ALTOONA, Pa. — Oneil Cruz stood a couple steps from the Altoona Curve dugout, near the on-deck circle, bobbing his head to the music. As he strode confidently toward home plate, he tapped his cleats with his bat, two times each, before settling into the batter’s box, a 6-foot-6 menace with long limbs and plenty of power.
Although Cruz cuts an imposing figure and has quickly ascended to the top of the Pirates’ list of prospects, his first at-bat during Sunday’s game at Peoples Natural Gas Field never really got off the ground. Cruz took two hittable pitches, then, in an 0-2 hole, bounced a ball to shortstop for an easy out.
That sort of duality — a supremely gifted athlete who’s still extremely raw — has defined Cruz’s minor league career thus far. On some plays, he looks like a budding star, the way Gregory Polanco did when he was here. On others, you can see why the Pirates are smartly tempering expectations, believing that Cruz is still very much in the developmental stages.
“There’s a lot of good,” Curve manager Michael Ryan said after his team’s 6-5 victory over Bowie on Sunday night, his franchise-record 214th win with Class AA Altoona. “There are also a lot of reminders of he’s got a ways to go.”
The Polanco comparisons are hard to avoid. They’re both long, lanky and left-handed. They have short dreadlocks died blonde and sheepish smiles. They can also make you jump out of your seat and rip your hair out within a couple of seconds.
“I think of Polanco when he was young, because he’s put on some man strength and some muscle,” Ryan said. “But you see the swing, you see the fluidity of what they can do at the plate, I think that’s what’s similar.”
Read More
Pirates farm director Larry Broadway isn’t so sure. He gets the height thing but also believes the 205-pound Cruz will remain lanky instead of bulking up like Polanco.
“Different players. Different athletes. Different bodies,” Broadway said. “I don’t see Cruz being as big as Polanco. They have different frames and body types.”
That, though, is a conversation for another day. Warranting the most discussion is what Cruz has done this season.
After producing a .150 batting average with no RBIs and two walks in his first six games with the Curve, Cruz is hitting .341 with 11 RBIs and six walks over his past 13 games.
While the native of Nizao, Dominican Republic, is hardly satisfied, Cruz said he’s beginning to feel more comfortable at Double-A.
“I’m getting better,” Cruz said via translator and assistant coach Salvador Paniagua. “I don’t feel comfortable yet because I’m going to get to the big leagues. But I’m trying my best every day to get there.”
If the strides that Cruz — an international signee the Pirates got from the Dodgers in the 2017 Tony Watson trade — has made this past season are any indication, his promotion to the big leagues might not be far off.
After overcoming a right-foot fracture that hampered him early on, Cruz led the Florida State League with six home runs, a .330 average, 13 RBIs and 18 runs over a 24-game stretch, earning FSL Player of the Month honors for High-A Bradenton before he was promoted to Class AA Altoona.
His production hasn’t gone unnoticed, either. After MLB Pipeline’s midseason update, Cruz is now No. 3 on the Pirates’ Top 30 list, behind Mitch Keller and Ke’Bryan Hayes. Baseball America has him ranked No. 79 overall, while MLB.com has him at No. 62.
All of that has netted Cruz plenty of extra attention, and it has also helped his confidence.
“I’m getting better every day,” Cruz said. “I’m getting more confident with what I’ve been doing in the box and in the field.”
But there’s also the yin and yang, a highly talented player who’s also just the 11th 20-year-old to play for the Curve, a list that includes Cole Tucker, Austin Meadows, Jameson Taillon and others.
Cruz is going to make mistakes, as he did in the fifth inning Sunday, when he had a ton of time to throw and pulled a throw well wide of first.
Or when he struck out a half-inning before by lunging at a pitch, arms and levers everywhere. According to Broadway, plate discipline has been a focal point for Cruz.
“He can hit a lot of pitches,” Broadway said. “It’s just a matter of hitting the pitch that he wants to hit, not the ones they want him to hit. He has to make sure he’s locked in on his plan, knows what he wants to do and sticks to it.”
But a half-inning before the ugly strikeout, Cruz used his long limbs to reach a ball in the hole between short and third, then in one windmill-like motion, threw back to second base for the forceout.
In the sixth, as Altoona rallied, Cruz walloped a slider from Bowie left-hander Alex Wells to left-center for an opposite-field, two-run double that tied the game. He would later score on Logan Hill’s single, taking about six strides to get from third to home.
Of course, the best play Cruz made might’ve come in the seventh, when he did a 360-degree spin and turned a terrific double play with second baseman Adrian Valerio.
“You hear the phrase, ‘He’s a five-tool player.’ Well, he’s a five-tool player,” Ryan said. “He can hit. He can hit for power. He can run. He’s got a cannon for an arm. He’s a very special player.
“The reminder is that he’s 20 years old as well. The five tools stick out each day but also the 20-year-old mindset. You just hope the good outweighs the bad.”
Given the whole Polanco thing and the fact that the Pirates have a couple of solid, young shortstops in Kevin Newman and Cole Tucker, it’s possible they could try to move Cruz somewhere else, perhaps to a corner outfield spot.
While Ryan said the obvious — that the decision will be made by Pirates management — he could also see Cruz conquering any challenge put in front of him.
“He’s so skilled, I think he can do whatever he wants to do on the field,” Ryan said. “He’s a really good shortstop, and I think that’s where he’s going to stay. But if there ever was an option at another position, he’s going to be able to do it.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.