Neal Huntington has spent most of 2018 casting doubt on statistical projections that pegged his team as a .500-ish bunch. As recently as this past Sunday, he made a point of mentioning that the club’s 2013-2015 playoff teams smashed popular projections, the implication being that they’re some degree of bullpucky. He even got a head start on spinning whatever the models say about 2019.
“Our projection is probably going to be 78 to 82 wins next year. Maybe a little worse if we take some of the veterans off this club,” Huntington told reporters.
“But when you have good, young players, you have more variability. When it works in a positive direction, you have a chance to be one of those teams that achieves more than most people expect.”
A deeper look at the individual projections those win totals were based on, however, reveals that the Pirates were going to need a lot of variability to be good in 2018. In particular, the rotation was going to need to shatter forecasts, not merely exceed them.
Dan Szymborski’s ZiPS projections are among the most respected in the industry, and they cast a lot of doubt on the Pirates’ young starters from the jump. Here’s what they were calling for in early December.
● Jameson Taillon: 3.65 ERA, 3.54 FIP (Fielding Independent Pitching, a defense-independent stat with a scale similar to ERA), 1.28 WHIP, 8.09 K/9, 2.41 BB/9
Read More
● Trevor Williams: 4.51 ERA, 4.47 FIP, 1.41 WHIP, 6.67 K/9, 2.96 BB/9
● Chad Kuhl: 4.70 ERA, 4.77 FIP, 1.42 WHIP, 7.57 K/9, 3.36 BB/9.
● Nick Kingham: 4.51 ERA, 4.40 FIP, 1.37 WHIP, 6.21 K/9, 2.50 BB/9
● Joe Musgrove: 4.08 ERA, 4.00 FIP, 1.24 WHIP, 8.08 K/9, 1.85 BB/9
That’s ... not great. And unfortunately for the Pirates, those numbers have been, more or less, right on the mark. Williams, Kuhl, Kingham and Musgrove are all within a few tenths of their projected ERAs, while Taillon has been closer to a half-run worse.
It’s been more of a mixed bag on offense. Here’s a sampling of the projections for regular position players younger than 30:
● Starling Marte: .278 average, .334 on-base percentage, .412 slugging percentage, .746 OPS
● Gregory Polanco: .268/.328/.437/.765
● Austin Meadows: .252/.307/.433/.740
● Josh Bell: .271/.347/.452/.799
● Colin Moran: .259/.312/.402/.714
● Elias Diaz: .240/.278/.334/.613
Diaz and Meadows have been much more productive than expected, but the success stories end there. Everyone else’s numbers are either worse or in roughly the same neighborhood that ZiPS projected for them.
That’s a problem when projections for almost all of the younger players were humble to begin with.
Huntington is correct when he says that there’s more uncertainty with guys who are in their early- and mid-20s. The models for those players rely a lot on minor-league numbers, which don’t always translate seamlessly to the top level.
That said, even if all of the pitchers had exceeded their projections by a half a run in ERA, and even if the position players had goosed their projected OPS marks by 50 or so points, we’d still probably be looking at a team on the fringes of contention. If Huntington was relying on variability to get this group from roughly .500 to playoff caliber, then it’s becoming clear he baked in too much.
It’s also worth noting that the success of those 2013-15 teams wasn’t merely a product of young players growing into unforeseen production. Sure, Josh Harrison came out of nowhere to post 4.8 wins above replacement in 2014 (via FanGraphs), and in 2013 Andrew McCutchen matured into an MVP-level player that helped covered some warts in other areas.
But there were important strategic decisions that led to veteran additions making bigger contributions than expected, too. The club’s progressive and liberal use of defensive shifts was a boon for pitchers like A.J. Burnett, Edinson Volquez and Francisco Liriano, while Russell Martin’s pitch framing helped those guys behind the plate.
If the 2018 group has been pursuing comparable initiatives that could swing the numbers in significant ways, it’s been hard to spot.
For that reason, the comparison between this team and its successful predecessors is somewhat strained. Sure, it was probably reasonable to expect some of the young guys to perform better than they have. There is, however, a fine line between hope and fantasy, and Huntington and Co. would probably be wise to figure that out in picking up the pieces from what looks like a third consecutive lost season.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.