Greetings and salutations. Welcome to the Pirates mailbag. Thank you for all the questions. Jason Mackey has the bag next week. Be sure to send inquiries to jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG

Roger Huffman @rogerhuffman8: Let’s hear detailed reasoning for your view that (Gregory) Polanco > (Bryan) Reynolds defensively?

Nubyjas: A lot of people didn’t like that line, I see. First of all, let me start by saying I like Bryan Reynolds and have been highly complimentary of him since he made his debut. In fact, I remember getting roasted for saying Reynolds is the guy we need to watch while everyone was raving about Cole Tucker. I also didn’t say Reynolds is a bad defender. I also talk to people in baseball daily. A lot more people like Polanco as a defender, even with his flaws, than people think. According to Baseball Savant, Reynolds has a minus-2 Outs Above Average and Polanco minus-1 this season. There are stats in Reynolds’ favor, such as UZR/150. However, it’s important to factor in Polanco coming back early from his shoulder injury. Polanco is still rounding into form, and when he does, there is no question to me that he’s, for now, better than a guy who hasn’t played 60 big-league games. None of this is to disparage Reynolds, who is having a great rookie season.

Jeffrey Koontz @JeffreyKoontzx: Do you feel the pitchers (or front office) have started to lose faith in Ray Searage? Keep up the good work. I truly appreciate having a different voice covering the Pirates.

Advertise with us

Nubyjas: I’d want you to ask Felipe Vazquez, Jordan Lyles, or Kyle Crick this question and see the response you get. It’s also important to remember even Glasnow admitted that it was he who didn’t buy in. Ray has had more wins than losses.

D.J. Spin @georgepayroll: Do you think there's a fairly clear cutoff date for when this team might decide to buy, sell, or both/neither? Or is it better to focus on a certain threshold of games outside the race(s) and a rough period of time? Either way, it seems like absent a decent run ASAP, we sell?

Nubyjas: The team still believes from Frank Coonelly all the way to down the clubhouse workers and everyone in between that the Pirates can compete once healthy. Frankly, the numbers aren’t in their favor. But they believe in themselves. That said, the next couple of weeks will be telling. Let’s say Trevor Williams and Jordan Lyles are healthy and good. That could change everything if they can go deep in games and save the bullpen. If not, they’ll likely be sellers.

Julius Pepperwood @bdub7: What do you think it would take for the Pirates to eat the rest of Hurdle’s contract and get fresh blood in the coaching staff next year?

Nubyjas: A natural disaster. Also, which fresh blood do you want on the coaching staff? Even if Ray was the problem, which he isn’t, what about how well Rick Eckstein is doing? The offense has been prolific for nearly eight weeks. A lot of this has to do with Eckstein and Jacob Cruz. Do you want to get rid of them?

Advertise with us

Nate @NateMuzika: What would a hypothetical return on Dickerson look like in terms of trade value?

Nubyjas: It’ll be tough. The industry is looking for younger guys with controllable contracts. This is Corey Dickerson’s walk year. It will make trading him difficult. Not impossible, but much harder.

Matt Dicicco @DiciccoMatt: If the Pirates decide to open the store, who will bring the most back?

Nubyjas: Felipe Vazquez or Starling Marte. In fact, I may or may not know of a team I used to cover that could really use a closer and would have some young players the Pirates could use. That said, the Pirates still feel they’re in it.

Yark @eYarkulation: So Reynolds only got a 1.35 draft bonus. I see that as an opportunity to gain some years on an extension and get cost certainty with super 2 being a foregone conclusion. Think it's possible and what's a legit deal? 9/80 maybe some options.

Advertise with us

Nubyjas: I don’t see him going down to the minors any time soon, so you’re probably right about him gaining Super 2 status. However, it’s too soon to be thinking of that. You still have to get Josh Bell and a lot of your rotation done. Oh, and now Kevin Newman and Colin Moran look like big leaguers. Reynolds will get his, but there’s so much time left and there are more pressing issues.

@regemcd: Are there any contract talks being kicked around with some of the younger players (Bell, Reynolds, Taillon, etc.) to sign them through their arbitration years

Nubyjas: There are always conversations and thoughts going around. There hasn’t been anything hot and heavy yet. This will be an interesting offseason, to say the least.

@raygreyfox: With the job Dario Agrazal did Saturday (better than Steven Brault, Nick Kingham, and Mitch Keller it seems in composure and confidence) and the high level of play of Reynolds, is the problem lack of depth or misjudging the talent of the depth? We wouldn't be seeing either if not for injuries.

Nubyjas: Agrazal is a unique story. He got DFA’d and then cleared waivers, which means the industry thought the same about him as the Pirates did. However, he worked hard and got himself to a sound start on Saturday. I was there and got to chat with him. I like his attitude. If nothing else, he isn’t afraid. He will be back in the bigs.