Hello and welcome to this week’s Pirates mailbag, bubbling with positivity as always. Thanks for the participation now and this entire season. As always, if you have questions, tweet me (@JMackeyPG) or send me an email (jmackey@post-gazette.com).

Kevin (@kevinalthouse2): Will [Clint] Hurdle be around next year?

Jason Mackey: I think this is the money question right now, Kevin. And if I had to wager a guess, honestly, I would say no.

I think the Pirates know they need to change something. How could they not? And I think Hurdle would be a logical choice — even if I don’t think this is all his fault.

Advertise with us

There is a reasonable exit strategy here. If the Pirates want to move on from Hurdle, they could work something out where he basically retires and does it on his own terms.

Meanwhile, you could look for them to turn things over to Jeff Banister, Tom Prince or — here’s a name that interests me — Andy Barkett, who used to manage Class AAA Indianapolis.

Whatever they do, I think it will have to be cheap, since they’re already going to be paying Hurdle. But given what a mess this season has become, I can’t see them bringing everyone back. I just can’t.

Mike Moore (@MichaelMooreNB): Will they fire any management?

Jason Mackey: By this, Mike, I’m assuming you mean general manager Neal Huntington. I understand people screaming for president Frank Coonelly to lose his job; however, it’s not like Coonelly is making day-to-day baseball decisions.

Advertise with us

Any move with Coonelly would likely be a part of something bigger, and I’m not sure I see that happening at this point.

As for Huntington, I don’t know how it’s not at least considered. I understand the constraints in which he has to work, which aren’t great. However, the Pirates have not drafted, developed or traded well enough during Huntington’s tenure, especially recently.

And if they’re not going to spend money — a gigantic spending spree wouldn’t move them out of MLB’s lower-third — then they have to be better at the aforementioned tasks.

Bottom line, I think both should be on the table: changing the manager and/or management. However, I would said the more likely of the two involves the manager.

Paul Sapienza (@psapienza): What was the point of Neal Huntington's simulation comment?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I think what Neal was trying to say is that this wretched stretch is a statistical anomaly. I think.

I also think it only infuriated the fan base, which was already pretty mad. That and the admission they wouldn’t pursue a front-of-the-rotation starter to replace their injured front-of-the-rotation starter.

Regardless of what a simulation might say, even if it’s 100 percent correct, who wants to hear that? Is there actually someone out there who was like, “Oh, they’ve completely stunk since the break. I’ve been mad about it, too. But if the computer simulation says it’s rare, then I can live with that.”

I give Huntington credit here for resisting the cliche. Love it or hate it, it’s not canned garbage. But I think there’s such a thing as reading the room.

How about …

Advertise with us

“Nobody in here likes this. Nobody here expected this. This isn’t good enough. We all need to look in the mirror and figure out a way to never, ever let this happen again.”

That’s what I would have said.

Mark Maradei (@coachmaradei): How can the fan base, even the diehards, buy into Huntington at all when they expect steps toward a championship but management is still trying to go .500?

Jason Mackey: This is another question stemming from Huntington’s radio show, and I think it’s a really good one.

Short answer: Honestly, I don’t know. I thought it was pretty bad that Huntington basically said they went into this season thinking they would be a .500 club — then things got cataclysmically worse.

Advertise with us

Didn’t Bob Nutting say during spring training that the Pirates’ goal every year is to win a World Series? How is your goal to win a World Series if you’re starting the season with a club you think will go .500?

Those two assessments or goals don’t jibe.

If I’m a fan, that comes off as insulting or condescending, thinking I’m not smart enough to connect those dots.

And if you weren’t expecting .500, then why even bothering using the simulation line to justify going 7-28 or whatever since the All-Star break?

Paully D (@NoBigDill6): If you're Neal Huntington, what prospects do you bring up on Sept. 1? And who loses their 40-man spot if you're selecting players not on the 40?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: If I’m Neal Huntington, there are a couple guys I’d like to see.

I disagree on their stance with Ke’Bryan Hayes. (They don’t think he’s ready, and Huntington said so Sunday.) If he’s close, I want to see what he can do at this level. And don’t tell me a cup of coffee in September is going to ruin the kid’s confidence. At minimum, regardless of what you think about his hitting, he has an MLB-ready glove. Let him see what it’s like.

I’d also want to see how Will Craig’s power translates. Maybe he showcases himself for the offseason. Maybe he gives them something else to think about.

The other guy I want to see is starting pitcher James Marvel. The guy is 4-0 with a 2.74 ERA with Class AAA Indianapolis, although he did have a rough last start, giving up five earned runs over three innings.

However, before that, he allowed a total of three earned runs over his five previous starts combined. The Pirates need to be exhausting all options when it comes to finding starting pitching.

Advertise with us

I can’t figure out why Marvel, to this point, has not been given a chance. It’s not like the competition has been fierce.

Clearing spots wouldn’t be hard. Alex McRae has a 9.98 ERA, and Yefry Ramirez is at 7.36. Believe they could also transfer JT Brubaker to the 60-day injured list.

Melissa Piper (@mfpiper): Is Jacob Stallings everyone's "personal catcher" now?

Jason Mackey: Good question, Melissa. I think we have probably moved past the “personal catcher” phase with Stallings into “best available option” territory.

Stallings has been charged with just two errors in 419 1/3 career innings behind the plate, and he’s hit .280 since June 16. (Elias Diaz is at .223 during about the same time period.)

Advertise with us

Does that mean Stallings is the Pirates’ future at the position? I hope not. They need more. But I do think he’s a better player than Diaz, who threw another ball away last night.

Next season, I would be fine with Stallings as my backup, but as I’ve been saying, I really think they need to seek to upgrade that position via free agency.

Rieder79 (@rieder79): Is there any faith in the Pirates organization? Can baseball step in and force management to make changes? I have lost all faith in any change happening with statements coming from Huntington and Hurdle.

Jason Mackey: I don’t think there’s anything baseball can do to change the Pirates, although you bring up an interesting point.

If they’re going 83-79, then I suppose MLB can’t really say much. But if this continues and say they lose 100 games for the first time since 2010 and continue to be a total disaster, then I suppose MLB would have some better ground to stand on.

Advertise with us

Also, if they continue down this path and don’t do anything to show that they care, then no, there is no reason you should trust them.

However — and I’m sure some people will say I’m nuts — I have a tough time seeing the Pirates lose 95 games this season, with some of the pieces they have, and accept it. If it’s that bad, and I think it probably will be, something will get done.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.