A weekend sweep of the Cincinnati Reds gave the Pirates something to feel good about, although it didn’t make general manager Neal Huntington’s job for the rest of this season and beyond any easier. There’s still plenty of frustration from the fan base — and rightfully so — for the second-half slide that has taken the Pirates from 2½ games out of the NL Central lead to the bottom of their division.
In an interview with the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette on Sunday afternoon, Huntington shared some of his big-picture thoughts on the Pirates, his own job and what he hopes to fix for next season.
Among the conclusions to draw are these: It doesn’t sound as though the Pirates will be making any in-season changes, although Huntington — and his bosses — are definitely not OK with how things have transpired since they were knocking on the door at the All-Star break.
“The focus is doing our very best to put a winning team on the field because that’s what the fan base is starving for,” Huntington said. “We’ve done it. We heard it in 2010. We heard it in 2011. We heard it again in 2012. The drum beat was probably the loudest in ’12. We recognize the fans’ feelings. We empathize with a lot of them. Our focus right now is to work together to get this right again, to get this back on the right track.”
How can the Pirates do that?
Huntington said a key will be assessing all aspects of what they do, from what went right during the first half to what went so drastically wrong out of the All-Star break. From developing players to analytics to personnel, Huntington said that no stone will be left unturned.
Read More
However, Huntington’s comments focused a lot on what the Pirates were doing well early on and the need to get back to that sort of performance.
“We’re going to go through a thorough assessment of who we are, what we do, why we do it, what’s worked, what hasn’t worked, how we build upon what’s worked and how we learn from what hasn’t to make it work better to get this right again,” Huntington said.
A few weeks ago on his radio show, Huntington talked about changes potentially being necessary. That still holds true, the general manager said. But it wasn’t just personnel changes to which he was alluding.
“The changes may come in terms of process. The changes may come in terms of equipment and technology. The changes could include personnel,” Huntington said. “This is not where we thought we would be. We were excited about the group that was 2½ games out coming out of the All-Star break. Much of that same group is still here.
“We want to recognize why this is similar to 2012. That team finished with a really tough stretch and the core of that team was the same team that went out and won 94 games in 2013. We also need to understand why it’s different and what can we do to turn the ship, what can we do to finish strong, what can we do to build momentum for next year.”
As for the personnel part of that answer, Huntington said the process has already begun.
And no, the Pirates haven’t secretly fired anyone. It’s more about learning from the struggles of 2019.
“In terms of personnel, we’re already having conversations about lessons learned in the process, lessons learned with technology, lessons learned with how we’re making decisions and how we’re impacting the players,” Huntington said. “We’re already making some adjustments, and we’re already working to get back on track.”
Many fans have called for the Pirates to clean house by firing Huntington, president Frank Coonelly and manager Clint Hurdle.
Huntington has absolutely heard those criticisms and understands the frustration.
The GM said that everyone’s performance will be evaluated at the end of the season, his included, to see where the Pirates can get better.
“We’re going to go through an assessment process top to bottom, myself included,” Huntington said. “What we’ve done that’s worked, what hasn’t worked, and how do we put the best group together going forward? We got here together. I fully anticipate we’ll pull out of this thing together.”
Another familiar refrain has been the idea of a rebuild, to blow this thing up and start over. Huntington was a little more resolute when presented with that possibility — he doesn’t see it happening.
Teams that rebuild, Huntington argued, often aren’t 2½ games out of first place at the All-Star break. They also don’t have some of the young pieces that the Pirates do in Josh Bell, Bryan Reynolds, Kevin Newman and others.
Which is why Huntington doesn’t foresee a rebuild on the horizon — and yes, he actually did use the word.
“I think as teams rebuild, they rebuild for a number of reasons,” Huntington said. “They’re non-competitive. They’re aging. They have a lot of players nearing free agency. They don’t have a very good farm system.
“Sixteen of the 25 players who got us to within 2½ games of first place are young [with three years of service time or less]. We have other players coming in behind with Mitch Keller, Ke’Bryan Hayes and Oneil Cruz on the horizon. You get JT Brubaker healthy, we’ve got a lot of good, young arms. If you look at the boxes to rebuild that you check, the one that we check is non-competitive.
“The young players, we feel like we have those guys who we can build around going forward. The prospects on the horizon, we feel like we have some of those guys going forward. Unfortunately, we tried to retool and compete as we were turning some things over, and our won-loss record looks more like a rebuild than a retool. That’s on us. That’s on me.”
Expanding that sentiment a little more, Huntington name-checked a variety of key pieces. Not only Bell, Reynolds and Newman, but also Felipe Vazquez, Michael Feliz, Richard Rodriguez, Kyle Crick and Keone Kela in the bullpen; Chris Archer, Trevor Williams and Joe Musgrove all potentially “turning a corner” in the rotation; and the improvements that Colin Moran has made with his power numbers to go along with Starling Marte in center field.
Keller, Cole Tucker and Hayes will have more prominent roles in the future, Huntington intimated.
“Again, I hate to keep coming back to the 2012 team, but as you start to look at Josh Bell and Bryan Reynolds and some of the arms that have had success and the prospects that are on the horizon and how that team turned a corner, we need to work hard to help this team turn a corner,” Huntington said.
One last thing that seems to bother the fan base involves owner Bob Nutting. Not only wanting him to spend more, but also wanting to get his thoughts on the team’s tailspin out of the All-Star break — again, aside from this past weekend.
While Nutting has not spoken on the matter, Huntington has been in regular contact with the Pirates owner and said that he’s been bothered by what has happened, too.
“Absolutely,” Huntington said. “Bob is engaged. Bob is involved and asking the right questions. He’s challenging us to get this right again. We certainly respect his role as owner. Frank is doing the same in his role as president.
“We understand the fans’ feelings about this season. We share most of those feelings and are working to get it right again.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.