HOUSTON — It's tempting to make Tuesday all about Gerrit Cole, the former Pirates ace who was pitching for the first time against his former team.

For good reason, too.

Cole has been flat-out ridiculous for the Astros, a strikeout machine and the power arm many expected to see following the January 2018 trade that netted the Pirates four players.

Although Cole and his new employer beat the Pirates, 5-1, at Minute Maid Park, something else that materialized here could ultimately become a more important marking point in their season.

Advertise with us

Making his second start since coming off the injured list, Trevor Williams went toe-to-toe with Cole and held his own, pitching into the seventh inning and looking more like the guy who was one of Major League Baseball’s best starting pitchers after the All-Star break last season.

"I thought it was better across the board," Pirates manager Clint Hurdle said.

Williams allowed four runs in 6 2/3 innings, but two of those should probably have an asterisk next to them. Not that the Astros (50-30) didn't earn them; they did.

But the fourth-inning pitch Williams made to Yuli Gurriel, who smacked a two-run homer, was not one that's going to get him in trouble very often. In fact, most guys will leave it alone or drive it foul.

Instead, Gurriel somehow kept it fair, deposited it into the left-field seats and gave the Astros a 2-0 lead in the fourth inning.

Advertise with us

“As soon as he hit it, I thought it was going to be foul, but he kept it fair,” Williams said. “It was a big homer for them at that point in the game.”

Trevor Williams

The other home run Williams allowed was a leadoff homer to Alex Bregman in the top of the sixth, and that was completely on the Pirates starter, who made a terrible pitch. Houston's fourth run came via a leadoff double and sacrifice fly.

On the positive side, Williams walked nobody. He moved both fastballs around, fired a couple quality changeups and retired nine Astros on three or fewer pitches. Williams had only three three-ball counts.

"I felt better," Williams said. "It’s not that I felt ill-prepared last start. I just wasn’t as sharp as I was [Tuesday]. It’s a frustrating game. There’s few balls I wish I could have back, but that’s the nature of the beast."

The Pirates need it to be.

Advertise with us

Their offense was mostly quiet in this one. Melky Cabrera drove in their only run with a single through the right side in the sixth inning, as the top four in the order combined to go two for 16. So what?

More often than not, the Pirates have been able to score runs. It's preventing them that has been a problem.

If they can count on getting quality outings from Williams, who has made 27 starts of at least six innings since 2018 (the team is 18-9), then it could go a long way toward addressing one of their biggest issues.

Of course, they also need Jameson Taillon to start throwing, which will likely happen later this road trip. And they need to get Jordan Lyles (expected to start Saturday) back, too.

But you need to walk before you run, and too often this season Pirates starting pitchers — if they even have one available — have barely been able to crawl.

Advertise with us

“We need [Williams] back,” Hurdle said. “We need him back to get things done.”

As for Cole, it was sort of a strange night for the former Pirates ace. Despite leading the league in strikeouts prior to Tuesday's game, Cole fanned a season-low three against his former club.

Without his best stuff, though, Cole did show plenty of resolve by consistently working out of jams.

In the end, Cole earned the win by going six innings and allowing an earned run on seven hits with two walks and three strikeouts.

Cole threw 104 pitches, 69 for strikes, and fired first-pitch strikes to 18 of the 26 hitters he faced. Cole retired seven hitters on three or fewer pitches and required five three-ball counts.

Advertise with us

"It was fun going toe-to-toe with him," Williams said. "He’s a great competitor. He was a great teammate when he was with us. He’s going to have a long, great career. I wish him nothing but success."

It's not hard to see that Cole loves life with the Astros, whether that's being able to pitch how he wants to pitch (read: fewer sinkers, more spin pitches) or the situation he encountered in the sixth inning, when manager AJ Hinch let Cole clean up his own mess.

After walking Jose Osuna to load the bases, Hinch — who had a reliever ready — did not yank Cole. Instead, he let his pitcher figure it out. Cole wound up getting Elias Diaz to hit a tapper back to the mound to end the inning.

"That’s what tough pitchers do," said Adam Frazier, who struck out twice. "They buckle down when the situation gets tight."

Yep, life is good for Cole these days. He's part of a stacked Astros rotation, on one of the best teams in the league, which is why it might be smart for the Pirates (36-41) to let the Astros do their thing and worry about their own situation.

Advertise with us

If Williams and others can more frequently repeat the process we saw against the Astros, it should serve them well during a brutal stretch over the next month.

“The home run Yuli hit wasn’t a bad pitch," Joe Musgrove said. "The Bregman homer was middle-elevated, but I thought [Williams] did a really good job moving the ball around and changing speeds. Definitely something we can build off of."

Around the horn

The Pirates had emerged victorious in each of Williams’ past eight interleague starts. … Josh Bell and Starling Marte went a combined 0 for 8 with just three of those balls leaving the infield. … Kevin Newman extended his hitting streak to 15 games with a first-inning single. ... Bryan Reynolds is dealing with some sort of lower-body injury and couldn't run Tuesday, Hurdle said.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.

Advertise with us