Neal Huntington isn’t going to get much sympathy from Pirates fans.

There’s a large subset that wants Huntington to trade everyone, twice, and maybe do it again for good measure. There’s another eager to criticize the Pirates general manager for everything from global warming to adding the wrong players and improperly selling off good ones, pretty much single-handedly ruining seasons.

Such is life when you’ve suffered through 20 years of losing — OK, only 19 were Huntington’s fault — and have failed to make the postseason the past three seasons. But sarcasm and misplaced anger aside, there’s some reality to the situation Huntington faces between now and July 31 for the MLB trade deadline: No part of this is easy.

Not the bunched-up standings, where Huntington’s club took the field Sunday as one of seven teams within five games of the final wild card spot in the National League.

Advertise with us

Not the elephant in the room that says the Pirates’ playoff chances stink, either based on sheer math (five games under .500, 7 1/2 back in the division) or past precedent (missing all but three years since the start of the 1993 season).

Not the convoluted message his players have been sending — winning five of their final seven before the All-Star break and losing six of their first eight coming out of it.

All told, Huntington is basically trying to put together a puzzle that might be missing a couple pieces to begin with, and a few more are hiding under the couch, unbeknownst to him.

“You look at the number of clubs in the National League that are competitive, and if you’re within a good two weeks, it makes it an interesting dynamic,” Huntington said Sunday at PNC Park. “We always want to [have a] long-term vision, but yet you want to respect that you’re in a pennant race even if you’re on the outside looking in.”

That might be the biggest question Huntington faces, and it actually has no answer, at least not on July 21: Are the Pirates in any sort of playoff race?

Advertise with us

Forget the pennant or anything substantive whatsoever. Just focus on making it. Is there a legitimate reason why Huntington shouldn’t start doing what a portion of his fanbase wants and just trade everyone?

Well, yeah.

For one, next season. Their rotation could be really good, assuming Jameson Taillon gets healthy, Dario Agrazal doesn’t turn into a pumpkin, and Mitch Keller takes the next step. Should Chris Archer keep improving in the second half and they get meaningful contributions from Trevor Williams and Joe Musgrove, then the Pirates could be very good. They have more depth arms in Edgar Santana, Chad Kuhl and JT Brubaker, though all three will bring about (legitimate) injury concerns.

If the Pirates can get Kyle Crick right, Keone Kela healthy and use them both to bridge the gap to Felipe Vazquez — a premium reliever, who, in this scenario, they’d keep — then they might have something with which to work.

Oh, and forgot to mention: You’re building that around Josh Bell, Bryan Reynolds, Starling Marte, Colin Moran, Kevin Newman and a few other young, talented position players.

Advertise with us

Huntington wouldn’t be crazy for sticking with what he has and only entertaining minor moves.

“We believe we have a good group of young players,” Huntington said. “We talk a lot about Josh Bell’s breakout, but there’s a good group of young players here that want to win and are driven to help their teammates be better.

“I’ve got to do everything in my power — and you could argue, a better job — to add to that.”

Perhaps the sneaky-hard part of what Huntington must do involves the prominent players on expiring contracts: Francisco Cervelli, Jung Ho Kang, Corey Dickerson, Melky Cabrera and Francisco Liriano.

Cervelli would be next to impossible because of his yearly salary ($11.5 million) and (lengthy) concussion history. Hard to imagine anyone wants Kang because of his off-field baggage, .182 average and propensity for striking out (50, or more than 30 percent of his 166 plate appearances).

Advertise with us

Dickerson and Cabrera would be attractive pieces to contenders, but right now Gregory Polanco’s balky shoulder has gummed up the works; the Pirates don’t know what they have in him, at least for the foreseeable future. And should they want a reliable fourth outfielder, at this point, they’d almost have to Dickerson and Cabrera.

As for Liriano, we’re talking about removing one of the more reliable arms from a bullpen that has been anything but that this season. He’s also their only lefty aside from Vazquez and has been able to work in a variety of situations — sixth, seventh or eighth, tied, ahead or behind.

Which means that Huntington has about a dozen or more plates in the air, and he’s trying his best to balance them all. It’s not easy.

“There’s a lot of external speculation about what every team in this situation is going to do or, better yet, should do,” Huntington said. “That’s where we’re going to continue to work to make what we believe to be the best decisions for the organization, and each organization is going to do that.”

If that sounds like a whole bunch of nuthin’, you might not be wrong. But at the same time, what do you want Huntington to say? What can he say?

Advertise with us

His team has been wildly inconsistent. His hands are likely tied by those above him. (Do you really think he’d turn down a chance to spend more money?) And he’s doing it all under a system that, for the first time, has one trade deadline instead of two, while competing in close division/wild card races with a team that doesn’t quite know what it is.

“I think we’re all learning,” Huntington said. “We’re all working through that. We’re all anticipating just how different it will be. I think the number of teams that are competitive in the National League is having as much impact as is having one deadline.”

And the Jekyll-and-Hyde impression his club has nailed so far this season has hardly made that any easier for Huntington.

“We’d love to be able to add to this group,” Huntington said. “We’ll see where we go. We’ll see what the market allows and where we can move this market in one direction or the other.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.