Neal Huntington spoke Sunday to the Post-Gazette’s Jason Mackey and did his best to put a positive spin on the future of the Pirates. As incredible as that seems given where this season has gone, he is still out there fighting the good fight and trying to convince people that he hasn’t horribly mismanaged this roster.
He talked glowingly about the “young” core of players and brought back the ridiculous comparisons to the 2012 season. He again put on full display his incredible ability to use selective numbers to paint a rosy picture and again took the condescending approach that fans and media create narratives that just aren’t true.
He explained that a total rebuild and house cleaning is not necessary and that there is all kinds of hope on the horizon. He said there are plenty of excellent young players on the horizon in the Pirates’ minor league system.
“Sixteen of the 25 players who got us to within 2 1/2 games of first place are young [with three years of service time or less],” Huntington said, as if that is supposed to mean something. He then followed that with some pie in the sky nonsense about how the changes necessary are simply to “equipment and technology.”
Oh, we get it now! It isn’t that the Pirates don’t have enough good players, have assembled a mediocre roster, have drafted horribly and have been poor at developing players. Nope. It is that they needed a new video machine. Perhaps their X-Ray machine is as bad as the one at Oakland Coliseum and maybe they just need a new cryotherapy chamber to see improvement.
Please, Neal, my man, just stop with this nonsense. I give him a lot of credit in that he seems to really believe most of what he says, but he should stop treating us like idiots. This isn’t a good baseball team by any measure and this idea that hope is around the corner is borderline delusional.
Read More
They have played a little better this past week, so I am sure Huntington and his apologists are already putting together their “we finished strong and that’s who we really are” line of nonsense.
It all sounds so wonderful until you get beyond the talking points and look at the numbers. And that’s what I would challenge anyone to do when assessing this season — forget about the talking points, look at the numbers. The numbers that are relevant to me are the won-loss record, the won-loss record against teams with winning records, where the team finishes in the division and the run differential.
The Pirates are 55-75. They are going to finish with a losing record for the third time in four seasons and 8th time in Huntington’s 12 seasons as general manager. There is a decent chance they will finish with 90 or more losses. That is reality, and the only reality that matters.
They are in last place in the National League Central, 5 1/2 games behind the Reds for fourth place and 16 1/2 games behind the Cardinals, who are in first place.
The Pirates have achieved a winning record over only four (all bad) National League teams — the Marlins, the Giants, the Padres and the Reds. Huntington likes to use selective numbers to suggest the Pirates are better than we think, so how about this one: Take those four bad teams out of the equation and the Pirates are 22-62 against the National League. The top three teams in the NL Central division (Cardinals, Cubs and Brewers) are 32-13 against the Pirates.
The Pirates also have a run differential of minus-109 and that is after a weekend sweep of the Reds in which they were a combined plus-16. Huntington likes to point out they were “2 1/2 games out at the All Star Break” which is true. It is also true that at that point they had a losing record, a run differential of minus-36, the fifth-worst record in the National League and were kept afloat by a division full of underachieving teams.
That means even at the height of this season, the Pirates were in fourth place in their own division and one of the worst teams in the National League. And despite Huntington’s best attempts to minimize the stat, their run differential suggested it was only a matter of time before the bottom fell out.
The Pirates need to be rebuilt. The front office needs to be purged of just about every significant decision maker and director in it. The organization needs a fresh start, a fresh set of ideas and a different course than the one it is on. The Huntington spin cycle may still work on the shrinking segment of fans who have bought what he has sold for so long, but it can’t overcome the numbers that tell the bleak story of this team and this season.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.