The 2019 MLB season is at the halfway point, and this is the time of year that the drama and excitement should be starting to heat up. There should be tight pennant races and intriguing decisions to be made by teams in terms of what to do at the trade deadline. The weather has recently (finally) taken a turn for the good in the northern cities and this should be the time of year that baseball captures the attention of sports fans.
But it isn’t, and that’s because baseball has a real problem and I’m not sure there is a way to solve it. There are simply too many teams that are either not all that interesting, particularly good or flat out awful. There isn’t much intrigue in the pennant races and there isn’t much to get excited about in terms of the stretch run, either.
I know I am not the only one that feels this way because attendance is down for the fourth straight year. I don’t blame fans for finally getting smart and I hope they continue to stay away in droves until the powers that be address the problem. There should be no incentive at all to tank or have a minimum payroll.
I have been resistant to the idea that a salary cap would solve some of these issues, but here’s why I am now 100 percent for a salary cap: It would also come with a salary floor and end this ridiculous undervaluing of star players. If teams had to spend more, there wouldn’t be teams trying to maximize their profits while putting a bad product on the field.
You might think I am firing at the Pirates here, but this is a problem league-wide. The reason the Pirates aren’t in the crosshairs nationally is because they have done just enough to field a team that is indeed competitive. They are painfully mediocre, but they are at least competitive and have a shot to win 82 or 83 games and claim they are really trying.
The issue with teams like the Pirates is that with a just a little bit of effort and willingness to spend a little bit more money, they probably could be an 88- to 90-win team. Instead, they are willing to go with no margin for error, try to catch lightning in a bottle and hope that everything goes right to give them those extra six or seven wins.
Read More
That is a model, though, that is used around the majors, so while fans here love to attack Bob Nutting, they are missing the fact that this is how a lot of baseball teams operate. That is why there are so many mediocre teams in the league and why the Pirates will be able to float around .500 all season.
The bigger problem, though, is the teams that aren’t even trying to win. They are either tanking or stripping it all the way down and rebuilding, putting a glorified Class AAA team on the field every night. The Orioles and Marlins are the poster children for this, but they have some company in the Royals, Mariners, Tigers and Blue Jays — and to a little lesser extent, the Mets and Giants.
Those teams all have a real chance to lose 100 games, and that’s absurd. If you are a fan of baseball in one of those towns, what exactly are you paying good money for tickets to see? Camden Yards is a great park and Boog Powell’s Barbecue is tremendous, but that isn’t enough to make me want to go watch that nonsense the Orioles put out there every day.
It is baseball’s biggest problem. It is barely July and the season is realistically over for far too many teams.
The division races in the American League East and Central and National League West are over already. The American League West is almost over, as is the National League East.
The only division race of any intrigue is the National League Central, and that’s mostly because the Cubs and Brewers have been wildly inconsistent. And one of those two teams will figure it out, add something at the trade deadline and leave the bottom three teams way behind.
That’s not an accident or a coincidence, either; it is almost by design. Teams are happy to collect money and pocket it rather than really do what it takes to win. I understand there will be down years and mathematically some teams have to have losing records every year, but what is going in baseball is horrible for the sport.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.