Neal Huntington discusses firing of Clint Hurdle

Sunday was supposed to be about Steve Blass, a victory lap for the franchise legend who’s retiring after 60 years with the Pirates.

It was not.

Instead, Sunday became very much about Clint Hurdle, who was fired as manager a little more than an hour before the start of the Pirates’ final game of the season against the Reds at PNC Park.

So, let’s start with one of several million-dollar questions here: Why in the world did the Pirates do this now?

Advertise with us

In explaining the Pirates’ rationale behind firing Hurdle, general manager Huntington also talked a little about the timing of the move. Here are those responses, along with a little context and analysis.

Keeping a secret

It’ll be tough to find a player who expected this. As far as they were concerned, Hurdle was under contract for two more years, and they expected him to stay in place as manager.

Turns out there’s a reason why they felt that way. A very intentional one.

Huntington said he did not seek any player input on the move, because he didn’t want information to leak.

Advertise with us

“We talked with a lot of people to gather input, to get their thoughts, to get their observations,” Huntington said. “That bridge to players is sometimes challenging because we didn’t want it to ever leak that we were considering it. You see those all the time. Those are detrimental.

“In all of our player meetings at the end of the season, you can get a sense. But, no, I never directly asked a player for their feedback on our manager.”

Asked what sense the players gave, Huntington said, “That we have areas where we can get better.”

Those assurances

So what about those assurances Hurdle supposedly received from those above him?

Advertise with us

Huntington shouldered some of the blame, saying he had been talking with Hurdle about next year because that’s what those in their positions do.

“I can understand why he felt the way he did,” Huntington said. “Every conversation I had with Clint was about our challenges at the major league level. They were about how we address those, overcome them and what we were going to do this offseason and moving forward.

“If I am to blame for his perception that he had assurances that he was coming back, I will wear that.”

The night Hurdle said he thought he was coming back, Huntington put out a terse statement saying the Pirates, per their norm, wouldn’t be talking about personnel moves in-season.

It was weird, to say the least, especially considering that Hurdle and Huntington received matching extensions in September 2017 — during the season.

Advertise with us

“We’ve made staff changes in-season,” Huntington said Sunday. “We’ve made staff changes the day after the season. We’ve made staff changes in the offseason. We wanted to handle this the best way we could despite it being an incredibly difficult situation.”

The Blass effect

It’s too bad this had to happen on Sunday.

All of the stories involving the Pirates and what they did Sunday will start and end with the firing of Hurdle. They should’ve been all about Blass, although that really isn’t going to be what anyone is talking about.

Huntington was hesitant on outlining the timing here, describing when they made the decision as “recently” before ultimately answering that they told Hurdle he was fired around noon, after he met with reporters and talked for 20 minutes about bouncing back from a tough year.

Advertise with us

Hurdle was given the option to manage against the Reds but turned it down.

“We wanted to handle this the best way we could despite it being an incredibly challenging situation,” Huntington said. “We wanted to give Clint the opportunity to potentially know he was managing his last game as a Pirates manager, to talk to the people that he’s loved and that have loved him, that he’s poured into, that have poured into him.

“Calling him and asking him to come to the office [Monday], with most of the team out of town and most of his staff out of town, it just didn’t feel like the right thing to do. So that’s why we made him aware [Sunday].”

The Pirates should have sat on the news and fired Hurdle on Monday. Instead, they made Sunday about the wrong guy and seemingly ticked off Hurdle while doing it.

If the concern was about letting someone enjoy their final day of work, Blass, with 60 years of service, should trump Hurdle. In that case, Hurdle can come into the office on Monday.

Advertise with us

Why not earlier?

It’s hardly news that the Pirates have been bad this season. Much of their fan base probably expected this move to be made amid a horrid losing stretch out of the All-Star break, especially after they lost 24 of 28.

Huntington was asked why he didn’t do anything earlier, although he wasn’t terribly revealing on the topic.

“There is no one thing that led to this,” Huntington said. “We’ve fallen short of expectations, internal or external, for a handful of years after meeting and greatly exceeding those expectations in some areas.

“These decisions are incredibly challenging. We make them for what we believe to be the right reasons. We’ll work to put the next-best manager in place while honoring and respecting what Clint accomplished while he was here.”

Advertise with us

More coming?

Huntington hinted the changes probably won’t stop with Hurdle, and that includes the coaching staff, a group the new manager will “have a say” in hiring.

Potential firings could include pitching coach Ray Searage, third-base coach Joey Cora or even Larry Broadway (senior director of minor league operations) or Kyle Stark (assistant general manager) if the Pirates choose to overhaul that wing of baseball operations.

“You want your new manager to always have a say in the staff,” Huntington said. “That said, we have some really talented people on this staff that we will work through with the new manager. But he’ll have to have a say.

“We have some talented people that absolutely have the opportunity to stay on the major league level or stay somewhere in our development system. But there may be some changes coming as well.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.