Building around young players is a central tenet in the vision Neal Huntington has articulated for building the Pirates back into a winner.
“Sixteen of the 25 players who got us to within 2½ games of first place are young [with three years of service time or less],” the general manager told reporters in August. “We have other players coming in behind with Mitch Keller, Ke’Bryan Hayes and Oneil Cruz on the horizon. You get JT Brubaker healthy, we’ve got a lot of good, young arms. If you look at the boxes to rebuild that you check, the one that we check is non-competitive.
“The young players, we feel like we have those guys who we can build around going forward. The prospects on the horizon, we feel like we have some of those guys going forward.”
He’s made some form of this argument since pretty much the moment he got to Pittsburgh in 2007, and it’s rooted in sound small-market logic. Cash-strapped clubs may be able to patch their holes via free agency, but they can’t afford to build their teams through it. Cheap, home-grown talent is going to have to carry a substantial portion of the load for a team like the Pirates to be successful.
Let’s set aside, for a moment, Huntington’s stingy recent approach to addressing the holes in free agency and accept that the theory, at least, is a good one. Let’s instead scrutinize the Pirates’ record of actually getting those young players to grow into franchise building blocks once they reach the majors, because it’s not great.
Reader Mark Fatla reached out following Friday’s post about the club’s latest rookie hopes — led by outfielder Bryan Reynolds and shortstop Kevin Newman — still falling short of All-Star caliber results. He cast doubt on their ability to ever reach that level by providing some damning year-by-year wins above replacement totals for several current and former Pirates who spent part or all of their minor league years in the club’s system.
Read More
Figures are from Baseball Reference.
● Josh Harrison – 1.2/-0.1/0.1/5.5/1.8/1.9/3.4/0.3
● Jordy Mercer – 0.3/1.9/2.8/0.3/0.9/1.4/0.3
● Gregory Polanco – 0.1/2.6/1.8/0.2/1.9/-0.6
● Starling Marte – 1.0/5.2/4.7/5.3/4.9/1.5/3.7/2.9
● Colin Moran – 1.0/-0.4 (made debut with Houston)
● Elias Diaz – 1.6/-1.3
● Josh Bell - -1.0/1.9/0.8/3.0
● Adam Frazier - 0.5/1.8/2.7/3.0
WAR, as this space has noted numerous times, is not a perfect statistic, but it is one of the best snapshots we have into a player’s combined offensive and defensive value. And in these selections, it’s painting a picture of stifled growth at the big-league level.
In that group, only Frazier showed steady year-over-year growth, while Marte’s production flattened at robust levels. Others either struggled to replicate early success consistently or regressed entirely. That seems like a problem if the goal is to build around such players.
Let’s add some other examples from home-grown regulars on rosters dating to the team’s three playoff appearances from 2013-15.
● Andrew McCutchen - 2.4/3.8/5.4/6.9/7.9/6.1/4.9/-0.5/2.5
● Neil Walker - -0.6/2.1/2.6/2.6/3.9/3.6/2.4
● Pedro Alvarez - 0.6/-1.8/2.6/3.3/0.8/0.2
● Travis Snider - 0.2/-0.6/1.9 (made debut with Toronto)
● Jung Ho Kang - 4.0/2.5/0.0/-0.7 (missed most of two seasons because of DUI arrests)
Only McCutchen showed the career arc you’d like to see: solid production upon joining the roster, then steady growth for years before a decline. It’d be unreasonable to expect every player or even most players to reach the heights he did as an National League MVP, but similar arcs at lesser levels of production shouldn’t be too much to ask of a franchise that wants to build around internal assets.
To be fair, some of the factors in these players’ uneven production were beyond the club’s control. Polanco’s injuries and Kang’s legal issues are good examples.
There is, however, also a long list of players who’ve gotten legitimate playing time and never managed to develop into more than bench fodder. That list includes former prospects Alex Presley, Tony Sanchez, Andrew Lambo, Chase d'Arnaud, Gorkys Hernandez, Max Moroff, Jose Osuna, Alen Hanson, Jordan Luplow and Austin Meadows.
The Pirates invested some level of hope in all of them. Some completely flamed out and others found success with other organizations.None of those results reflect well on the club’s ability to actually produce the internal talent it says it needs to compete. And that’s before we even broach the topic of pitching, which deserves it own post.
In short, there’s no real reason for fans to believe Reynolds and Newman will develop any differently than their many predecessors. The same is true of Hayes and Cruz, prospects Huntington name dropped that we’ve yet to even see in the majors.
Could they imitate McCutchen’s arc? Sure. But that would only make them outliers like him, and not examples of anything the current Pirates management regime is doing well systematically.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.