The Pirates are on a four-game winning streak and coming off a three-game sweep of San Diego. On Sunday, they battled back twice from down three runs with their backs against the wall to win in thrilling fashion, 11-10.

It was an excellent weekend, and not surprisingly it has some dreaming of a big turnaround and a run to a playoff spot. Neal Huntington talked Sunday about the upward trend of the team and that has been the theme of some of the players, as well. We’ve heard all about how gritty and mentally tough this team is and how hard they battle to the end of each game.

That’s all pie in the sky nonsense, and at this point in the season I can’t believe there are people who are still willing to latch onto every sign of a pulse. The Pirates do have some good pieces, and maybe they will get on a run, but if they do, it won’t be because they somehow magically figured something out over the weekend against the Padres.

I’m not trying to be a Debbie Downer — or as some on social media would call me, a “negative yinzer media hack” — but we didn’t learn anything about the Pirates this weekend that we didn’t already know. There was nothing new about what they did and nothing to really celebrate other than they won a few games in a row.

Advertise with us

The Pirates’ four-game winning streak came against an awful Tigers team and a bad Padres team. And two of those wins felt almost like losses when you consider the Pirates needed to score a combined 19 runs in them just to scrape by with one-run wins. Sunday’s win had a lot more to do with the Padres’ pitching and defensive incompetence than anything the Pirates did.

There is something to be said about winning the games you are supposed to, but beating bad teams isn’t something that should produce hope and optimism. This is something the Pirates have done well, and it is the only reason they are even close to treading water and within shouting distance in the standings.

The Pirates are 36-40 and only 3½ games out of a wild-card spot. The spin from the Huntington camp is centered on the team’s injuries. I’d argue that the injury bug is a bit overrated, and that losing Trevor Williams and Jameson Taillon hurt but that’s really about it. Most of the other injuries have enabled players (Kevin Newman, Melky Cabrera, Elias Diaz, Bryan Reynolds, etc.) to play a lot more than they would have, and they’ve been better than the guys they replaced.

The Pirates are still in this race mostly because they have proven capable of beating up the bad teams. The Pirates are 22-8 against teams that are below .500. That tells me that if they got to play a bunch of bad teams the rest of the way, they might have a real chance to make some noise. The problem is they don’t, and they are 14-32 against teams that are .500 or better.

That second number is significant because the Pirates’ next 26 games will all come against winning teams. That starts tonight with the Astros and will include a heavy dose of games against the Brewers, Cubs and Cardinals. I’m not an expert in math, but if the Pirates are going to continue to play .304 ball against winning teams, they will go 8-18 over these next 26 games.

Advertise with us

That would leave them 44-58, dead and buried and just in time for the fire sale at the trade deadline to begin. That’s not being mean, harsh or negative; that is just calling it like I see it. This team has not proven it is capable of competing with or beating the best teams on its schedule, and it is getting ready to see a bunch of them.

That’s why I am not getting all giddy about a sweep of the Padres or a team that is “now getting healthy and ready to make a run,” because I’ve seen this show too many times already.

If the Pirates want to prove something, they need to post a winning record during this stretch of 26 games. If they can do that, then it will be time to take them seriously as a playoff contender.

Until then, stop jumping on the bandwagon every time they beat a bad team and stop talking about how they are trending. Their trend has been simple — they beat bad teams and lose to good ones. That needs to change, or this team will prove it is nothing more than a mediocre team that is better than the bottom teams in baseball.