Just like the Post-Gazette’s Joe Starkey, national sports media outlets didn’t love the Pirates’ few trade deadline moves.
The Pirates only made two trades before Wednesday’s 4 p.m. deadline, sending pitcher Jordan Lyles to the Brewers on July 29 for reliever Cody Ponce and shipping outfielder Corey Dickerson to Philadelphia on deadline day for international signing pool money and a player to be named later.
Notably, the team did not trade reliever Felipe Vazquez. The Dodgers had been rumored to be interested in him, but the Pirates’ asking price was reportedly too high and the team ultimately passed.
Those trades collectively inspired little more from the national sports media than a yawn.
For example, Sports Illustrated’s Emma Baccellieri gave the Pirates’ two trades a cumulative “C” grade.
“Given the number of teams who needed to upgrade their bullpens, it’s striking that Pittsburgh didn’t move Felipe Vazquez (or Keone Kela),” she wrote. “Vazquez, particularly, seems like he could have yielded a significant return ... Plus — only cash in return for Corey Dickerson?”
Read More
CBS Sports’ Mike Axisa was less generous, as the Pirates only earned a “D” grade in his estimation.
“The Pirates did the bare minimum at the trade deadline,” he wrote. “Ace closer Felipe Vazquez stayed put, as did useful veterans Melky Cabrera and Francisco Liriano. GM Neal Huntington told reporters ... he kept Cabrera and Liriano to provide veteran leadership. That seems ... unnecessary.”
Bleacher Report’s Zachary D. Rymer broke down both trades individually and even gave separate grades for how each team was impacted.
For the Lyles trade, he gave the Brewers a “C+” and described him as a “much-needed warm body.” The Pirates actually won this trade in Rymer’s calculations, as he gave the trade a “B” for the Bucs and said Ponce has a shot to be “a solid major-leaguer in the near future.”
As for the Dickerson trade, Rymer gave the Phillies an “A” and said that team got “a pretty good deal on a pretty good rental.” He could only give the Pirates an “incomplete” grade due to it being impossible to fully evaluate the move until we know which player the Pirates acquired from Philadelphia.
Elsewhere, ESPN’s deadline tracker had this to say of the Lyles trade: “The Brewers definitely needed some rotation help, but it's hard to see Lyles (9.58 ERA in eight starts since the end of May) as the answer.”
Few other outlets addressed the Pirates’ moves directly, as they were overshadowed by flashier acquisitions, particularly the Astros getting pitcher Zack Greinke from the Diamondbacks.
Some, however, did criticize the Dodgers for not going all out to lock down Vazquez.
Both ESPN’s David Schoenfield and Yahoo! Sports’ Mike Oz classified the Dodgers as a “loser” of the trade deadline for not adding Vazquez or another comparable rotation piece to its lineup.
The Ringer’s Zack Kram gave the Dodgers more credit than those two for holding on to its top prospects.
“In the Dodgers’ defense, their push for Pirates closer Felipe Vazquez was reportedly thwarted by Pittsburgh’s prospect demands: The Dodgers have two top-10 prospects and Pittsburgh wanted one or both, but even an elite, cost-controlled reliever isn’t worth that trade-off,” he wrote.
The Pirates may not have made much of an impact on the MLB landscape at the trade deadline, but it is possible that the Dodgers not ending up with Vazquez may have a tangible impact on the outcome of the 2019 World Series.
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxel222






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.