We don’t have time to explain the subtleties of the @dril Twitter account. Wikipedia defines him as a “user best known for his idiosyncratic style of absurdist humor and non sequiturs.” That and this famous tweet about cover it.

Like many of that account’s posts, it’s nonsense until you encounter a real-world situation that captures the essence of the humor. Like, for example, the Pirates pitching staff’s proclivity to pepper opponents with fastballs. Pirates blogger Alex Stumpf couldn’t help but use the the tweet as inspiration for a bit of commentary on Mitch Keller’s ugly June 12 start at Atlanta.

Keller ended up giving up three runs in the frame, then six runs total in a fastball-heavy start. It’s almost like opponents knew what was coming. And underlying statistics suggest that’s a generally recurring theme with this club.

Let’s first establish that while the Pirates pitching staff has struggled, particularly over the past month and change, it hasn’t been bad in every category.

Advertise with us

MLB’s Statcast data puts them in the top half in baseball in percentage of pitches in the strike zone and percentage of pitches that cause opponents to chase. Despite the seemingly endless home runs they’ve allowed, they’re about average in throwing “meatballs,” or dangerously hittable pitches. Their hard-hit percentage is a tad high, but not terminal. And their average exit velocity allowed is actually below the MLB average.

These numbers should add up to something closer to mediocrity than we’ve seen, even despite the staff’s many injuries this season. The reason they’re not probably has something to do with one category where they’re a big outlier.

Weighted on-base average, or wOBA, is a popular advanced stat because it doesn’t treat all hits as equal. Home runs, obviously, are more valuable than an equal number of singles. So wOBA weights extra base hits more heavily in arriving at an on-base number that more accurately reflects a hitter’s overall productivity. (Check out the methodology here.)

The Pirates are not great in this category. Their .344 wOBA allowed is fourth-worst in MLB and 20 points worse than the league average of .324.

More vividly, their wOBA on contact, or wOBAcon, is terrible. At .404, they’re third-worst in MLB, 22 points below average and in the bottom 7% across baseball.

Advertise with us

To put that number in context, Gregory Polanco is fifth on the team in hitter wOBAcon at .414. So opponents are, more or less, hitting like him every time they put balls in play against Pirates pitchers. That’s not good and looks even worse with a bit more context.

The Pirates are third in baseball in swing percentage generated at 47.7%, but their whiff percentage isn’t correspondingly high. They sit at 24.6%, below the big league average of 25.7%.

You don’t have to be a stats genius to come to some simple conclusions: Opponents feel comfortable swinging away against the Pirates. Relative to the rest of baseball, they’re not missing very often, and they’re doing a lot of damage when they connect.

Meanwhile, the Pirates are throwing a lot of fastballs, and not particularly good ones. Fangraphs data puts their fastball usage percentage at 55.6, 10th in baseball. The site’s pitch values grade them poorly, though, with an average run expectancy allowed of minus-12.8, 23rd in baseball. (You can read more about pitch values here.)

Combine the patterns and it sure looks like Pirates opponents are expecting fastballs, seeing a lot of them and swinging away at them for great effect. Consider, for example, Chris Archer’s start one night before Keller’s. He gave up five homers that night, and four of them came on fastballs.

Advertise with us

Two starts are anecdotal evidence, at best. Different pitchers have different repertoires, sequences and abilities to execute, so these patterns probably aren’t applicable to every pitching meltdown we’ve seen this season.

At the 30,000-foot level, though, it sure looks like the Pirates are a bit predictable. Maybe it’s time to re-evaluate that proverbial candle budget.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.