Clay Holmes

Take what transpired at PNC Park Tuesday, the eighth-inning rally, Starling Marte’s three-run home run, a four-out performance from Felipe Vazquez, a win manager Clint Hurdle called “one of the best team victories we’ve had all year,” and put it on ice.

Or at least don’t lose focus on a key storyline to come out of the Pirates’ come-from-behind, 4-1 defeat of the Nationals, the fact that Chris Archer left the game before the start of the second inning with right shoulder discomfort.

"This was a complete team win," Richard Rodriguez said through team translator Mike Gonzalez. "It’s sad to see what Archer went through. That’s one of our teammates, but it’s awesome to show not only him but the rest of the team that when one man goes down, the rest of the team will stand up for him."

On his fifth warmup pitch, Archer sailed one high over Jacob Stallings’ head. The two chatted. Then manager Clint Hurdle and head athletic trainer Bryan Housand joined the conversation. Archer walked quietly to the dugout, his night over after just 17 pitches.

Advertise with us

Nobody knew much postgame, and Archer was not available. Hurdle said nothing more would be known until Archer had an MRI.

The injury comes at a time, too, where Archer was seemingly starting to figure some things out, as he changed his approach out of the All-Star break. And whether you’re happy with his performance or not, the Pirates, per their general manager’s comments Sunday night, were counting on Archer being a meaningful part of the rotation in 2020.

Again, hold that thought. At least until the MRI results come back.

For now, though, the Pirates had all kinds of things to celebrate in this one, a victory that looked like another snoozefest, one where their offense languished, until the eighth inning.

Bryan Reynolds drove in one run with his sacrifice fly, a welcomed change after the Pirates left the bases loaded three times in Saturday’s 2-0 loss to the Cubs.

Advertise with us

Marte then clobbered a fastball from former Pirate Daniel Hudson to right center, the latest part of his post-All-Star break power surge.

While the rest of the Pirates have struggled, Marte has been probably their most consistent offensive producer.

Marte now has 10 home runs, 28 RBIs and 31 runs scored since the All-Star break. Which means that, of their 144 runs since the break, Marte has either driven in or scored 41 percent.

“That was one of his goals at the beginning of the season, to be dependable,” Hurdle said. “He’s been very, very dependable.”

Especially on the final out of the game.

Advertise with us

After Howie Kendrick made contact, Vazquez hung his head, thinking the ball was gone. Then, for whatever reason, he decided to take a look.

“Something told me, ‘Hey, look back. He’s going to make a nice play.’ ” Vazquez said. “I turned back. I saw him jumping. He got it. I was excited.”

For part of his outing, though, it looked like Vazquez might experience the same fate as Archer. After throwing a breaking ball — and admitting he maybe tried a little too hard to get it to move — Vazquez felt his back tighten.

Again Hurdle and Housand came out to the mound, but Vazquez was able to shake it off. Turns out he thinks he tweaked something while hustling down to first in the bottom of the eighth.

“I shouldn’t have done that,” Vazquez joked.

Advertise with us

Another encouraging sign when it came to what happened after Archer left. Needing to cover eight innings, the Pirates turned to Clay Holmes, who has experienced plenty of ups and downs.

Using a lot of breaking stuff — and struggling a little with his control — Holmes gave the Pirates a “big shot in the arm” with 3⅔ innings of one-run ball, turning what could be a terrible situation into a winnable game.

“Clay Holmes really picked us up,” Hurdle said. “That’s his best performance of the year. With a lot of separation between the next one.”

Holmes said the biggest factor was his ability to throw both his curveball and slider. The four walks need to be tamped down, but as the Pirates search for bullpen fixes — no, it’s not just the starters — Holmes remains an intriguing possibility.

“I think it was a much-needed outing for our team and for myself,” Holmes said. “I was just glad to give our team a chance to win and put the guys in the [bullpen] in a good situation.”

Advertise with us

The best situation, of course, will involve Archer, who had given the Pirates quality starters in four of his past seven. Neal Huntington talked on Sunday about Archer needing a baseball offseason, not rehabbing any injuries.

Should this shoulder issue be somewhat serious, maybe that doesn’t happen. The Pirates also need to make a decision on whether to pick up his $8.25 million option for next season. More time would certainly help.

But the fact of the matter is that Archer has actually been a halfway decent pitcher in the second half. Obviously the Pirates would like to see him continue to make progress.

“I don’t touch that,” Hurdle said of knowing more about Archer’s shoulder. “There’s no way to know until we send him in to get an MRI, and the doctor will look at him [Wednesday].”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.