Clint Hurdle has talked in the past about receiving a bunch of free advice every time he sets foot inside Giant Eagle.

Here’s guessing it has been an informative couple of days for the Pirates manager.

As the club’s season has potentially skidded off the rails, a couple of decisions Hurdle has made have raised eyebrows among the fan base. Why no Felipe Vazquez Monday night? Wait, Michael Feliz in that situation?

Right or wrong, Hurdle’s job isn’t easy. It’s baseball tradition to second-guess the manager, and Hurdle knows that. As he discussed one of two sacrifice bunts the Pirates have attempted the past two nights — both of which were heavily scrutinized — Hurdle hit the nail on the head with at least one point he made.

Advertise with us

“We’re trying to win a game,” Hurdle said. “What are your best percentages to win a game? You have a runner on third base with less than two outs, or do you take three shots with a guy at second? It’s a gut feel. When it doesn’t work, it’s not the right decision no matter what the percentages are. It didn’t work out.”

The situation to which Hurdle was likely referring occurred Sunday afternoon. In the 10th inning, with Adam Frazier on second base and no outs, Hurdle had Kevin Newman put down a bunt.

Newman’s bunt did the job, and the Pirates had a runner on third with one out, meaning a fly ball or maybe a grounder to the right side would tie the score. Instead, the Pirates got a strikeout and a grounder to third, and fans blamed Hurdle.

What if he had three guys swing away, and nobody did anything? Chances are Hurdle would’ve been reminded the Pirates only needed one run; why play for a big inning?

On Monday, Hurdle had a similar thought. With two on, no outs and trailing by one in the bottom of the 10th inning, Hurdle had his catcher, Elias Diaz bunt. That one didn’t work, as pitcher Carlos Martinez was able to get the lead runner at third base.

Advertise with us

Had Diaz done the job, Corey Dickerson would’ve scored on Jacob Stallings’ single.

The point of all that? Hurdle made decisions that are incumbent on his players executing at key times in the game, and they haven’t done that. Go ahead and say Diaz should’ve hit away, but he’s hitting .175 over the past month and the Pirates had one reliever left, Chris Stratton, which means they needed to do everything possible to get one run, not save outs. (Dickerson, remember, scores on a wild pitch or passed ball from third base.)

On the mound, Hurdle’s recent decisions have been a little more curious, starting with his first call to the bullpen out of the All-Star break.

With everyone rested, Hurdle chose Feliz to take the ball from Chris Archer, and Feliz struggled to stop the bleeding. Fans wondered whether Hurdle had lost his mind.

Was Hurdle right? Based on what he said Tuesday, absolutely not. But there was at least some sound logic behind the decision.

Advertise with us

To that point, Feliz had inherited six runners, and none had scored. Opposing hitters were hitting .172 against Feliz over his past 16 outings, and he was scored upon just once in there.

“Feliz has been as good as anybody out there down a run and close the last month,” Hurdle said after that game.

Another decision with Feliz recently caused more consternation over how Hurdle has been managing the club. Last Wednesday in St. Louis, after Francisco Liriano put two on, Hurdle went to Feliz, who allowed the deciding, three-run home run to Paul Goldschmidt.

Why not let Liriano get out of the jam, many at home wondered. Where’s Richard Rodriguez? Fair questions, the same for why Feliz didn’t just start the inning if he had the best stuff against the heart of the Cardinals’ lineup. But more blackjack-type odds guided Hurdle’s decision-making here.

Goldschmidt hits left-handed pitchers a lot harder than he does right-handers — OPS of .935 compared to .732 — meaning Liriano would be a riskier play.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, Hurdle had to be mindful of Kyle Crick’s struggles and decided to hold Rodriguez back for the eighth inning. Enter Feliz, who began the game with a 1.80 ERA and .184 batting average against in 14 appearances since June 8.

The situation that’s been easiest to second-guess occurred Monday, when Hurdle declined to use Vazquez in the top of the 10th inning because he had thrown 35 pitches over the previous two games, including one day game after a night game.

Turns out that Vazquez apparently intimated to Hurdle that he could use a day down.

“He’s been very honest and forthright about when he’s been able to go,” Hurdle said. “He’s gone multiple times three days in a row. When he says he can go, he can go. He’ll be the first one to tell you, ‘It would be in my best interest to not try and go.’ ”

None of this is to say Hurdle is above criticism; he’s not. The Pirates had lost eight of 10 out of the All-Star break when they had a real chance to make a run at the division, yet they were seemingly nowhere near prepared to play.

Advertise with us

That’s at least partly on Hurdle, who said he has gotten better over the years at separating home and work life.

“For me personally and for our team, [Monday] night hurt,” Hurdle said. “Losing, I’m not a fan. However, in my position, I’ve got to find a way to turn it off. I have a home to go to. I have people at home who are counting on me just as much. I think a lot of time people lose sight of that.

“I have kids at home who are looking for me to show up in the morning when they wake up. I have a wife who deserves my time and attention when I get home. That’s what I’ve become more mindful of and plug into.”

At least until he ventures out to the grocery story, anyway.

Around the horn

Advertise with us

Hurdle said that Gregory Polanco visited Dr. David Altchek on Monday in New York City, and the Pirates were waiting for more results on Polanco’s balky shoulder. … The Pirates intend to activate Keone Kela from the injured list Wednesday, Hurdle said. It’s likely Kela will see a lower-leverage situation in his first outing back.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.