BucsFanMD: I support the idea of trading Vazquez for a combination of Lux, Ruiz, and Mays but I also have no confidence in the Pirates organization to develop these guys. What would you say is the floor for each of these guys?
Greg: Do you think Felipe gets dealt?
Bill Brink: If I had to make a call, the answer is no, but there are very compelling reasons to do it. I spoke yesterday with some people from other teams; it seems as though Gavin Lux isn't going anywhere. Let's say they could pull off Keibert Ruiz or Dustin May; that would be a real jump-start to the near future of their farm system. And with the uncertainty around Jameson Taillon and how bad Chris Archer has been (it's to the point where declining his option has to have entered the conversation), how confident do they feel about contending next year?
nubyjas wilborn: I made a typo in my reply to BUCSMDFAN about Lux. Sorry, I meant to say highly-touted shortstop prospect.
Chris: If the Pirates are unwilling to participate in meaningful free agency, why are they so reluctant to do at least a small rebuild (Vazquez/Marte deals) at this point? The public seems to at least be open to the concept.
Jumpin Jack Flash: Perhaps thinking too much about it, but if the Pirates trade Vazquez so soon into his very team-friendly deal, would this impact other players from signing deals with the Pirates in the future? I would think twice about signing that deal if it means the Pirates would still move me just 1.5 seasons after signing it.
Read More
Adam Bittner: The big incentive for players to sign deals like Vazquez's is to lock in that one, guaranteed pay day before injuries or struggles can derail it. Staying with a team for a long time is a possible perk, but it's not the purpose in agreeing to the extensions. So I'd be surprised if players who'd be inclined to take team-friendly deals change their mind because they're concerned they may be traded. It's about the money, first and foremost.
nubyjas wilborn: @chris I don't think the Pirates would be opposed to trading either guy if there was a return they felt comfortable with. Let's be real if the Pirates don't get great returns on either the narrative of Neal Huntington being a bad trader gets worse. If you trade either you better get a return. Otherwise, you hold them. Also, if you trade Marte, who plays centerfield?
Guest: Is it safe to assume that as long as NH and BN run the show, we're never winning a world series?
Bill Brink: Hi, Guest. No, it is not, and I say that because after a slow start in 2014 they might have been the best team in the league from like May onward, and if they'd found a way past Bumgarner who knows what would have happened. But I will agree with the premise of the question. The way Huntington must operate, given the resources he is given to work with, make it challenging to be competitive every year, let alone good enough to win a ring. You must hit more draft picks, signings and trades than not, and that hasn't been the case.
Tommy: Do the Phillies have any interest in Marte? If that happens could you resign Dickerson?
Adam Bittner: The Phillies-Marte talk has mostly been speculative to this point. Not much hard reporting to back it up, but it makes sense. There's an Andrew McCutchen-sized hole in that lineup and Marte would be a great candidate to fill it if the Pirates decide to make him available.
Mike: Assuming Taillon is back next year, the 2020 Pirates would add (some from AAA some from injuries): Taillon-SP, Keller-SP, Kela-RP, Santana-RP, Hayes-3B, Craig-RF? and Tucker-2B to a decent core. That might be enough to win a NL Central that is up for the taking. Quite an argument to hold on to Vazquez, Marte and Kela, but part ways with Dickerson, Caberera, Liriano etc.
nubyjas wilborn: It'd be a lot to assume Will Craig would be ready to play every day at RF and assuming Taillon will be back is tough considering the update we got from Todd Tomcyzk. The Pirates do feel good about their young players, but they also felt good about this year's team, so, we'll see. A lot of things will have to go right.
Ghost of AVS: Figures that the only power hitting prospect we have plays the same position as the only power hitting major leaguer we have. Should the pirates try to trade Will Myers for another teams top prospect who plays another position. A like for like trade. Does this ever happen with just prospects who may be blocked at the majors?
Bill Brink: I'll assume for the purposes of the chat that we're talking about Will Craig, who currently has 20 home runs and a .777 OPS, but 110 strikeouts in 419 plate appearances, for Class AA Altoona. The answer is probably yes because of the fact that it's first base. It's one thing to move someone out from behind the plate, or from up the middle to a corner, or TO first base, but once you're at first base there are only so many places to go. You could argue they should try to keep him because they need power, but where would he play?
MeatMaster: Can injured players be traded? Like chisenhall or polonco?
Adam Bittner: Any players under contract *can* be traded. Considering we haven't seen Lonnie Chisenhall since late March, though, I wouldn't count on it.
Austin: Over under 2.5 trades for the pirates today?
Adam Bittner: These are my official predictions for the day. So, I'd have to say over.
Alan: This deadline has to be considered a failure if the only trade that occurs is sending Lyles out, correct? Even if the return is minimal for the likes of Cabrerra, Dickerson, etc. Clearly, Vazquez needs to be dealt for the right return, but should be aggressively shopped.
nubyjas wilborn: They'll try to trade the expiring contracts for the right return. I don't know if I would consider it a failure if they didn't feel they would get fair value and kept certain guys. The Pirates don't have to shop Vazquez, it's up to teams to present an offer the Pirates can feel good about.
Kris Benson: Is Archer beyond repair? If so, what do the Pirates do with him? Trade him, DFA him, etc.?
Bill Brink: He's pitched about a full season with the Pirates (29 starts) and has a 5.14 ERA with a 5.15 FIP. He's walked four batters per nine innings. Archer doesn't qualify for the ERA title, but if he did, his 5.58 ERA would be better than only Aaron Sanchez among qualified starters, and he has allowed the most home runs in the National League. I hate declaring players done or beyond repair, but it's not looking good. Can't trade him. Might have to let him try to pitch his way out of it/pitch better so as to trade him in the offseason, or decline the optoin.
nate: Just a hypothetical, do you think Tampa Bay would trade Shane Baz today straight up for Archer?
HitEmWithTheHein: what can I do to stop being so negative about this team and its front office without actually stopping watching them?
nubyjas wilborn: PNC Park in the summer is still a nice experience. I'd say enjoy the development of Bryan Reynolds. Kevin Newman and Colin Moran have become serviceable baseball players. Josh Bell has been fun to watch even as he's struggled. Watching Jalapeno Hannah loses in the pierogi race is also fun.
ManBearPig1971: Do any pirates have a no trade clause and what do you think the pirates biggest need is going into the 2020 season.?
Bill Brink: Good question, and no they do not. As I look at it, starting pitching and catching will be the biggest needs. Their rotation next year will have, for sure, Williams and Musgrove. If it contains Chris Archer, what can they expect from him? Will it have Taillon? Will Keller start the season in the majors? What about Chad Kuhl, coming off Tommy John, and if so how many innings can he give after missing a year and a half? Brault? Agrazal? They need starting pitching.
Mark: What is Cervelli's contract status? If he is in the last year of a contract, do they try to sign him to a more team friendly deal? Thanks.
Adam Bittner: Cervelli is in the last year of his deal. He'll be a free agent this winter, and I imagine he's going to have a hard time finding anywhere close to the $11.5 million he's making in 2019. The injury/concussion situation is just too much of a wild card, so he'll likely sign for a lot less. Will the Pirates be that team? Maybe, but it's hard to see an obvious spot for him in 2020 and beyond with two younger options in Elias Diaz and Jacob Stallings in the fold.
scott: They have to move archer and Kela and cut there lose don't they? Archer is a hot mess and Kela admitted to throwing at Deitrich last night. Package them to someone for a top tier prospect....
nubyjas wilborn: Scott, you can't expect teams to give you their best players for guys you don't want anymore. That said, I think the Pirates are likely best served to let Archer finish the season and hope he finds something. As far as Kela goes, when he's healthy he's a very good reliever. But his reputation has limited his market,
Ry: What is the latest on the rumblings of Vazquez to Dodgers? Any other teams interested?
PhillyJake: Vasquez and Hayes for May, Lux and Ruiz. Who hangs up ?
Ry: Thoughts on getting a package of Pederson, May, and Ruiz from LAD for Vazquez?
Steve : Chances Vazquez gets traded 50 50 or what?
Steve : 50 50 on Vasquez being traded?
Bill Brink: I just asked around and got a "nothing yet" back on Vazquez.
Bill Brink: We're having fun talking possible trades, but if you're interested in some thoughts on trades that actually do or do not occur, we'll do a Pirates trade deadline recap podcast tomorrow. You can find it here: https://newsinteractive.post-gazette.com/the-north-shore-drive-sports-...
BucsFanMD: What are your thoughts on Jason Martin? I thought he looked good during his call up earlier in the season. Should we expect an outfield of Reynolds, Marte, and Martin for next season?
Bill Brink: Talented, and well thought of, though triple-A and the majors have been tough for him. I bet we see a lot of him in September and we'll get a better gauge on what he's capable of (though September is a bad time for evaluation because of the expanded rosters and 27 pitchers at each team's disposal). As the Pirates consider Marte's future and Polanco's health, they'll want to see what they have in Marin.
Bill Brink: Martin*
Ryan: Out of line to expect a 2020 opening day starting rotation of (in no order) Archer, Musgrove, Williams, Taillion, Kuhl? What do you guys think of that group of 5 if they can stay healthy?
nubyjas wilborn: They have a chance to be good. I wouldn't rule out Agrazal or Keller either. But yeah, as Brink said the Pirates need answers at SP. I also wouldn't count on Jameson yet.
D.J. Spin: Do you guys have any read/guess about the Dodgers ownership group? Maybe given the potential dearth of LHP options (if Giants don't sell), Friedman ends up with a directive to get Vazquez. Just something I haven't seen discussed much.
Bill Brink: That's a great question, because Friedman, despite having a larger payroll to work with, has operated in somewhat similar fashion to the way he ran the Rays, with a keen grasp of the importance of surplus value and young, talented prospects. If Huntington does his job and asks for a boatload for Vazquez, the only way he gets it from Friedman might be if someone above Friedman makes the call.
Eric: Do you think anyone is held accountable at season's end for another year of losing? Player development is very poor, as well as very poor scouting. Who in their right minds recommended trading for Archer?
nubyjas wilborn: I don't believe that Huntington, Coonelly, or Hurdle are in jeopardy. However, there are fair reasons to critique player development. On the Archer deal, the Pirates "went for it" last season. It didn't work out then or now. It happens. But I'd counter that Neal has made more good trades than bad trades.
nate: Does management really think they are close to contending or do you think that is just what they are saying publicly?
Bill Brink: I think it's more the latter than the former. They know better than we do the risks facing Taillon, and possibly Polanco, and how much injuries can affect a season. I don't think they're being untruthful (if their team stays healthy, they could contend next year) but they are likely more realistic internally.
john jas02 : Why would Huntington not trade Vazquez. He pitches every 3-4 days and the Pirates are delusional if they think they are playoff contenders next year?
Adam Bittner: Vazquez is under contract for four more seasons after this one at a very reasonable price. That's a lot of control. Enough that you can imagine him pitching for the next competitive Pirates team. Neal Huntington can't overlook that for the sake of making a big splash in the moment. If Vazquez is going to go, it has to be because the Pirates feel the deal is the best option for their long-term future and not simply 2020.
nate: is it dodgers or bust for a Vazquez deal? Doesn't Minnesota need bullpen help?
nubyjas wilborn: Nah, there are several teams interested as they should be. The Dodgers have gotten the most talk because they have highly ranked prospects. My old friends in Atlanta could use him. So could the Nats.
Matty: Refresh our memories, when the Rays got Baz as the PTBNL last season, did the Pirates have a say in that? Or were the Rays free to pick anyone not on the 40-man roster?
Bill Brink: Generally, though not always, with players to be named later, teams will agree on a small pool of players (say, three) from which the other team can select. This allows a trade to get done in a short period of time while giving the acquiring team more time to scout the youngsters in question. It was also used to circumvent the waiting period for players after they were drafted, but a rule change (call it the Trea Turner Corollary) got rid of that.
Eddie: What do you think the opening day payroll will be next year? Will the new TV deal they have to negotiate influence the offseason signings(or lack there of)
Adam Bittner: Arbitration is going to have a big impact on the number. The Pirates will have some prominent guys -- Elias Diaz, Adam Frazier, Jameson Taillon, Trevor Williams and Joe Musgrove -- eligible for the first time. The club also has to make option decisions on Starling Marte and Chris Archer, and big contracts for Francisco Cervelli and Corey Dickerson are coming off the books, so there are a lot of balls in the air that make a projection difficult before you even consider the TV contract, which is a real wild card because of the possible sale of AT&T Sportsnet. Bill broke that situation down over the weekend. I recommend checking that out while we're waiting for some news.
Adam Bittner: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/pirates/2019/07/26/Pirates-ATT-spo...
scott: off the topic of the trade deadline, Does David Bell get a multiple game suspension from last night? Especially after getting thrown out and then coming back on the field?
nubyjas wilborn: I'd think David Bell and Keone Kela are in a bit of hot water. Bell was ejected and shouldn't have been anywhere near the field. Kela not only started the whole thing but admitted to doing intentionally. Bell made physical contact with Hurdle and had been ejected rather often in his first season as a manager.
Mark: The Pirates have a chance to shed some serious payroll before the '20 season and they are already near the bottom. The Player's union would have to take action at that point, right?
Bill Brink: The union already has taken action, filing a grievance against the Pirates and three other teams alleging improper use of revenue-sharing money. I don't know what else they could do at this point, considering that grievance remains unresolved.
rcc prof: Let's pretend for a moment: let's say the pirates trade one guy, Corey Dickerson, and keep everyone else, including Cabrera, and get rid of all their double A pitchers. Next year Huntington actually is allowed to bring in three pitchers (via trade or free agency) and doesn't screw it up, why couldn't the pirates compete for a playoff spot?
nubyjas wilborn: In your scenario, we have to start with finding out what they get for Dickerson. Also, how are the Pirates "getting rid" of their "double A" pitchers? I assume you mean the pitchers that haven't performed well on the big league level? The Pirates were let down by their starting pitching this season. Pitching still wins championships so yes if the Pirates got significantly better pitching they could compete.
Buccs 72: We know about the proposed or rumored Vasquez to Dodgers trade, what are you hearing about others such as Dickerson, Cabrera and Liriano? Do you think NH is trying to peddle Archer? The Yankees are supposedly desperate for SP, I doubt they would trade much for Archer but they might take his salary off the Pirates hands? Possible?
Bill Brink: Dickerson, Cabrera and Liriano could bring back small returns, but nothing large. In Dickerson's case the Pirates might consider keeping him to try to re-sign him (though they can always try to re-sign him after the season when he reaches free agency, they won't have the five-day exclusive rights window). The Yankees' rotation needs help, but I can't imagine Brian Cashman looking at Archer's 25 homers allowed and the way he's pitching now and thinking that will play in the AL East.
Adam Bittner: Looks like the Reds are making a mid-game deal, too.
Bill Brink: Hey hey, everyone.
Don Orris: If the payroll will be much lower again in 2020, why wouldn't Nutting bite the bullet and reach a buyout with Hurdle and bring a new manager on board with a fresh approach? At this point imo the players have tuned Hurdle out and he is on collapse #6 in 9 years. His time has passed along with Ray Searage. Thoughts?
Adam Bittner: Bob Nutting's Pirates fired John Russell and Jim Tracy with time left on their deals. If they want to move on from Clint Hurdle, I don't think they'll be too worried about his contract. Performance and the working relationship with management will likely be bigger factors. As far as the clubhouse goes, his guys seemed to show some fight for him Tuesday night, didn't they?
Bill Brink: Doesn't prohibit them from attempting to re-sign him, but the guess here is they don't, unless they decide to move on from Starling Marte. Dickerson has been good when healthy with the Pirates.
Adam Bittner: So the Phillies get a Pirates outfielder and it's not Starling Marte. Makes a lot of sense to me. Andrew McCutchen is still their long-term fixture. A rental of Corey Dickerson gives them a short-term band-aid who can hopefully help them contend in 2019 and still have options in the offseason. Interested to see the possible return.
Al Owens: They should have traded Polanco to the Phillies. I'd much rather have Dickerson with us for a few more seasons than underachieving Polanco.
nubyjas wilborn: Why would the Phillies do that? We don't know when Polanco would play again this season. Meanwhile, Dickerson is healthy.
nate: If you guys were in Huntington's shoes would you need Lux to make a deal or would you settle for less?
Bill Brink: It depends on what "less" turns out to be. Let's say "less" was Keibert Ruiz, Dustin May and a third player; or Alex Verdugo-plus; you have to think about it. Now is a great time to move Vazquez given his performance, price and years of control. But if less is truly less, then no, hold him.
Mike: SP: Taillon, Williams, Musgrove, Archer, Keller, Brault, Kuhl
RP: Vazquez, Kela, Crick, Santana, Rodriquez, Feliz, Argazio
IF: Hayes, Newman, Tucker, Bell
OF: Marte, Reynolds, Polanco
Bench: Frazier, Osuana, Moran, Craig
How far off is this squad if no insane injuries? I think it could compete in the NL Central which is very balanced.
Bill Brink: The problem is the injuries already baked in, with Taillon and Polanco; Archer's performance since joining the Pirates; and the uncertainty regarding how many innings Kuhl can go after missing a year and a half. Even if everything goes according to plan, there's already problem areas, and nothing ever goes according to plan.
Brian: Whom does the ultimate responsibility of player development fall on ? I would think NH is more rooted on the business side. On a front line basis, is Searage in jeopardy ? What is the club's opinion of Altoona pitching coach Joel Hanrahan ?
nubyjas wilborn: Huntington is the general manager so the blame or glory lies with him. I haven't heard any inclination that the Pirates aren't happy with Ray. Joel is working his way up the chain.
D.J. Spin: Do you think Huntington might still stick with something like the original plan of buy & sell, despite the collapse? Obviously not rentals for this year, but maybe he can find some controllable pitching for next year, and shuffle around some prospects who seem like they might be blocked like Craig or Kramer. Or would such a deal be more likely in the winter?
Adam Bittner: It's been a slow trade market for the teams that have incentive to buy, let alone teams like the Pirates that are looking more toward next year and beyond. For that reason, I'd be surprised to see Neal Huntington make a pure "buy" of a possible big-league piece for next year. I'd look more toward the winter for moves like that. Then again, we've seen him pick up some valuable diamonds in the rough at the last minute in the past. Thinking of JA Happ and Ivan Nova. So it's not out of the realm of possibility.
Jeff from south side: Ur chat sux worse than the loser pirates
Bill Brink: Hi Jeff.
nate: Do you think adding Tucker or Newman to the Vazquez deal would help the Dodgers move on from Lux? Yes, I know they aren't in his stratosphere as prospects but still...
Bill Brink: No, neither of them are of the caliber to move the needle and they have Corey Seager for a few more years -- at which point they'll have Lux presumably ready.
Dan: Does any trade returns need to include prospective starting pitching candidates?
Adam Bittner: The Pirates absolutely have a need for starting pitching, but I don't think they can get too picky with the trade chips they have. Most of them -- Dickerson, Cabrera, Liriano, etc. -- are on expiring contracts. Not a ton of leverage there. If you're going to deal them, take the best available prospects whether they're starters or not.
GSMP: This might be a dumb question but is the GM spending all of the money that is allocated to the MLB payroll or is he spending less than his budget to perhaps add to profits?
Bill Brink: Not a dumb question; the wider pool of money that GMs have to spend got lots of different places. The rough axiom that has existed for a while is that about half of the baseball ops budget goes toward payroll. Teams might spend $10 million on the draft, $6 million on international signings, $20 million to run a farm system, plus staff and scout salaries, capital improvements, new facilities, pitching machines, etc. I would imagine Huntington spends every dollar he can, somewhere. If anyone is trying to save money, it's ownership in the form of allocating less to Huntington.
Bill Brink: Here we go on Dickerson:
Bill Brink: Pirates save roughly $2.8 million on Dickerson.
Mike: Do you really think Hurdle's job is 100% safe? Seems silly. Is it a contract issue and not wanting to pay any sort of buy-out? How about Uncle Ray? Do you feel his job is safe?
nubyjas wilborn: No such thing as 100 percent safe. However, I don't believe the Pirates will fire either as of now. A lot can change, but I don't forsee it.
Chief Powhatan: Since the Pirates' scouting department can't pick a winner in drafts why not throw in our #1 pick next year with Vazquez for Lux and a AAA pitcher?
Bill Brink: Unfortunately for all of us who like intrigue, teams can't trade draft picks (except for those granted in the competitive balance rounds). That would be much fun if they could.
Dan: Out of curiosity last time I looked at GCL Pirates team they had played something like 28 games and get this...NOONE... had hit a home run...not 1!!
Bill Brink: While we're on the subject of things that don't matter, the Pirates' second entry in the Dominican Summer League is 43-8 with an 11-game winning streak. Teenagers not hitting for power is not an issue.
Rick in Orlando: Why not keep Dickerson if you get absolutely nothing for him (PTBNL). They save a whopping 2 .8 mil. Are they really that cash strapped?
Tracy: At some point, don't the Pirates have to look at the optics of making a trade like they just did with the Phils? Money and a player to be named later? Come on.
Adam Bittner: What are you getting from Corey Dickerson that's worth paying him $2.8 million at this point? This team isn't going anywhere, and you don't have to be "cash strapped" to find motivation to cut your losses. The Pirates also have plenty of options for outfield playing time.
You're right, Tracy, the optics aren't great. Not after a do-nothing offseason that's led to a disappointing season. Practically speaking, though, saving is what bad teams should do in this situation. We also don't know who the PTBNL is yet. Last year, the Pirates gave up Shane Baz. The return could still turn out to be more than it appears right now.
Brian: Hey guys just read that the Phillies aren't giving the Pirates ANY PLAYERS for Dickerson, a pure salary dump like Nicasio a couple seasons ago. This is disgraceful if true and I hope you guys write about it and call Bob Nutting out. Awful.
nubyjas wilborn: Adam pretty much answered your question above. Also, don't sleep on the International Pool Money. A lot of great players have come from Latin American and beyond.
Brian: I think you guys need to start accepting that Josh Bell is not the superstar we all thought. He has had 6 amazing weeks and the rest of his past 2 seasons have been terrible. He hit .207 in June and is hitting under .200 this month. Last year he was bad too. And he can't throw and he is not a good 1st baseman. It might be time to think of him as Pedro 2.0. Thoughts?
Bill Brink: I would argue there is a difference between "had a bad June and July" and "Pedro 2.0," though I will acknowledge that the throwing has not gotten any better despite a ton of effort on his and the coaching staff's part. He destroyed everything he saw in May and pitchers rightfully adjusted the way they attacked him after that. He is an incredibly hard worker and smart, and he'll be able to adjust to the shifts in how opposing pitchers go after him.
Chief Powhatan: Wouldn't settle for anything less for Vazquez than a #1 prospect. Get Lux.
Dan: IMO, Pirates need to stand firm on their ask from the Dodgers for Vazquez, otherwise keep him.
nubyjas wilborn: It appears the team agrees with you two. The Pirates shouldn't feel pressured to trade Vazquez. I also feel that people who consider him a luxury aren't around the team and have no idea how much he means in the clubhouse.
Adam Bittner: Another note on the Dickerson return as we understand it at this point. International bonus pool money is involved, and that it a capped resource. Acquiring more of it allows the Pirates to ultimately spend more in acquiring international free agents than they were previously allotted. It's not sexy but it is valuable and not a simple cash savings that could mysteriously disappear into the profit margin. If the Pirates simply wanted to just save money, they'd do that instead. Acquiring pool cap space implies that they intend to spend it.
Eddie Shack: Does NH get like a 15% cut from Spend Nutting when he dumps a salary like he did with Dickerson?
Tracy: Adam, Nubyjas. I completely understand your point about the return for Dickerson. But seriously, at some point doesn't the front office need to do some PR work with the fan base? This trade is not going to go over well. It's just going to create more anger and mistrust.
Bill Brink: I'm still kicking this one around in my head, to be honest. For two months of Dickerson, the Pirates saved $2.8 million got a player and got the opportunity to spend more in the international market, which (I know you won't want to hear this, but it's true) has an increased urgency under new scouting director Junior Vizcaino. On the other hand, they have a history of salary dumps (Liriano, Nicasio, Morton) so in that context this looks bad, especially because Dickerson was hitting well, has hit well when healthy, and hit .300 while winning a Gold Glove last year.
Bill Brink: Maybe this means more playing time for Jason Martin; maybe that money will actually be used, like when the money saved on Liriano went to Nova. But yes, in the context of the perennially low payroll and lack of spending, it won't go over well.
Bill Brink: And you could argue they should have gotten more for Dickerson, though front offices (especially Matt Klentak in Philly, a young analytically savvy GM) don't love giving up much for rentals these days.
Chuck Tanner's Burner Account: How far away is KeBryan Hayes away from the big club ? Is Adam Frazier a candidate to be moved to make room for some of the young talent at the big league level ?
Chuck Tanner's Burner Account: Nubyjas, what's the #1 priority for the Pirates the balance of this season besides winning games ?
nubyjas wilborn: Hello, Chuck. There is interest in Frazier and that is a possibility especially as Kevin Newman has emerged as a real player. They still like Cole Tucker.
nubyjas wilborn: To answer your second question it would seeing what they have in certain prospects.
Scott Deel: Adam seriously you sound like a Nutting apologist. Oh boy some 'international money' let me jump up and down right now. What about the $50 BAM money each owner pocketed? Where the heck did that go? Exactly all in Nutting's pocket. Certainly not to help the team bring in quality players. All this Dickerson deal was was a salary dump. Stop shilling for the organization please.
Adam Bittner: Scott, I'm not telling you to be excited about the team getting some extra international bonus cap space. I'm explaining the difference between acquiring it and simply dumping salary. There is no practical reason to trade for the space unless you intend to spend it. Acknowledging this in a nuanced way is not the same as dismissing management and ownership's shortcomings.
HitEmWithTheHein: The pirates got international pool money for Dickerson. Who recently came to the team from this pool?
Adam Bittner: The short answer for the Pirates is no one, though other prominent young stars around baseball have been acquired through this process. The Braves' Ronald Acuna and Ozzie Albies. The Blue Jays' Vlad Guerrero Jr. Can the Pirates sign and develop guys like that? That's a valid question. Their track record at the moment suggests the answer is no. They also can't stop trying, and if acquiring bonus pool money helps in that pursuit, then it's useful.
Richard: Is it a 100% definite that Francisco Cervelli and Corey Dickerson will be gone next year?
Bill Brink: We know the answer on Dickerson (though he'll be a free agent and could re-sign) and the guess here is that the answer is the same for Cervelli. His future behind the plate is in question and it will be hard for the Pirates to pay for, and rely upon, him.
Woj from W Mifflin: Pretend u r Nutting. Give me 3 reasons why I should renew my Pirates season tickets for 2020.
Bill Brink: 1. Josh Bell hits balls into the river 2. Ke'Bryan Hayes might be playing Gold Glove-caliber defense at third base as a rookie 3. The ballpark is beautiful.
Adam Bittner: It looks like Felipe Vazquez will remain a Pirate.
Adam Bittner: The deadline has passed, but deals often are announced after 4 p.m. So stay tuned.
Dean: Does the PTBNL pool have to be set right now or could it/the player be determined on Dickerson's performance?
Bill Brink: Generally the PTBNL pool is agreed up on at the time of the deal, and I've never heard of a situation where it was contingent upon performance.
Richard: From a distance, Francisco Cervelli looks like the kind of guy who could have a career in coaching/management. Are in agreement and, if so, has any such conversation gone on within the Pirates organization?
Rick Sunner in Orlando: Have the Bucs dangled J. Bell or Craig out there as bait? Only 1 should be kept at this point.
nubyjas wilborn: He's said that he wants to be in a front office one day. To be honest, most players who've made as much money as Cervelli don't want to coach because you're working as hard as a player in many ways for not nearly as much money. I could see Cervelli start as a special advisor and do some spring work with players.
Bill Brink: I have to imagine opposing teams can do the same math we can on Craig and probably have inquired, but the Pirates have no need to be hasty there.
CampHillguy: Do you think it’s surprising Liriano and Melky weren’t traded?
Bill Brink: Yes. You figure they'd have gotten something, anything, for Melky. Liriano maybe less so considering just how beat up this pitching staff is and maybe keeping Liriano and not getting anything in return is worth more than having Geoff Hartlieb's and Montana DuRapau's arms fall off.
Gator Gal: How is it that the Dodgers are year-in, year-out one of the best teams in the league, but they have all those high-end prospects... and the Pirates finish poorly and do not?
Adam Bittner: Part of the problem is that the Pirates have not actually "finished poorly" in recent years. They've been mediocre, which means they've been toward the middle of the draft order and not getting consistent access to the top five or ten prospects in a given draft. That makes a difference over a period of years. So, too, does failing to draft and development impact guys with the picks you are given. Put the two together and the results can be uninspiring.
Buccs 72: Let's be real. International pool money cap space only counts if you SPEND it. I wouldnt trust BN to spend the money. Why acquire it? So they can say they did at the time these deals are made. Am I being unfair?
Bill Brink: It is entirely fair to criticize Nutting and the Pirates front office for not spending on the major league payroll. This is a different area entirely. Similar to my answer earlier about Huntington spending everything he can, international scouting director Junior Vizcaino will spend every cent he has to bring in talent.
Mike: Aren't you making the assumption that team mangament is trying to build a winning team? What if that assumption is wrong. What if they are trying to win just enoutgh to make a profit?
Bill Brink: I operate under the assumption that from Huntington on down the Pirates are trying to build a winning team. Their jobs depend on it (or they should; doubt Nutting would want to pay two GMs or managers). If we are to wonder about doing just enough to make a profit, we must look at what has been allocated to Huntington, and that falls on ownership.
rcc prof: Adam, I don't like the Dickerson trade at all. In one of your answers, you asked, can the Pirates sign the likes of Acuna, Albies etc.? A better question would be is there anybody in this darn organization capable of finding such players????
Adam Bittner: That is a completely valid question, and explaining the logic of the move is not the same as endorsing the Pirates' scouting and development. They could easily screw up any signings they make. What is the alternative, though? Throwing their hands up and giving up on acquiring talented international amateurs? Obviously, the answer is no. They must keep trying, as this is one of the few areas where they can compete with larger markets on a relatively even playing field.
thomastown: Doesn’t keeping Melky and trading Dickerson basically confirm that was a salary dump. Melky’s not making much money.
nubyjas wilborn: Depends on what they do with the $250,000 in Int'l pool money and who the PTBNL is. I know pool money isn't "sexy" but it could turn into a good player or two.
CampHillguy: Adam, why do you suggest the Pirates being in the middle of the draft order (the Dodgers draft in the bottom of the draft each year) or player development as the Pirates’ main problem? The main problem is that our Bob Nutting won’t allow a competive Prates payroll. Why do you ignore this obvious reality?
Adam Bittner: I was asked how the Dodgers can win and have elite prospects while the Pirates lose and do not. That's a narrower question than the Pirates' overall problems, so I gave a narrower answer.
Buccs 72: Do we know if the Pirates spent all of their international pool cap money this year?
Bill Brink: The international signing period runs from July 2 to the following June 15, so we won't know for a bit. I'm currently looking up what they spent in the most recent signing period and will report back.
CampHillguy: I know Brink wrote an excellent article on the upcoming new Bucs TV deal negotiations. Have any of you thought of the possibility of the network acquiring the new TV rights requiring a clause from Nutting that the Pirates maintain a minimum payroll - - say of 70% of the MLB average? That way we Pirates fans may have a competitive to watch on TV!!
Bill Brink: That would be an interesting twist in the negotiations, for sure. I have not thought about that, and I can't think of anything similar to that, and I feel as though that would cause a breakdown in negotiations.
Drew: Question about the timing of the single trade deadline in general. There are still four weeks until the playoff rosters need to be finalized by the contenders in which time there could be a number of key players who go down with injuries. Under the old system, teams had until the end of August to make a trade and address those late injuries. So my question is this: have you heard any thought to moving the trade deadline to mid-August? Splitting the difference might be a safeguard against the late season injuries.
Austin: Can you guys confirm the Pirates didn’t make any other trades today aside from Dickerson?
nubyjas wilborn: All sides will evaluate how it worked out this season. I enjoy having a single deadline. It forces teams to figure out who they are sooner and that streamlines the process.
Adam Bittner: @Austin, not yet. News can trickle out.
nubyjas wilborn: @Austin We do know they will not move Vazquez, Neal, confirmed it just now on a conference call.
Chuck Tanner's Burner Account: Did you see that the Astros ot Greinke from Arizona ? WOW
Adam Bittner: AL West*
Bill Brink: Deadline has passed. Any final questions?
Matthew: With the season pretty much a wash who are some young guys we could see called up in September to be excited about?
Bill Brink: I'd love to see Ke'Bryan Hayes play defense at the major league level. This season has been tough for him, but it's his first in Class AAA and he is trending back toward his April numbers in July, a month in which he has four homers after one in each of the first three months. And it'd be nice to see Mitch Keller get three starts in a row, see how he adjsuts.
Adam Bittner: Alright, gang. I'm signing off. Good talk.
Buccs 72: Thank you. I'm skeptical on this international pool money because it seems I have heard that the Pirates seldom bid on the big name international players. Why is that if they have as much or more international pool money as the teams who do bid and sign the big name players?
Golden Jim: I'm glad the Buccos got what is essentially $$ for Dickerson. What every real Pirate fan wants is for the owner to make lots of money.
nubyjas wilborn: Pool money isn't actual money. Pool money is the opportunity to spend money and the Pirates acquired the ability to spend $250,000 more than they could before. We'll see how it plays out.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.