Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lindy Ruff and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions, which again this week are laced with Pirates-related rage and hopelessness …

Joe Hunter, @JoeHunter1980: Has any GM on any sports team regularly said as many nonsensical things as Neal Huntington?

Starkey: I don’t have the numbers, Joe, although I’m sure somebody does, given the fact that everything in baseball is quantified. But I will say this: Huntington has a terrible sense of timing, combined with a lawyerly presentation. Those are traits that can lead to this, a mind-shattering quote uttered on 93.7 The Fan the other day even as Huntington’s baseball team was bursting into flames behind him …

“If you run 10,000 simulations on teams that are supposed to be a .500 team, eight times you would run into a 4-24 stretch, according to FanGraphs. So a less than 1% chance of what we just experienced. What we experienced was real.”

Advertise with us

It still is, because the Pirates are still on pace for the worst post-All-Star break record of all time and just got embarrassed on national television (on a Little League field, fittingly enough), then returned home to lose a game 13-0. So let’s not talk about this meltdown as if it’s in the past. It’s still happening.

This quote immediately brought to mind a Huntington quote from January. The one that went like this: “We have the ninth-best record in baseball over the last six years. We are one of a few teams that have made the postseason three times in the last seven years.”

True. But then there’s the pesky little fact that none of those postseason appearances resulted in a series win (Pirates have not had a playoff series win since 1979), none were the product of a division title (none since 1992) and none had occurred in three years. That is now four years — although, how could I forget, the Pirates are “still in it, technically.”

Looking closer at the simulation quote, this is what I hear: We got unlucky. Like … This never happens to anyone, and it happened to us. Can you believe it?

I’m sure it’s also heartening to know the Pirates were “supposed to be a .500 team.”

Advertise with us

Anyway, this whole thing also reminded me of when a different regime put Tike Redman in the 3-hole because that is what something like 3,000 computer-simulated games told them to do (the Pirates went 4-2,996 in those games, by the way).

It also got me to thinking about how things haven’t been this ridiculous since the early 2000s, and how you might as well laugh instead of cry. So let’s look at some of the better quotes of the early 2000s, because Huntington isn’t the only guy to put together some memorable words ….

• “This story is bigger than Israel-Palestine. It’s amazing. We’re talking about bottled water.” — Pirates owner Kevin McClatchy, at a news conference to reverse policy that bans fans from bringing bottled water into PNC Park.

• “Did you think he was going to be safe?” — Manager Jim Tracy, responding to question about why Jeromy Burnitz dogged it to first on a grounder.

And my personal favorite:

Advertise with us

• “We feel comfortable projecting him as a No. 3 starter.” — Dave Littlefield, on the day he drafts Bryan Bullington first overall, ahead of B.J. Upton.

MFH, @FakeHoltzy22: I’d like to revisit a question from a couple weeks ago. Do your computer simulations show the Pirates will lose 100 games this year?

Starkey: My simulations show it’s quite possible the Pirates will lose their final 38 games, Mr. Fake Holtzy. To lose 100, they would need to go 11-27, a winning percentage of .289.

Impossible, you say? The Pirates are 7-28 since the All-Star break, an even .200 winning percentage. Which means they still have a shot to out-do the 1935 Boston Braves for the worst post-All Star break record of all-time. Those Braves went 17-63 (.213) down the stretch.

With this team, all things are possible.

Advertise with us

OK, quick timeout for a Twitter Poll, and this one really jumped off the screen. Nearly 6,000 people responded to a question posed by The Fan’s Andrew Fillipponi (@ThePoniExpress). These were the results:

“Do you still have faith in Pirates management?”

Yes: 3%

No: 97%

What we learned: There’s not a lot of faith in Pirates management.

Advertise with us

Now, that might not be breaking news, but to see it so starkly reflected is eye-opening — and should be to the Pirates. If they polled their season-ticket base with that exact question, I’m guessing the result would be the same or worse.

Big Ern, @BigErn_88: Shouldn’t Bob Nutting come out and at least make a statement about the current status of his team. It just looks like he could care less by being in hiding.

Scott Hicks, @ScottHi61862866: Why is Bob Nutting hiding and not speaking up about his team?

Starkey: There were multiple inquiries on this topic this week, and I would agree: Nutting looks terrible for remaining in hiding during this disaster and doing nothing.

Jim Parker, @JJsparker98: With twp years remaining in GM and manager’s contracts, it is doubtful there will be any changes. Your thoughts?

Advertise with us

Starkey: A week ago, I would have agreed, Mr. Parker. But at least in Hurdle’s case, I’m budging ever so slightly. I mean, how can a manager, anywhere, in any market, survive this disaster? If Hurdle were fired today, I would have to believe nobody in baseball — including him — would be all that shocked. And here’s the thing: The Pirates could replace him in-house for a pittance.

I’m not saying I’d bet on that. I’m just saying I’m beginning to budge.

CharDeeMacDennis, @CharDeeMacDen12: Should the Steelers consider carrying only two QBs?

Starkey: I like three, just in case. I’m also intrigued by Devlin Hodges, and not just because he is a champion duck caller.

Larry VANALLEN, @Larry Vanallen: What will the Pens do if Billy leaves for MN? This might be a bigger issue than shopping hotdog boy.

Advertise with us

Starkey: They will field a competitive hockey team, Larry. I like Bill Guerin just fine, but I’m thinking the franchise would survive.

Chris Lamber, @lambo1203: Is it good sportsmanship for a LLWS pitcher to high-five a guy who just hit a HR off of him? Or is that just weird?

Starkey: This has occurred multiple times over the years, and I have no problem with it, Mr. Lamber. I think it’s good fun, good sportsmanship, whatever you want to call it.

It’s better than throwing at a guy’s head, right?

And thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). Click here to subscribe to our daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.