Welcome to our weekly Pirates mailbag. Lots of questions this week. Good ones, too. Had a tough time picking.
Here’s what made it, and as always, fire away at jmackey@post-gazette.com or on Twitter @JMackeyPG.
Andrew (@avogel5491): Is there any situation where we trade Vazquez and if so is there any situation where we could get AT LEAST 2 of Lux, Smith, May, or Ruiz? I say trade tucker or Kramer with Vazquez and get Lux, Smith and May.
Jason Mackey: Andrew, I admire your aggression. You may make an excellent GM one day.
However, I have a tough time seeing the Dodgers offering the Pirates two of their top three prospects.
That being said, I think if the Dodgers are willing to give up, say, catcher Keibert Ruiz and right-hander Dustin May — I would insist on getting a front-of-the-rotation starter — then I’d definitely have a conversation. I might even do it. However, again, I have a really tough time seeing the Dodgers doing that.
Read More
I believe they refused to give up May to the Orioles during the Manny Machado discussions, and I don't think Vazquez would change their mind.
But the deal you mentioned is the type of thing Neal Huntington would have to have in order to trade Vazquez: a premium haul of prospects.
Brian Skokowski (@brianski71): Why would any GM in their right mind NOT trade Felipe Vazquez? His value will never be higher and you can rebuild the entire franchise by trading one relief pitcher.
Jason Mackey: Hi Brian. I see what you're saying here, although I disagree with the idea that the Pirates can rebuild their entire franchise around one pitcher. Even if they got a premium prospect haul, I think that goal might be a bit lofty.
Why keep Vazquez?
Well, in my opinion, because the Pirates were 2 1/2 games out at the All-Star break, despite a slew of injuries and underperformance from key players. They've also had issues in their bullpen with Kyle Crick and Keone Kela.
What if Crick doesn't turn it around? What if Kela can't get/stay healthy?
Then you're suddenly in dire straits at the back end of your bullpen, then they have another problem they must address with Vazquez gone.
Bottom line, if they feel like they can build around this young core and get some pitchers to perform better — be it Dario Agrazal or Mitch Keller, maybe a healthy Jameson Taillon — then I can see the logic in keeping Vazquez for a better season in 2020 and beyond.
Pat Clarke (@PClarke2652): When and why did you switch from covering the pens to the pirates?
Jason Mackey: I switched over to Pirates in mid-May, and I did it as sort of a bucket list thing, among several reasons.
I played baseball my entire life, through college and into my late 20s. One of the biggest reasons I got into this business in the first place was baseball writing — Dejan Kovacevic at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, Barry Svrluga, Dave Sheinin, Thomas Boswell, Adam Kilgore and Chico Harlan at The Post when I was living in Washington, D.C.
The combination of those two things, plus feeling like I had proven myself on the Penguins, I wanted to give it a shot before it was too late.
I’ve always been a big believer in trying new things and staying creative. I can think of no better way in this business than to change every fiber of what you’re doing. It’s been a lot of fun thus far, liberating and challenging all at once.
My hope is that I can prove myself as a capable baseball writer and eventually transition into a columnist role. Hopefully the coverage has been to your liking.
Zach (@fackzoltz): do the pirates trade Dickerson or Cabrera? Or both
Jason Mackey: I think it depends on the return, honestly.
If you get good return for both, then I would consider that, too. But I also think they need to be mindful of where Gregory Polanco is at, whether his shoulder is OK. If you trade both, who is going to man the third outfield spot with Starling Marte and Bryan Reynolds?
Obviously that becomes less important if the Pirates continue losing, but what I’m saying is I would not let them go for nothing, just to say I did it.
Maybe it works out that Dickerson makes sense to keep — if I had to pick one to keep, he would be it — then do that and maybe try to re-sign him next year.
Mike Flynn (@mflynn300): With Newman doing the job and earning the starting SS role, does this make Cole Tucker expendable? Not that I’d ever want to see a #1 traded, but seems logical if Newman does the job, to use him to get an arm or two
Jason Mackey: I don’t think it makes him expendable, just because Newman has shown an ability to play either second base or third.
Based on what he’s done so far, I think Newman has earned the right to play. Tucker is also the better defensive shortstop. But I could definitely see them going with Tucker at short — assuming he’s ready next year — and moving Newman somewhere else.
Now if someone values Tucker and might want him in a trade, and it makes sense for the Pirates, I also wouldn’t rule that out. I think with where they’re at right now, they should rule nothing out, outside of — in my opinion — trading away Vazquez.
York (@eYARKulation): Any chance Kuhl pitches in September?:
Jason Mackey: Not that I’m aware of. Everything we’ve heard is that these guys — Kuhl and Edgar Santana — are tracking to be ready for spring training 2020.
Les Weiss (@LesWeiss5): 1) What is going on with Reynolds, looks clueless? 2) Did the home run derby screw up Bell’s swing?
Jason Mackey: I think Reynolds is going through a slump. He’s not the first person to endure one. He’s chasing more than he should and not making solid contact when he does swing. I don’t think there’s anything fundamentally wrong with his approach or execution.
As for Bell, no, I don’t think that’s the case. His numbers, as he pointed out recently, weren’t great going into the break, either.
Bell doesn’t have enough protection in the lineup. Opposing teams are pitching around him because they can … and he’s not helping his cause by swinging at some so-so pitches, probably putting a little too much pressure on himself to do damage.
Zack Henry (@zackoff39): What do you see happening with Will Craig? Seems to have good power and run production numbers but also plays first base where one would figure there’s a bit of a block there. Does he have value; could they get a piece that has control that could help teams the next couple years?
Jason Mackey: I think Craig would have some value as a trade piece, but not a ton. He would likely require some other piece to carry a deal, but I could see the Pirates being OK moving him if they have an interested party.
Unless they suddenly implement the DH in the National League, which I don’t think they’re going to do, then you’re right: He doesn’t really have anywhere to play at the major league level.
EJM (@ejm2218): Why does pitching coach Ray Searage get praise and accolades for turning re-tread pitchers around but does not get any grief for his in-ability to develop any of the young pitchers the Pirates currently have? Their is absolutely zero consistency with any of these young pitchers.
Jason Mackey: I would argue against the assertion that Ray Searage gets a lot of praise. Honestly, I hear more criticism of him than anything.
I don’t fault him for the Chris Archer stuff. I think that was more on Archer, trying to be something he’s not.
If you want to crush Searage for young guys not developing here, fine. But I still think Tyler Glasnow is a bit of a special case. Nobody in their right mind thought he was going to develop here, and I don’t think that was all Ray’s fault. Sometimes that just happens. Guys need a change of scenery, and they figure it out someplace else.
Mitch Keller is more worrisome to me. But again, Searage isn’t working with Keller every day. It’s hard to blame one guy for that and for multiple pitchers.
Jacob (@joberdorf_23): What are your thoughts on the Pirates pitching philosophy of going for contact and the results it brings? Is it the main reason to blame pitchers such as Cole and Morton not having near the success they are having elsewhere?
Jason Mackey: I think this is an appropriate followup here.
Something that doesn’t get discussed enough with the Pirates pitching philosophy is with whom they’re trying to make it work. You can’t just automatically say you’re a strikeout pitcher. You have to have the stuff and you have to have some idea to pitch that way. No organizational philosophy is going to give a guy a nasty curveball.
Did the Pirates screw up with Gerrit Cole by making him something he was not? Yeah, I think that’s fair.
But overall, because of the pitchers they’re forced to employ, it’s tough to make non-strikeout guys strikeout guys. That’s just not how it works. You have to accentuate pitchers’ strengths, and the strengths of the guys the Pirates have had on their payroll under Searage haven’t always been strikeout-type pitchers.
Zig (@ZigMZ): 3 things Jason: One, is there any scenario where Kang is part of this team next yr-team friendly contract maybe? 2nd-w Newman's emergence, my thinking is him at 2B and Tucker at SS is middle IF of the future. Is there any scenario that precludes Tucker from being the guy? ... Third....have you seen Jason Isbell since the Pittsburgh show in 2018?
Jason Mackey: First part … no. Absolutely not. They have too many good, young infielders. More Kang makes no sense to me. Two, I like your idea, and I think that’s completely reasonable. You could even rotate Newman at second and third. The key will be Tucker showing he can be the team’s everyday shortstop. He’s shown flashes, but he needs to do it more consistently. Lastly, no I have not. Sadly. I’m going to see Amanda Shires with my wife when she comes to Hard Rock, and I couldn’t be more excited about it. But no Isbell shows for me … yet.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.