ST. LOUIS — Josh Bell has been a terrific story, even with his current funk. Bryan Reynolds has emerged as a key piece of the Pirates outfield for years to come. Young position players such as Kevin Newman, Colin Moran and Adam Frazier have all taken steps forward.
But for as many good stories as this Pirates season has produced, there’s been a bunch of less enjoyable ones, too, the unfortunate reality of being five games under .500 and two games from last place in what is perhaps Major League Baseball’s most mediocre division.
With that in mind, here are the five most frustrating story lines of the Pirates season thus far. Warning: This probably won’t produce a lot of smiles.
1. Let’s start with the recent stuff first: On July 7, after the Pirates used a three-run homer from Reynolds to beat the Brewers at PNC Park, 6-5, they were riding high at 44-45 and 2½ games out of first place in the National League’s Central Division.
But since the All-Star break, things have been bad. Jordan Lyles didn’t last an inning in Chicago. Trevor Williams and Joe Musgrove were a tick off. The Pirates were sloppy Monday in St. Louis, and their bullpen blew a lead in the seventh inning Wednesday.
Bottom line, the Pirates, despite all their early-season injuries and struggles, had a gigantic opportunity, and they very well may have blown it.
Read More
“We need to sharpen our game up,” manager Clint Hurdle said Tuesday at Busch Stadium. “We need to pitch better. Walks have been problematic. Multiple-run innings have been problematic. Defensively there were gaffes [Monday] night and there have been.
“Our want-to and our how-to are not matching up right now.”
2. The Pirates won 12 of their first 18 games behind a starting rotation that was supposed to be the strength of the team. In that (admittedly small) thumbnail, nobody had a better ERA than the Pirates’ mark of 2.52.
Since then, it’s been bad.
From April 21 through Wednesday, the Pirates have a staff ERA of 5.57. Only four clubs have been worse. Based on what Jameson Taillon and Williams did during the second half of last season and what the Pirates thought they could get from Musgrove and Chris Archer, the starting pitchers have produced well below expectations.
Not only that, the Pirates had Nick Kingham and Mitch Keller do absolutely nothing with the opportunities they were afforded, while finding consistent relief pitching has been an ongoing problem.
At the root of the Pirates’ pitching issues has been a stunning lack of control. Since April 21, nobody has fared worse than their 3.99 walks per nine innings.
“The walks are a challenge,” general manager Neal Huntington said on his radio show this past Sunday. “We are definitely walking way too many hitters. Free baserunners in a home run environment can become a crooked number very quickly.”
3. Given the poor performance by the pitching staff, the Pirates have needed an extra/reliable arm for months … yet nothing has been done.
With Dallas Kuechel available before the Braves signed him for $13 million (and no draft-pick compensation), the Pirates instead tinkered with an opener and had Montana DuRapau and Michael Feliz start games.
Meanwhile, the biggest trade the Pirates made was for Chris Stratton, who’s been fine as the long man out of the bullpen, but he’s not exactly the type of fix we’re talking about here.
Expecting the Pirates to mortgage significant pieces of their future for someone like Giants left-hander Madison Bumgarner might be a bit much. But acquiring a guy who has at least started big league games, and hasn’t been banished to the Frontier League after doing it, should not be too much to ask.
4. The Pirates have one of the best closers in baseball with Felipe Vazquez, but getting him the ball has been an issue.
Early in the season it was Richard Rodriguez who struggled a lot, allowing eight homers in his first 22 appearances before he improved his fastball command and turned his season around.
In the eighth inning, Kyle Crick was terrific a season ago — 1.4 wins above replacement — but has struggled with his control this season, walking 28 in 32⅓ innings, good enough for just 0.5 WAR.
Keone Kela has been hurt for much of the year, dealing with right shoulder inflammation, and Feliz hasn’t been able to graduate to a higher-leverage role.
5. Injuries have hurt the Pirates, especially when you’re talking about guys they expected to assume prominent roles.
Francisco Cervelli was supposed to catch 100-plus games, but he’s dealing with at least his sixth concussion since 2011 and might’ve played his last MLB game.
Taillon hasn’t pitched since May 1 and has only recently started throwing again, the result of a right elbow flexor tendon strain. Even in the best-case scenario, maybe Taillon makes it back by mid-to-late August. But given the fact that he’s throwing from just 90 feet on flat ground, that’s a long way away.
Gregory Polanco, meanwhile, had his rehab assignment shut down because of persistent problems in his left shoulder, which he had surgically repaired in the fall. After this season, Polanco has two more years on the five-year, $35 million contract he signed in 2016, meaning they could be paying a lot for damaged goods.
Lonnie Chisenhall, one of the Pirates’ offseason additions, has dealt with persistent calf issues. His locker does a great job of storing spikes and bats, but chances are the Pirates would rather actually have Chisenhall occupying it than at home in North Carolina, collecting a salary.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.