Hello and welcome to this week’s Pirates mailbag. I know times are tough right now, so I want to thank everyone who submitted questions — more than 40 in all. I won’t be able to get to all of them, but I did select 10 that I thought brought up interesting topics and didn’t just focus on, “When are they going to fire everyone?”
As always, you can reach me at jmackey@post-gazette.com or on Twitter @JMackeyPG.
Kayla Mae (@kaylamae263): What’s the lineup look like for next year, barring acquisitions? Do you expect them to make any good moves or just tear it all down over the offseason?
Jason Mackey: Good question, Kayla. I would imagine your top four looks like it does now: Kevin Newman, Bryan Reynolds, Starling Marte and Josh Bell. From there, I think it depends on the health of Gregory Polanco. If he’s good to go, he probably bats fifth.
Then maybe you look at a catcher they acquire or Colin Moran sixth, the other one seventh, maybe Adam Frazier eighth and the pitcher’s spot.
The “good moves” line cracked me up. For me, any move this side of Lonnie Chisenhall would be a good one. However …
Read More
As much as I think people are looking for them to make major player changes, nothing we’ve been told — on or off the record — would indicate that’s is going to happen.
I do think they need to address the pitching staff, especially the starters, but I don’t know how much they’re going to do there, either. I really do think it’s going to be a lot of the same, outside of low-key addressing the catching situation and maybe grabbing a fourth outfielder as insurance — the 2020 Melky Cabrera.
Reid Family (@family_reid): Is it possible that Bryan Reynolds and Kevin Newman could finish first and second for Rookie of the Year? Also, Newman and Cole Tucker are our second baseman and shortstop next season, right?
Jason Mackey: I don’t see that happening. As good as they both have been, I don’t see how Pete Alonso isn’t the National League’s Rookie of the Year. I think you also have to look at Mike Soroka and Fernando Tatis Jr.
Reynold and Newman have been fantastic, but league-wide, I’m not sure they’re going to make much of a splash.
As for the second part, everything general manager Neal Huntington has said to this point indicates that Tucker is not quite ready to start, the bat lagging behind.
It still could happen, but I think it’s more likely at this point that you see Newman and Adam Frazier up the middle.

Stephen (@stephen_412): Richard Rodriguez has given up 13 home runs this season. Should that be a concern heading into next year, or is it more the risk associated with throwing a lot of high fastballs?
Jason Mackey: I think it has less to do with how Rodriguez pitches and more to do with his early-season struggles.
Lately, honestly, he’s been one of their most reliable relievers. Shoot, one of their only reliable relievers.
Since June 1, Rodriguez has a 2.13 ERA, which trails only Felipe Vazquez (1.75). Rodriguez has allowed four home runs during that time, Vazquez three.
While I think the Pirates bullpen is not without its issues, I’m fine if Rodriguez is pitching the seventh inning for them. I’m also good if Keone Kela is the eighth-inning guy; he’s been flat-out unhittable since returning from injury.
I worry more about Clay Holmes, Geoff Hartlieb, Michael Feliz … those types of guys.
Kevin Lane (@klane1705): Why didn’t Ke’Bryan Hayes or Will Craig get the September call-up to see what they have going into next year?
Jason Mackey: I disagree with their reasoning on this, Kevin, but the Pirates don’t think they’re ready. Because of that, they don’t see much of an opportunity for Hayes and Craig at this level, right now.
Again, I don’t see why you wouldn’t want those guys around the team and, yes, to see what they have in those guys. But the Pirates do not share that belief.
I’ve also heard that Hayes was dealing with a little bit of sort foot/ankle — a minor, lower-body injury where it might’ve actually made sense for the Pirates to shut him down.
John Zivkovic (@Zippy587): Do you see them being any better next year?
Jason Mackey: Good question, John. It’s the most important question here, right?
If they’re going to come back with the same group, which it sounds like they’re probably going to do, then no, I don’t see how they can be a whole lot better.
What will matter most is simple: starting pitching. If Trevor Williams and Joe Musgrove get better, great. Ditto for Chris Archer. They would also need Steven Brault to find what he did from May to August and have Mitch Keller, James Marvel or Dario Agrazal take the next step. It wouldn’t hurt if Chad Kuhl came back and grabbed a spot.
I think some of those guys are better than fans have given them credit for, but I also think you’re counting on a lot of things falling into place.
This team’s offense is good enough. They have some good, young position players — enough to at least be competitive. But if they’re non-competitive on the mound, which they’ve been far too often this season, it won’t matter.
Paul (@TheBigGaston): Where in the lineup do the Pirates need the most help?
Jason Mackey: To me, the area they need to upgrade the most is catcher. I like Jacob Stallings … as a backup.
But their catchers have been among the least productive in the National League for much of the season, the two biggest factors being Francisco Cervelli’s early struggles and a big-time regression from Elias Diaz.
For me, it’s a no-brainer to look to upgrade there and get a legitimate starter behind the plate, someone who can add at least a little offensive pop.
I don’t think that’s going to be Yasmani Grandal, to answer another question that was asked, but I do think they can do better than what they currently have.
A sneaky second might be an effective fourth outfielder. I don’t have a ton of faith that Gregory Polanco will play, say, 140 games in 2020 and do so effectively.
I think they need to have someone else around who isn’t Pablo Reyes or Kevin Kramer, nothing against those guys. Veteran guy, good off the bench but can start for a stretch if need be.

Ryan Norwood (@rnnorwood): How exactly can the Pirates be this bad when they are leading the league in batting average?
Jason Mackey: I don’t know if this is sarcastic or what, but batting average obviously isn’t everything, especially not with the way the game is being played now.
The Pirates don’t have the ability to score enough runs, especially when it comes to their pitching staff. So, yeah, they have a decent average, but if you look at their OPS — it’s currently 17th in baseball — I think it paints a truer picture.
Sue Bell (@ciaobellas_sue): Who among the players are clubhouse leaders? Is morale OK?
Jason Mackey: I worry about this, Sue. Coming from hockey, I saw first-hand how important guys like Patric Hornqvist could be. Sure, he was an effective player, but he set the tone — very loudly — for everyone around him. That might’ve been even more important than the number of goals he scored.
There was just a standard way of doing things, and guys were scared to operate outside of it. I’m not sure that tone exists around the Pirates clubhouse these days.
It’s not as dysfunctional as some people might say, but I don’t think it’s functioning at its highest capacity.
The Pirates don’t have anything close to a Hornqvist. I think they have a bunch of decent guys, but they’re very quiet, with little mileage on the tires. I think morale has taken a hit because of that.
If I’m building that group for next year, I’m absolutely looking for someone who can serve as a little bit more of a veteran voice, someone to set the tone, someone to help give them a bit of a swagger. I think they’ve missed that, and I think it has hurt morale.
Nick Cammuso (@npc210): Do you sense any anger within the organization about what is happening? You certainly don’t see it from Clint Hurdle and Neal Huntington’s comments.
Jason Mackey: Honestly, no. And that’s scary.
I tweeted a picture of PNC Park a couple weeks ago, mostly empty, before the start of a game against the Marlins.
If I’m in charge, that would worry me from a market penetration standpoint. The worst thing fans can be is apathetic, and I’m scared we’re headed down that path.
That’s not good for the Pirates, and it’s not good for those who cover this team, to be perfectly honest.
On the field, I also don’t get it. I asked manager Clint Hurdle after Sunday’s game about the pitching and how he tries to keep guys from getting too down when they’re getting clobbered.
I don’t think Hurdle appreciated it. Then he turned it around and said he doesn’t seem to share the same concern that I seem to have about club’s pitching.
That’s fine, but their ERA is 5.23. Only the 1930 team (5.24) has been worse since the 1800s. I get wanting to stand behind your guys, but they probably should be concerned at this point.
I also don’t think it would be the worst thing in the world for those decision-makers in that franchise to act like they’re upset — assuming they are.
I think that’s all fans want: an honest day’s effort and for those in charge to care as much as they do. I can tell you from the Penguins side, those guys cared when they lost. Jim Rutherford remains one of the nicest people I’ve ever dealt with in this business, but after a loss, he’s flat-out furious.
Mike (@miker8771): Do you regret being a beat writer for one of the worst-run franchises in the history of sports?
Jason Mackey: Just to clear this one up, because I get it a lot. I’m not the beat writer for the Pirates. I cover the Pirates for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
I’m not a fan. Other beat writers aren’t fans. As I’ve been told by older writers on our staff, they win, we write. They lose, we write.
Sure, it’s easier formulating stories during happy times, when everybody is more willing to talk. But it doesn’t change my day any if the Pirates lose.
The only thing that changes is the tone of my writing. I can’t cover the Pirates the same way I would cover the Penguins.
I hope I’ve done a good enough job in that regard, although I’m sure I could probably get better. At minimum, it’s not some sort of bummer for me that I have to cover a bad team.
If anything, it’s a challenge to continue to write interesting stuff when things aren’t going well. These guys are still Major League Baseball players (save the jokes), and it’s still a team people care about, even though the fan sentiment is obviously different than it is with the Penguins.
Thanks, as always, for reading. This season is coming to a close fast, and I never taken the participation here for granted. So, thank you.
Until next time …
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.