whenever the 2020 season gets underway.

From that, along with his emphasis on the relationship between himself and the baseball operations staff, it seems Shelton feels comfortable diving into the details as a manager.

Advertise with us

What kind of impact can that approach have on the Pirates? And on a larger scale, what affect can the new coaching staff have in Pittsburgh?

This spring, former Pirates pitcher Tyler Glasnow, now with the Tampa Bay Rays, spoke candidly with the Post-Gazette about some of the shortcomings he experienced while in Pittsburgh in that department.

In short, Glasnow said there was a consistent method that the coaching staff believed in for its pitchers — throwing down and in — rather than finding a pitcher’s strengths and catering to them. When anybody was struggling, that method was the answer, according to Glasnow.

Glasnow’s new team likely has a lot to do with his outlook. The Rays have outperformed their payroll consistently in past years, and it is thought that a lot of the credit for that can be given to the way they are ahead of the curve in analytics.

Luckily for the Pirates, Shelton is familiar with this sort of approach, since he spent seven seasons in Tampa Bay from 2010-2016, and he said Monday on a conference call that he and his staff have used the delay for the 2020 season to completely revamp the Pirates’ baseball operations department.

Advertise with us

“We tore down our advance process completely with our major league coaching staff and with our advance guys because of the fact that we have time,” Shelton said. “That’s not to say that we’re adjusting everything that’s in there, but we have the time right now to look through it. Why are we doing this? How are we doing this? There are some places where I hope we’ll be a little bit more ahead of the game.”

Chris Archer is a perfect example of how a new approach can help. Last year, he tried to develop a sinker to work down and in on hitters, and he got shelled. He talked this spring about finding his old self again, which is a guy who gets swings and misses on his four-seam fastball and slider.

Gregory Polanco is another example. Last year, in limited time, the right-fielder saw an uptick in his whiff percentage on breaking and off-speed pitches. When he swung at those types of pitches, he missed them more than 38% of the time. Maybe part of that was his injuries, but a deep dive from the coaching staff and a tweak in Polanco’s approach might improve those numbers and give him new life in the box.

A change could be seen in the field, too, in regards to shifting. The Pirates shifted 10th-most in MLB last season. One of the teams ahead of them was Minnesota — where Shelton was the bench coach — which finished sixth in shifts. Additionally, the Rays teams that Shelton was a part of were always near the top of the league in that department.

It’s all a part of tweaking little things here and there, and Shelton has already gotten a jump on that.

Advertise with us

“Some of the things that have stood out in watching the defensive side of the game, how people move and where they move and their placement, if they go to their right or to their left better, or how they get themselves into position,” Shelton said. “Because when you watch a wide variety of games, you see a lot more things. Because of that, in spring training, some of those instances didn’t come up, so it’s just learning more information about the group, about their movements, about how they did.

“Some of the offensive side of it is watching pitches guys swing at, and knowing at what point of the year, if they were swinging the bat really good or really bad, if they get over-aggressive or if they get under-aggressive. And in spring training, you don’t find those things out because of the fact that guys are working on things, and I think we’ve been able to hone in on that a little bit.”

This stretches beyond Shelton, too. Bench coach Don Kelly was with the Houston Astros last year, who are, for all their flaws, an extremely efficient organization. New pitching coach Oscar Marin was the Texas Rangers’ bullpen coach last year. The Rangers’ bullpen finished 18th in wins above replacement last year but had an extremely low payroll in that department, too. Perhaps Marin did the best he could with what he had.

Rick Eckstein is the holdover from last year’s Pirates regime, but he’s in deep with the analytics-driven approach, too. Plus, the Pirates were pretty good offensively last year, finishing sixth in the league in team batting average. Shelton says Eckstein has been able to give him some context for what he’s seen while watching last year’s games, explaining why certain things happened in more detail.

On that side of the ball, the Pirates could use an uptick in power, but that’s Shelton’s specialty. The Twins came out of nowhere to lead the league in home runs last season. Eight different players hit 20 or more home runs for them in 2019. Five of them hit 30 or more. Plus, the Twins finished fifth in on-base percentage, whereas the Pirates placed 18th.

Advertise with us

The key to all of this: The approach has to be adopted by the players, and Shelton’s is, by many accounts, a very good locker room guy. Former Twins manager Paul Molitor told the New York Post last year that players “gravitate toward” Shelton.

Shelton’s approach seems to be holistic. There is some tweaking needed here and there, and the idea is that enough of that will add up to larger improvements as a team.

That could take time, even beyond this season. But with this being his first year — and with a first-year general manager in Ben Cherington -—there’s a built-in runway. If certain approaches don’t work at first, there’s time to adjust or to try on new players. Now if only Shelton could get on the field with his players to see exactly what adjustments need to be made in real time.

STATISTICALLY SPEAKING: The Pirates were sixth in MLB in team batting average in 2019 but finished 18th or worse in runs, home runs, on-base percentage and slugging percentage.

KNOW THIS: The Twins took a huge leap in Shelton’s second season. They were in the bottom half of the league in OPS, on-base percentage and home runs in 2018 before finishing top five in all three categories in 2019.

Advertise with us

THEY SAID IT: “On the pitching side, I think we’ve done a really good job of making sure that we have a plan in place of how we’re going to do that. On the position player side, it’s not that we don’t have a plan, it goes back to the point of some guys don’t have facilities.” — Derek Shelton

Mike Persak: mpersak@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDPersak