Two weeks ago, the sentiment around the Pirates went something like this: Can they really pull this off? Just a game under .500 at 44-45 and 2½ back of first place in the National League’s Central Division, a playoff spot didn’t seem insane.
Now, the sentiment around the team has changed. As they try to recover from losing seven of their past nine, it has shifted to whether it makes sense to make a trade or two.
The most significant move they could make involves closer Felipe Vazquez, who has converted 21 of his 22 save chances this season and 49 of his previous 52 dating back to May 30 of last season.
Should the Pirates decide to move Vazquez, they would have no shortage of suitors, a group that would potentially include the win-at-all-costs Dodgers.
Whether or not to trade Vazquez is something that will surely be kicked around on sports talk radio and at local bars until 4 p.m. on July 31 for the MLB trade deadline.
So, let’s make a case in three points to trade the two-time All-Star and to keep him.
Read More
Reasons to deal
1. At 46-52 and 7 1/2 games out of the division lead entering Monday’s series-opener against the Cardinals, the Pirates’ playoff chances aren’t promising. Even when it comes to the second wild card, the Pirates are 5 1/2 back from that, and there are six teams ahead of them.
Having a premium closer doesn’t matter if you’re not playing competitive baseball. You’re simply sitting on one of your best assets.
2. Say what you want about the Pirates occasionally dumpster-diving, but they’ve actually done a pretty good job of that over the years with their closers, perhaps proof of how volatile that position can be.
Mark Melancon didn’t exactly have the greatest track record when they acquired him in 2013, and he wound up saving 130 games in parts of four years, fourth-most in franchise history. Jason Grilli was even less experienced when he took over, and he did fine. Ditto for Joel Hanrahan.
Why couldn’t someone else on the roster close? Kyle Crick has the stuff. Keone Kela, too. Shoot, Kela even has a bit of a track record with 24 saves for the Rangers last season.
3. The Dodgers might actually be willing to get stupid.
Los Angeles hasn’t won a World Series title since 1988, and the Dodgers have walked off losers in the past two — in 2018 to the Red Sox and 2017 to the Astros.
Furthermore, if you look at the Dodgers, their bullpen is the one thing they have that’s not elite. Their top three pitchers — Hyun-Jin Ryu, Walker Buehler and Clayton Kershaw — are ridiculous, the same for their Cody Bellinger- and Max Muncy-anchored lineup.
Adding Vazquez would be a huge coup for the Dodgers when comparing them to other World Series contenders such as the Astros, Yankees or Braves.
Plus, the Dodgers have a deep farm system and can easily afford to overpay to get what they might think is the one piece to get them over the top.
Reasons to stand pat
1. Vazquez’s contract is incredibly team-friendly. He’ll make just $4 million this season, and the Pirates can control him for a reasonable cost through 2024, when he’ll become an unrestricted free agent.
For what he is — an elite left-handed reliever who’s among the best at what he does — he should command way more than that on the open market, meaning the Pirates are getting a bargain. And you know the Pirates love bargains.
2. This team also might not actually stink. Yes, people are down on the Pirates right now because they’ve laid a gigantic egg out of the All-Star break, and a good bit of that is earned. They had an opportunity and have likely blown it.
But think about what this team might look like next year, a group obviously headlined by Josh Bell. They have a good young core with Bryan Reynolds, Colin Moran, Adam Frazier and Kevin Newman. Cole Tucker will be ready. Starling Marte should be considered among the top 10 at his position.
Pitching-wise, there are possibilities around Trevor Williams, Joe Musgrove and Chris Archer. Dario Agrazal has been very good. Mitch Keller should be ready. You would hope Jameson Taillon is healthy. Chad Kuhl and Edgar Santana will be back.
Should the Pirates think about forfeiting their season? Probably not, because they do have something worth building around. It might make sense to not kill momentum by forfeiting late leads.
3. Crick has had a rough season, especially lately, and Kela has endured problems with his throwing shoulder.
Should the Pirates trade Vazquez on Tuesday, how they would back-fill that spot remains a bit of a mystery.
Whereas in past years they had something of a clear succession plan, or at least some idea of what they’d like to do in the event they have to make a move, that’s not the case now because of what has happened to their two best setup men.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.