The Pirates are among eight teams that are looking to hire a manager this offseason. While several candidates will be of interest to the Pirates, they'll also be intriguing to other organizations.
Athletics bench control coach Ryan Christenson and quality control coach Mark Kotsay are candidates for the Pirates’ job, but they've also been in the mix for the Giants’ opening. Sam Fuld is the player information coordinator for Philadelphia Phillies and was reported to be on the list for several teams, including the Pirates. A recent report has Fuld declining interviews in Pittsburgh along with the Cubs and the Mets.
Fuld, Christenson, and Kotsay are all top applicants who will be interviewing the Pirates as much as the Pirates will be interviewing them.
In that vein, we've decided to list some pros and cons of each job. Since this isn't a ranking, the list will start with the Pirates and go in alphabetical order for the rest of the teams.
Pirates
Pros: It isn't easy to find positives when looking at the Pirates’ last-place finish in the division and their horrendous swoon after the All-Star break. However, there is hope.
Read More
Josh Bell, Bryan Reynolds, Kevin Newman and Starling Marte make up a nice core at the top of the lineup. Newman proved himself as a good leadoff hitter, Reynolds is trustworthy in the two-hole, and Marte and Bell can drive them in. Adam Frazier and Colin Moran add depth to the lineup. If Gregory Polanco is healthy, it makes the Pirates offense even more formidable.
Cons: The starting pitching at times was dreadful. Chris Archer, Joe Musgrove, Trevor Williams, Steven Brault, and Mitch Keller showed flashes of success, but it wasn't enough. The loss of Jameson Taillon looms large over 2020. Getting a new pitching coach to replace Ray Searage could help, but the Pirates still could use another arm or two. The problem is the Pirates are consistently in the bottom five in payroll. The A's and Rays have proven that teams don’t have to have a big payroll to make the playoffs. A new manager with a choice between the Pirates and a team with deeper pockets will have to decide if winning with the Pirates’ salary structure is a realistic task.
Chicago Cubs
Pros: Theo Epstein is known as one of the best minds in baseball. The Cubs are one of the wealthiest franchises in sports, and they don't mind spending money. Anthony Rizzo is a star, and the Cubs have a lot of talent.
Cons: Better tell your agent to get you some guarantees on the front and back end of the deal. Joe Maddon brought the first World Series win to Wrigley in more than 100 years and didn't last five seasons. Expectations are high on the North Side of Chicago. The Cubs also mortgaged a lot of the farm system and young talent to win that World Series. Closer Aroldis Chapman was a big part of that championship, but the Cubs had to trade budding star Gleybar Torres to get him. Moves like that have the Cubs lacking young stars.
Kansas City Royals
Pros: General manager Dayton Moore is a great baseball mind and is respected in the game. There are some talented players like Salvador Perez, Whit Merrifield, and Jorge Soler, as well. The team will be under new ownership, which seems to want to spend more money.
Cons: This will likely be the last job to get filled because of the ownership change. The Royals are actively rebuilding and struggled last season.
Los Angeles Angels
Pros: Mike Trout has a chance to go down as one of the top five to ever touch a baseball diamond. Trout is magnificent and gives a strong foundation to build around. Shohei Ohtani is a unique athlete as a hitter and pitcher. Arte Moreno is an owner who will spend on big-name free agents.
Cons: You'll always be second fiddle to the Los Angeles Dodgers. Oh, and you're not really in L.A., you're in Anaheim. And share a division with the Houston Astros and A's.
New York Mets
Pros: Pete Alonso is a monster, and the best thing is he's got two more seasons before he's eligible for arbitration. Jacob deGrom is likely going to win another Cy Young Award. Noah Syndergaard is a reliable pitcher, as well. The Mets showed lots of promise in 2019 and could be a few pieces away from being a serious contender.
Cons: Like the Angels aren't the Dodgers, the Mets aren't the Yankees. They have had many instances where it seemed like they were ready to turn the corner, but somehow it all falls down each time. What will be different this time?
Philadelphia Phillies
Pros: They will spend the money. The owners said they were going to break the bank and they did it. Philadelphia is a significant market and the owners act like it. Bryce Harper is a good player and there is a lot of talent in that clubhouse.
Cons: Start out winning fast or Philly won't be fun. It is as rough of a market as there is in America. Expectations will be high and that can be hard to handle for some.
San Diego Padres
Pros: Manny Machado is still a great player in spite of a season that didn't live up to his lofty expectations. Fernando Tatis Jr. is an exciting talent who had one of the best rookie seasons in baseball. The Padres have one of the best closers in baseball with Kirby Yates.
Cons: The offense was 28th in baseball. They struggled with a lot of basic base running and situational hitting. The starting pitching needs help, as well.
San Francisco Giants
Pros: The Giants spent most of the 2000s competing for titles, and ownership has proven that they'll spend the big bucks.
Cons: It might be time for a rebuild in the Bay. The roster is aging other than a few guys like Mike Yastrzemski. The team is paying the cost for trading away young talent.
Nubyjas Wilborn: nwilborn@post-gazette.com and Twitter @nwilborn19




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.