The sunrise is blinding as it climbs above the Appalachian Mountains. It’s early on baseball’s opening day, the day fans wait for all winter, and a cloudless spring day is blooming as I drive east on the Pennsylvania Turnpike, from Pittsburgh to Philadelphia, for the first half of a home-opener double play — at Citizens Bank Park on March 28, then PNC Park on April 1.
Hope springs eternal on opening day, though it isn’t equally divided.
The Pirates and Phillies, parked on either side of Pennsylvania, provide a compelling case study about baseball’s economics and how to build a winner. The Pirates won 82 games last season despite trading away Andrew McCutchen and Gerrit Cole. The Phillies, attempting to awaken from a lengthy rebuild, won 80. This winter, the Pirates again spent little in free agency, while Phillies owner John Middleton told USA Today in November, “We’re going into this expecting to spend money. And maybe even be a little bit stupid about it.’’
Then he spent it. The Phillies had an opening-day payroll $100 million larger than the Pirates.
A little over halfway through the drive to Philadelphia, I pass an exit for Mechanicsburg, a borough outside of Harrisburg, and am reminded of Jon Gracey. When we met in 2013 in Mechanicsburg, Gracey was five years into his battle with multiple myeloma, an incurable cancer of the plasma cells. His life expectancy at the time of diagnosis in 2007 was 15 months.
But we spent more time talking about his kids — twin daughters Haley and Erin and son Nathan — and baseball than about cancer. Gracey was a Pirates fan stuck in Phillies country. “I have two favorite teams,” he told me then, “the Pirates and anybody playing the Phillies.”
Read More
We were in touch off and on over the past five years. We sat together for a couple innings at a Pirates-Phillies game in Philadelphia in 2015. Gracey texted a few times every baseball season, asking what I thought about this game or that trade, but I hadn’t heard from him since sometime last summer.
I know he’d have thoughts for this story. So I text: “Happy opening day!”
■ ■ ■
“Holy [expletive],” an elderly man marvels to no one in particular as he stands outside the left-field gates to Citizens Bank Park on opening day. “I’ve never stood in a line of any kind here before.” He counts roughly 50 people between him and the metal detector. He doesn’t sound upset.
Inside the ballpark, a queue snakes out of the Phillies team store, stretching past three kiosks on the concourse before doubling back on itself. There are lines at every beer and brat stand.
“Know how you can gauge the excitement over the team?” asks Tony “Tornado” Penecale, a self-proclaimed Super-Phan. “The lines at the restrooms are long again.”
In the Phillies clubhouse, there are too many reporters to fit into manager Gabe Kapler’s office at one time, so he holds two sessions. During batting practice, photographers form an arc in front of the home dugout, waiting for superstar Bryce Harper to emerge from the clubhouse tunnel and climb the dugout steps. They wait over an hour before realizing Harper hit in the indoor batting cages. He won’t come out until pregame introductions, with everyone at their seats.
Harper is a showman. When he runs to right field in the first inning, he bows dramatically, then pumps his fist twice. The crowd roars. After throwing warm-up tosses, Harper hurls the baseball into the upper deck. He wears bright green spikes with the Phillie Phanatic’s face on them. (The next game, the Phanatic would wear shoes with Harper’s face on them.)

Penecale, who wears a sequin-studded, red-and-white-striped vest and an Uncle Sam hat to games, works for a health insurance company. He was sitting in his cubicle Feb. 28 when a colleague walked over and said, “We got him.” Penecale glared back. “Shut up,” he said, then checked Twitter. The Phillies had signed Harper to a 13-year, $330 million contract.
“We went through a lot of years of bad,” Penecale says. “Then [Middleton] said, ‘We’ve got to spend some stupid money.’ When you say something like that, you’ve got to back it up.”
Shortly before first pitch, Gracey texts back. He says he’s involved in a clinical trial, and it seems to be working. He’s getting ready to watch the Pirates play the Cincinnati Reds. “Looking forward to RTJR [Raise the Jolly Roger],” he writes. We make plans to meet for breakfast the next day.
In Philadelphia, the party starts with one swing. When McCutchen belts a leadoff home run to left-center field, Eric Harring, the owner of a sprinkler-fitter company in New Jersey, tells me, “We got your boy! Money well spent.” One of his employees, Steve Beaky, says, “Pittsburgh had a good team for a couple years, and then they didn’t pay nothin’. They just sat there.”
Nearby, brothers Joel and Kurt Magda say they haven’t seen the ballpark this full — the announced attendance is 44,469 — since opening day in 2009, the spring after the Phillies’ last World Series title. The Magdas have gone to every Phillies home opener since 1995. Perhaps the Phillies learned a lesson on rebuilding by studying the Philadelphia 76ers, because the Phillies followed five consecutive trips to the playoffs by averaging 91 losses the past seven seasons.
“As a fan, you never want to be involved in the rebuild years, but you accept the fact that they're a necessary evil to get you where you want to be,” Joel Magda says. “Do we want to be a losing team? No. But if two years is what it takes to get you where you need to be? Yes.”
The price of the Phillies’ playoff runs from 2007 to 2011 was a collection of bloated contracts. The situation could resurface down the road, particularly toward the end of Harper’s contract.
“It’s the price of doing business in this day and age,” Kurt Magda says.
On opening day in Philadelphia, concerns can be dealt with another time. Rhys Hoskins smacks a grand slam, and Aaron Nola, the seventh overall draft pick in 2014, is sharp over six innings. “It felt like October out there,” Kapler says. After the last out of a 10-4 win against the Atlanta Braves, McCutchen euro-steps and dunks his glove through Harper’s waiting arms.
“Just kids playing,” McCutchen says later.
We like to have fun here. #RingTheBell pic.twitter.com/MbodHEllS1
— Philadelphia Phillies (@Phillies) March 28, 2019
■ ■ ■
The next morning, Gracey is standing in the doorway of a diner just off the turnpike. He looks no different than the last time we met. He says he’s shorter now. Doctors found three more fractures in his back, which makes 10 in the 12 years since he was diagnosed with multiple myeloma. He’s down 3½ inches from his peak height. But he’s cheerful and chipper.
Gracey, 56, asks for a table where we can talk. We sit by the window.
He’s a storyteller, and on this day each story is tumbling into two or three more. He rags on fair-weather Philadelphia fans, but, truth be told, he’s a little jealous. “In baseball, you can buy hope,” he says, “You can try to buy a pennant.” He chafes at the term “financial flexibility” and thinks Pirates management uses the team’s small-market status as an excuse to not spend.
Then he stops and smiles. He has good news about his health.
“We’re breaking new ground here,” he says.

For the past nine years, Gracey took chemotherapy pills regularly. They kept him alive, but he was nauseous for about 28 days per month. After begging his oncologist for years to put him on a clinical trial, Gracey was cleared this winter to undergo CAR (chimeric antigen receptor) T-cell therapy. The simplest way he can describe it: “They train these [cells] like circus fleas.”
The procedure involves collecting a patient’s T-cells — the fighter cells of the immune system — and engineering them to target a specific protein on myeloma cells. Ideally, when the modified T-cells are returned to the body, they then seek out the myeloma cell and destroy it.
Gracey unbuttons his flannel shirt to show a yellow T-shirt underneath which bears the Pirates, Penguins and Steelers logos. He wore the shirt on the day of his transplant in January at University of Pennsylvania’s medical center. In the days following the CAR T-cell therapy, he explains, you’re at a high risk for an adverse reaction. Nurses woke him up every four hours to give him a cognitive test. The first day, he walked two miles. The next day, he went three miles.
“Normally they only give [trials] to people on their deathbed,” Gracey says. “It’s a Hail Mary. A last resort. I begged them for years to give it to somebody who is pretty OK. Let’s see what it does to somebody like me. Guess what they're finding out? It’s killer — in a good way.”
Gracey says his doctors call him a freak, “the healthy guy with cancer.”
“We don’t know how long this will last,” he says, “but the bottom line is I’m not sick. I'm not miserable. I don’t have to eat poison every day. That has changed my life.”
■ ■ ■

It’s two hours before the Pirates home opener, and Ryan Ball already is in his seat in Section 212 at PNC Park. He’s waiting for his father, brother and niece. He has a pencil in his pocket and a new scorebook in his lap. His father, Joe, is losing his vision, so a few years ago, Ryan decided that when they go to the ballpark, he’ll keep score and tell his father what’s going on.
“I’m keeping track of every ticket for every game I go to for the rest of his life — as long as he can see and after that,” Ryan says. “We’re going to come to opening day every year until then.”
Joe is legally blind. He had to retire early. Joe and his father bonded over baseball, and then he and his four boys did the same. At home in Moon Township, Joe pulls his recliner a few feet from the TV to watch Pirates games. At the ballpark, if he and Ryan sit close to the field, Joe will pull out his binoculars and see what he can see. Whatever he misses, Ryan, 29, tells him about.
“It’s a great three or four hours I get to spend with my dad,” Ryan says.
Ryan’s Pirates fandom was reborn in 2013, the year they returned to the playoffs for the first time in 20 years. “That brought back out the kid in me,” he says. He dug through boxes to find a baseball that former Pirates outfielder Jermaine Allensworth tossed him in 1997. It’s still in a plastic case. Ryan comes to about 15 games per year. He tries to sit somewhere new each visit. He gives his dad the play-by-play, and he tells him about the view from their seats.
Like almost everyone in the ballpark, Ryan has an opinion about the Pirates ownership’s spending habits, but the home opener doesn’t feel like a day to complain.
“There’s always hope,” he says. “Every year, you’ve got to believe.”
Todd and Terri Martin, a couple from Coshocton, Ohio, left their four daughters with family to drive to Pittsburgh for the home opener. They’ve already mapped out a handful of games to attend early in the season. “It’s a fresh start,” Todd says. “Anything can happen from here.” He spends a lot of time reading about Pirates history, about their World Series runs.
“I hope we can get back there,” he says, “and make some current history.”
But the home opener is one the fan base would rather forget. The Pirates bullpen coughs up two leads, and as the game trudges into extra innings, the crowd of 37,336 thins. In the 11th, reliever Nick Kingham enters with the bases loaded and crosses up signs with catcher Francisco Cervelli. The St. Louis Cardinals’ go-ahead run scores on a passed ball.
“You never have it won ’til you win it,” manager Clint Hurdle says afterward.
■ ■ ■
Selfishly, Gracey wants to see the Pirates push all their chips in, spend big and go for it. He remarked to a friend recently that he might have to start liking the Phillies. Saying that, he admits, “is like vinegar in my mouth. But [the Phillies] have hope. They have investment.”
“I’d love to see a winner,” he says, “because I have no idea what my future is.”
Last August, Gracey’s health took a turn for the worse. He’s had pneumonia 14 times — “That’s what’s going to kill me,” he says — and he wasn’t sure he’d survive this bout. He started counting sunrises again. That’s what he’d done in January 2007 after he was diagnosed with multiple myeloma. He was a month away from his girls’ birthday. He promised them he’d make it.
“I had no hope then,” Gracey says. “I didn’t know if I’d make it through the night. So I wouldn't sleep. I knew when I saw the sun coming up in the morning that I’d made it another day.”
For Gracey, winters are dark. Winter is when his immune system is the weakest. As the weather improves, so does his health. On the first day of spring each year, Gracey celebrates with a few of his friends. The sunrises recently have made his heart swell. He doesn’t know how many winters he has left, but he knows he made it through this one, and he hasn’t felt better in ages.
For Gracey, opening day isn’t only about baseball. It’s about hope and new life. He starts to say something, but then his eyes well up and he buries his head in his hands.
“That’s exactly it,” he says. “I survived. I made it another year.”
Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.
Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.