Joe Musgrove

PHILADELPHIA — The Pirates lost a game Monday because their bullpen faltered.

Some of it, anyway.

The rest of it was … well, sort of a mess, which can actually describe much of the 6-5, 11-inning loss they suffered to the Phillies at Citizens Bank Park, one made possible by a pair of former Pirates.

The Pirates went into Monday’s game knowing Keone Kela and Kyle Crick would not pitch, Kela because they don’t want to use him on back-to-back days after shoulder issues earlier in the year and Crick because he had already pitched two days in a row.

Advertise with us

Felipe Vazquez was “probably” going to pitch the 12th inning, manager Clint Hurdle said, but the Pirates never got there because Michael Feliz — whom Hurdle also tried to preserve — hung a slider to former Pirate Sean Rodriguez, whose solo shot ended the game.

“I just missed with my slider,” Feliz said. “[Jacob] Stallings called the right pitches.

“Ahead in the count, I wanted to get him to swing and miss or soft contact.”

That did not happen, and we’re all left to ponder the question: Why didn’t the Pirates summon a few reinforcements before the game?

The answer is fairly simple: Because they’re out of contention, and the result of this game did not actually matter, although they’d never, ever say that.

Advertise with us

If they wanted to get an extra arm, they could’ve sent Pablo Reyes to Triple-A, though they would not have been able to immediately recall him, thus taking away evaluation time.

The Pirates also considered Vazquez available — he warmed up in the ninth — though only for a possible save.

After the Pirates scored three runs in the seventh inning to take a 4-2 lead, Richard Rodriguez picked a bad time for his home run problems to return.

Rodriguez had allowed just one home run since May 31 but served up two in the eighth, a solo shot to Bryce Harper and a two-run homer to Corey Dickerson, who was traded to the Phillies shortly before the MLB trade deadline.

"Unfortunately we have four guys in the bullpen who have given up home runs in the last 24 hours or 30 hours," Hurdle said, talking about Vazquez and Crick on Sunday, Rodriguez on Monday and Feliz on both days. "We talked about things being contagious. I don’t know. I’ll have to look at tape.

Advertise with us

"The one was a bad breaking ball. The other was an elevated fastball that he didn’t get the location he wanted.”

Josh Bell homered in the ninth to tie the game and force extra innings.

Michael Feliz

If the lack of execution wasn't frustrating enough for fans, Monday featured a couple more former Pirates thriving away from Pittsburgh.

There was Jordan Lyles beating the Pirates earlier this month and winning three of his past five starts with the Brewers while pitching to a 2.67 ERA.

Dickerson now has 21 RBIs in 19 games with his new team, and he's hitting (.348) 8-for-23 with 11 RBIs over his past five games.

Advertise with us

Designated for assignment last season by the Pirates, Rodriguez had been 1 for his previous 20 with 11 strikeouts, a performance bad enough that many Phillies fans thought he should have been returned to Triple-A when Bryce Harper returned from the paternity list before Monday’s game.

Instead, Rodriguez belted a homer that ruined the Pirates’ night.

“That’s been one of our bigger challenges all year: keeping the ball in the park,” Hurdle said.

The Phillies hit four home runs on Monday after the Reds hit three on Sunday afternoon. On the season, Pirates pitchers have allowed 193 home runs, which ranks among the 10 worst such marks in baseball.

That the Pirates even got to that point was rather mystifying. It seemed several times like the Phillies were going to win the game.

Advertise with us

Like in the ninth inning, when Chris Stratton loaded the bases with one out before getting a popout to first and striking out Harper. Or in the 10th, when the first two Phillies reached before Starling Marte made a terrific catch in center and doubled off J.T. Realmuto at second base, with Kevin Newman making a terrific scoop on the play.

Then Adam Frazier catching a liner from Cesar Hernandez to end the inning, the ball barely avoiding the dirt.

“So many plays where you felt like, ‘Gosh, we have to win this game.’ ” Joe Musgrove said. “Sometimes it doesn’t go your way, but I feel good about the way we played. I know everyone here feels good about the way we played. We have to try to carry that into [Tuesday].”

That Stratton pitched as long as he did was sort of astonishing. Since last Thursday, the reliever had thrown 110 pitches spread over two outings, including 50 on Monday.

But that’s what the Pirates signed up for by deciding to rest Kela (47 pitches during outings Aug. 23 and 25) and electing not to use Vazquez (30 pitches in the same games). Crick not pitching a three consecutive day is fairly standard for relievers.

Advertise with us

“I think part of the rotation we use in the bullpen by unplugging guys from time to time and putting guys in different spots helps them all,” Hurdle said. “They pitch in different situations throughout the year based on who’s available that day. If a couple of your higher-leverage guys are out, then people move back.

“We haven’t wanted to pitch Keone back-to-back days. Crick had gone back-to-back days. He’s out. Feliz had pitched two out of three [days] and six out of 11 before that, a day off, and six out of 11 before that. [Richard] Rodriguez had a little bit of a break. Stratton had a couple days off. The way it played out, that may be the best not letting a team score under the most adverse situations I’ve ever seen in back-to-back innings.”

Right. But ultimately the Phillies did crack a hole in the piñata, and it spoiled a strong start from Musgrove, who allowed two runs over six.

It also snapped the Pirates’ three-game winning streak.

Musgrove had solid stuff and wound up striking out six. It looked a lot like his start on Aug. 16, when Musgrove fanned a career-high-tying nine over 7 1/3 innings, when he had all six of his pitches working.

Advertise with us

“I was able to locate a lot of my pitches,” said Musgrove, who relied on his sinker and curveball on Monday. “It’s almost a blessing and a curse having six pitches. It’s tough to keep that many pitches sharp, but it’s also nice to have that many options.”

Too bad for the Pirates, none of those options could pitch out of the bullpen.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.