Neal Huntington has many talents. Reading a room is not one of them. The latest example came Sunday as the Pirates general manager attempted to explain his team’s horrific skid since the All-Star break as, basically, a mathematical fluke.

This is absolutely not what most fans want to hear. They want accountability. They want action. Some of them want Huntington to lose his job for exactly this type of analytic psychobabble.

He’s not wrong, though. That quote comes almost word-for-word from a Fangraphs post last week that crunched the numbers on the statistical improbability of this latest Pirates collapse.

“If you think the Pirates are a true-talent .471 team, as our odds do, wowzers — their odds of going on this ignominious run were a mere 0.08%,” the site’s Ben Clemens wrote. “In 10,000 sets of 29 games, in other words, they’d project to play this badly only eight times.”

Advertise with us

This is how simulations work. Some go exceedingly well. Some go really poorly. The vast majority fall somewhere in between and give us a sense of a team’s equilibrium as constituted.

Think of them as the practical application of line-of-best-fit lessons from your high school math classes. They can include data points that are all over a given axis, but you can plot a line through them that sums up the story they’re telling collectively.

For the Pirates, that story has been one of mediocrity for the past several years. Many popular projection models have settled on them as a .500-ish team, and they’ve more or less played on that level until this recent funk.

A better messenger could use this fact to make the case that, through a combination of bad luck and injuries, the Pirates just got skunked this year. The team isn’t really this bad. The performance is an aberration and the core of this roster remains a competitive one. Remain calm.

Unfortunately for Huntington, he is not that messenger.

Advertise with us

He’s spent the better part of those years making the case that, by intentionally constructing a .500-ish team, the Pirates will inevitably end up on the right side of a simulation at some point.

“Our projection is probably going to be 78 to 82 wins next year,” Huntington said last July. “Maybe a little worse if we take some of the veterans off this club.

“But when you have good, young players, you have more variability. When it works in a positive direction, you have a chance to be one of those teams that achieves more than most people expect.”

Again, he is right. There is a chance of just about anything.

The problem is that Huntington can’t have this reality both ways. He can’t tout the improbable possibility of significantly exceeding expectations while writing off this season’s failure as an outlier. The Pirates’ 51-72 record was baked into this cake the same way the reverse would have been — possible, but unlikely.

Advertise with us

That is the risk he took by making few significant additions to an 82-win team in 2018. These are the consequences he has to own now that this simulation has gone wrong.

The only way to improve the Pirates’ chances of truly competing for something is to raise their equilibrium. To consistently produce rosters that project to, say, 89 wins as opposed to 82.

That won’t guarantee success. There will still be simulations in 10,000 where things go wrong, sometimes dramatically so. There will also be more where things go right. Where the “variability” Huntington touts makes the difference between qualifying for the playoffs with a wild-card spot and winning the division, instead of simple mediocrity and contention.

Raising that equilibrium is, of course, easier said than done, especially with the budget Huntington has apparently been given by ownership.

At least making it a goal would be a good start, though.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.