There’s a line of thinking, right or wrong, that participating in the Home Run Derby as part of All-Star Game festivities could screw up one’s swing.

Perhaps it’s because that’s not how swings are normally taken — at least not until recently. It’s definitely not done with that sort of volume.

Regardless, it’s kind of an urban legend, a myth, that if a Major League Baseball player tries his hand in the Derby, bad things could follow.

Josh Bell and the Pirates do not subscribe to that line of thinking.

Advertise with us

“I don’t know where it started,” Bell said Monday before a series opener against the Chicago Cubs at PNC Park. “But I’m pretty sure that’s not the case.”

For the record, Bell is right: Bryce Harper had an OPS of .972 after winning the Derby a year ago. Aaron Judge cooled off some in 2017 but still wound up hitting 22 homers in the second half.

An MLB.com study in 2017 examined a three-year sample of the home run rate of Derby participants versus those who didn’t do it and found the rates basically stayed the same.

To make himself feel a little better about what he’s going to experience next week at Cleveland’s Progressive Field, and beyond, Bell called former Pirates outfielder Andrew McCutchen.

Swing at 70 percent, McCutchen told Bell. The rest would take care of itself.

Advertise with us

“Trying to hit the ball in the seats, it’s going to ramp you up,” Bell said. “Just try and keep it even keel.”

Normally in batting practice, after bunting down both baselines and working through a progression of swings geared toward specific goals — getting a sacrifice fly, moving a runner over, etc. — baseball players always take a round or two with no rules.

Swing as hard as you can, see who can hit the scoreboard, the Allegheny River or whatever.

At some point between now and next Monday, Bell said he’ll probably run through one mock-Derby round in the cage, simply to understand what that sort of exertion feels like, but nothing more.

“Show and go,” Bell said. “See what I got.”

Advertise with us

And not worry about what might come next, a sentiment that’s shared by Bell’s manager.

“It’s kind of like you’re going to be a parent, and your kids are gonna want to do things,” Clint Hurdle said, explaining why he’s not worried about a post-Derby slump.

“Let him go be in the Home Run Derby. He’s talked about the joy he thinks it’s going to bring, the fun he thinks it’s going to bring. We’ll see where it goes. It’ll be another learning experience.

“Zero fear.”

That time when …

Advertise with us

Bell has plenty of work to do to best Hurdle’s favorite Home Run Derby memory.

“I got to watch Josh Hamilton’s [28-homer opening round at old Yankee Stadium in 2008] … there’s nothing that’s going to top that,” Hurdle said. “I got to watch that on the field. He set the bar pretty high for me as far as watching Home Run Derby.”

Hurdle also has some firsthand memories.

In 1999 at Fenway Park, Hurdle wound up pitching to three of the final four remaining — his own guy, Larry Walker, in addition to Jeff Bagwell, Jeromy Burnitz and Ken Griffey Jr., who wound up winning it all.

“I was the only guy who got Walker out that year,” Hurdle joked.

Advertise with us

After Bagwell surprisingly asked Hurdle to throw to him, Burnitz’s pitcher got visibly ill. Potentially sensing an opportunity, Griffey then asked Hurdle to throw to him.

“I said, ‘Yeah, OK, let’s turn this one down,’” Hurdle joked about Griffey. “So I threw to four guys in the first round. Three got to the semifinals. Two got to the finals. I threw 190-some pitches. It was crazy.

“It’s not the easiest thing to do, either, to throw the Home Run Derby. I was a little tired at the end of the night.”

Archer … for now

As of now, the Pirates expect Chris Archer, who exited his previous start early because of left hip discomfort, to start Wednesday.

Advertise with us

But Hurdle also said he was going to check with Archer closer to game time about how he felt.

Snub city

Felipe Vazquez certainly wasn’t losing sleep over his All-Star snub.

“I think I’ll actually get more sleep,” Vazquez joked. “Get a couple days off.”

There wasn’t a huge uproar over neither Vazquez nor Bryan Reynolds making it, although their teammates certainly were hoping they would.

Advertise with us

“I know everybody in this clubhouse thinks both of those guys had a really good chance and thought they should have been in,” Joe Musgrove said.

Musgrove, for what it’s worth, would like to see Major League Baseball forget the one-player-from-each-team rule, which is probably the biggest reason neither Vazquez nor Reynolds was selected.

“I think it should be whoever’s the best goes,” Musgrove said. “I don’t think there needs to be a representative from each team.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.