Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lonnie Smith and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Rob Gateway, @RobGateway: Will anybody be held accountable for another Pirates collapse this year or is “accountability” something this organization preaches, but doesn’t practice?

Starkey: If you mean to ask whether Neal Huntington or Clint Hurdle will be fired, Mr. Gateway, the answer is no. They are both on long-term deals, and Bob Nutting would rather throw dollar bills out of the press box, like Greg Brown and Steve Blass did the other night (loved it!) than pay somebody to sit home. I’m not saying either should be fired, mind you. I’m just answering your question, and I appreciate the term “another collapse” because we’re talking about a trend here.

Hurdle has done some wonderful things here, but it’s also true that his teams have collapsed more than the average Larry King marriage. Five times in the past eight years, by my count. And by collapse I don’t mean “fall out contention” or “play poorly.” I mean disintegrate. And with eight losses in the first 10 games since the All-Star break, this team is trending in that direction.

Advertise with us

With that in mind, let’s rank the five worst collapses under Hurdle …

5. In 2017, the Pirates evened their record at 58-58 on Aug. 11 — just three games out of the division lead. They proceeded to lose six in a row and 13 of 18 to finish the month. Season. Gone. Neither Wade LeBlanc nor A.J. Schugel could stem the tide. But I would call this a mild collapse.

4. In 2018, the Pirates moved to 61-57 on Aug. 11 — the day after Clay Holmes made a surprise start in San Francisco and got his brains beaten in. They were just four games out of a wild card spot. They proceeded to lose five in a row, nine of 11 and 11 of 14. Season. Wrecked. The gut punch here was three 1-0 losses in five games. Much as Adeiny Hechavarria tried, he could not save the season.

3. In 2016, the Pirates moved to 67-61 on Aug. 28, tied in the loss column with the Cardinals for the second wild-card spot and three games behind the Giants for the first spot. They proceeded to lose eight in a row and 12 of 14. Season. Done. The slide started with a gut-splaying loss at Wrigley Field, a game in which the Pirates led 6-3 in the eighth and 7-6 in the 13th. Neftali Feliz and Jeff Locke did some stellar relief work, combining for four innings, 10 hits, four runs and three walks. This was an epic collapse, but nothing compared to …

2. In 2011, the Pirates were 53-47 on July 25, tied for first place in the NL Central. Then along came a man named Jerry Meals, who helped send the club careening toward a 1-12 stretch. Season. Ruined. The Pirates went 18-41 down the stretch. The new catch phrase for 2012 was “Finish.” Then this happened …

Advertise with us

1. In 2012 (and I’m stealing this from DJ Gallo), the Pirates “were 16 games over .500 at 63-47 as late as Aug. 8. Their fall from that many games over .500 to a sub-.500 finish is the greatest collapse in the history of Major League Baseball, a league which dates back to the 1800s.”

Is that bad? This collapse was punctuated early by a blown 7-1 lead at home to the 49-64 Padres. James McDonald, Chris Resop and Chad Qualls participated that night.

@maxsassone: I get the reason why they bunted, but for Pete’s sake they were hitting the [expletive] out of the ball, why not roll the dice for once?

Starkey: Thank you Max. I hate bunts. The attempted Elias Diaz sacrifice was maddening for several reasons …

• It would have been the first of Diaz’s career, meaning he wasn’t exactly practiced in the art.

Advertise with us

• It killed all the momentum.

• The Pirates had three outs left in the game, and that took away one of them. Or a little more than 33% of them.

I’m just not a fan of giving away outs when you’re behind. They’re very precious.

Mark Darragh, @MarkDarragh5: Do you think the fan base is still angry at trading Cutch and getting totally fleeced In the Archer deal to ever trust anything this owner and management team does and says?

Starkey: I do not think anybody in their right mind is angry about the McCutchen trade, Mark. That was a great move, and the Pirates were a thousand percent right not to extend McCutchen. As for the Archer trade, at least they tried. Give ’em that much.

Advertise with us

Also, I was mildly surprised to see that TV ratings are up significantly this season. Attendance is up, too, although “up” was about the only way it could go. Just goes to show that even a little bit of winning will bring the eyeballs back.

Sheryl, @Serenade_az: It’s easy to blame Clay Holmes for (Monday’s game), but if the Pirates were hitting with runners in scoring position, they wouldn’t have been in that situation. Can anything be done about that, or is that destined to be the way the Bucs break my heart this season?

Starkey: That is destined to be the way the Pirates break your heart this season, Sheryl. Or at least this is: When they pitch, they don’t hit, and vice versa. We have seen this movie before.

Nick Lorensen, @daily_cbb: Why don’t more batters hold off on 3-0 counts? There were three straight balls to Reynolds in the ninth that could’ve loaded the bases for a hungry Starling Marte.

Starkey: I don’t have 3-0 stats handy, Mr. Lorensen, but I generally am in favor of giving a good hitter the green light. I don’t love players swinging at borderline pitches in that situation, however, and that is precisely what Reynolds did Monday night. Bob Walk adroitly pointed out the mistake. Giving a rookie the green light on a 3-0 pitch is a sign of enormous trust. Reynolds was overeager, perhaps a result of his late-inning failures of the previous day. Might have been a good time to flash the red light.

Advertise with us

Rick Nolan, @SDN_230: Is Dave Parker a Hall of Famer?

Starkey: If Harold Baines is a Hall of Famer, then Dave Parker should be.

Thank you, kiddies. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com). Click here to subscribe to our daily all-sports newsletter, PG Sports Feed.