CHICAGO — Chris Archer saw this coming.

With two weeks left in the season, and without the ability to throw pain-free, Archer began to get a little suspicious that he would pitch again in 2019.

Speaking before Sunday's game at Wrigley Field, general manager Neal Huntington made it official: The Pirates have shut Archer down for the season.

The Pirates have called Archer's injury right shoulder inflammation. Archer has since clarified that it's actually tendinitis in his right biceps.

Advertise with us

"We just ran out of time," Archer said. "We had a game plan if everything went well. It didn’t go perfectly, so there’s no point in trying to force anything to happen.

“There’s still a little bit of soreness in there. As opposed to continuing to throw through it, we might as well continue to rest it."

Archer will finish the year 3-9 with a career-worst 5.19 ERA, though the Pirates are expected to pick up his $8.25 million contract option.

He flashed signs of improvement during the second half, when he got back to being more of a strikeout pitcher, but Archer’s right arm ultimately did not cooperate.

Sunday’s news came after both sides were cautiously optimistic Archer would throw a side session either this weekend or next week back in Pittsburgh. Now, that won’t happen.

Advertise with us

Huntington believes Archer shutting it down now will be enough for the injury to heal. The 30-year-old won’t require any sort of surgical procedure, and he’ll enjoy a normal offseason.

“Let’s turn our attention to offseason prep, let him have a great baseball offseason, which he hasn’t had as a Pirate,” Huntington said. “Last year he was rehabbing the abdominal surgery, as Joe Musgrove was.

“In my time, I’ve come to recognize that that is a huge factor in a player’s season the next year. We’re excited for Chris and Joe to have a baseball offseason, come in next year and be the pitchers we expect and need them to be.”

Archer said he’ll start gearing up in mid-to-late October. Building on that second-half success would've been nice, but he also didn't want to risk anything with his long-term health.

"It stinks because it puts our team in a tough position," Archer said. "I was feeling a lot better the second half of the season, but I think the smart play going forward is to come back fully healthy, have a normal offseason like Neal said and continue to fine-tune the things that I found in the second half and maybe even find ways to get better."

Advertise with us

Other shutdowns?

Huntington said the Pirates are working through two other health-related situations with Josh Bell and Starling Marte, though they’re hopeful neither will be lost for the season.

Bell has been unavailable the past two days because of left groin discomfort, which knocked him out of Friday’s game. Marte has been available only to pinch-run because of a left wrist sprain.

Both players will be further evaluated in Pittsburgh, Huntington said. If there’s additional injury risk, Huntington said they’ll be shut down. If not, the Pirates are content to let them work through things.

“There’s always value in players finishing healthy if the calendar allows them to,” Huntington said. “If there’s risk for further damage, then the shutdown becomes easy.

Advertise with us

“If it’s just an inflammation thing that they’re battling through, then the ideal situation becomes that they work themselves back when they’re ready to go.”

Fight talk

Huntington could trade Felipe Vasquez this summer. He could also trade Kyle Crick. But neither deal, Huntington said, would have anything to do with last Monday’s fight involving the Pirates relievers.

“As we sit here today, if there’s an opportunity to improve the club, if there’s an opportunity to take some of our right-handed depth to add to our left-handed depth, if there’s an opportunity to get an elite return, that’s a decision we make regardless of what happened between those two,” Huntington said.

As for the situation itself, Huntington said the Pirates need to move on and improve their clubhouse culture as a result.

Advertise with us

Huntington didn’t expound on how the Pirates planned on doing that — it would probably be a lengthy answer — but he did explain why they announced the fight instead of trying to ignore that it happened.

“We put a ton of public scrutiny on ourselves because we wanted to handle it the right way,” Huntington said. “There were a handful of situations this year in other clubhouses that weren’t handled directly or publicly. We felt that this was the right thing to do in the situation.

“We want to learn from it. We want to grow from it.”

Offseason priorities

It should be a busy offseason for the Pirates and Huntington, assuming he stays in his current role.

Advertise with us

Two of the boxes they must check came up on Sunday — helping players better transition from Class AAA and also the pitching problems the Pirates have experienced.

They begin Sunday’s game with a 5.16 ERA, fourth-worst in baseball.

“Unfortunately we’ve had a second consecutive year in which our young players coming from Triple-A to the big leagues have had challenges,” Huntington said. “How do we help that initial transition, and how do we get that better? It’s an answer that we absolutely have to come up with this offseason.”

Those lumps were taken everywhere. From the starting pitchers with Mitch Keller, Dario Agrazal and James Marvel to the bullpen and guys like Alex McRae, Rookie Davis and Montana DuRapau. Even position players such as Pablo Reyes, Jason Martin, Cole Tucker and Kevin Kramer.

Rarely have the Pirates been able to take a player who had been thriving at Class AAA and get that performance to translate to the big leagues.

Advertise with us

The biggest issue has been middle relief, which has contributed to 28 games where the Pirates have allowed 10 or more runs.

“We’ve said repeatedly that’s the weakest part of any team,” Huntington said. “It’s been a real challenge for us this year to keep a deficit close.”

As for the starting pitching, how in the world can the Pirates expect the results to be different when they’re seemingly set to run out the same set of guys?

Huntington said it will be about what some of these pitchers have done well previously and bringing that back.

“Every team would love to add a top-of-the-rotation guy. It’s not that we’re not looking for that,” Huntington said. “There’s reality of market size, trade acquisition cost and the ability to take some of our own guys and push them to those levels that either they’ve been or we think they can get to.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.