Welcome to Sir Joseph Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Larry Murphy and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …
Jon Linder, @LinderShowMiami: How many modern day Penguins or former Penguins do you think will have their jersey numbers retired in the organization? I got the obvious: Crosby, Malkin and Fleury. Anyone else?
To which “DC @crockettdc” adds: “I’d be surprised if fleurys number was retired.”
Starkey: First, let me say this: I love that the Penguins do not dole out retired jerseys like Skittles. The only two so far are Mario Lemieux’s 66 and the late Michel Briere’s 21.
I would have thought about Tom Barrasso’s No. 35 — or at least not handing it out anymore — but I’m OK with the omission (Barrasso, incidentally, once challenged me to shoot pucks on him because he was angry over a story; I was tempted to answer, ‘OK, but only from center ice like Tom Fitzgerald.’ I thought better of it. I think that was a good choice).
Yes, Crosby and Malkin will see their jerseys raised someday. I’m not sure anything else is guaranteed, though I believe Jaromir Jagr, Fleury and perhaps Kris Letang have a chance.
Read More
I never believed Jagr signing with the Flyers all those years ago was as big a deal to the Penguins as it was to the fan base. It really wasn’t a betrayal. Jagr did not actually commit to coming back here. It only seemed that way. And then he simply went to the best place for him. I believe No. 68 will rise here someday.
Letang is the most accomplished defenseman in franchise history — and you might remember him scoring a Cup-winning goal in San Jose. He still has some productive years left, as well.
Fleury is a fascinating case. He has the team record for wins at a robust 375. He was one of the faces of the Penguins’ revival. He won the Cup with an iconic save. He paved the way for another Cup win by stoning the Washington Capitals. He is a wonderful human being on top of all that.
So yes, if it were up to me, Fleury’s automatic (Matt Murray’s off to a pretty nice start, as well, with two Cups; and did you know he is the Penguins’ all-time leader in save percentage at .918?).
It should be interesting, if any of us are alive to see it. Which brings us to question No. 2 …
Mary Mac Bakehouse, @MaryMacMixes: What’s the matter with people? I’ll hang up and listen for your response.
Starkey: If humanity were a baseball team, one that renews itself each year, Mary Mac, 2019 humans are the ’62 Mets. We suck.
As for diagnosing the precise issue, I’d say fear, pride, self-loathing, avarice and ignorance are the leaders in the clubhouse.
KatieKelly, @ktCakes_: Favorite athlete who shares your first or last name?
Starkey: Do any share my last name? That’s an honest question. The most famous Starkey has to be Ringo Starr, whose original name is “Sir Richard Starkey.”
Should my new byline be “Sir Joseph Starkey”?
The only famous Joe Starkey, by the way, is the Joe Starkey who preceded Mike Lange on Penguins broadcasts, called games for the San Francisco 49ers and made the famous “The band is on the field!” call from the 1982 Cal-Stanford game. I met him once. Knocked on his press-box door before a Steelers-49ers game and said, “Hello, Joe Starkey. My name is Joe Starkey.” He took it well.
As fate would have it, the topic of “Most Famous Joe” in sports history came up on the show the other day. Which name pops into your head first? Ron Cook and Joe Block both said Joe DiMaggio. Mine was Joe Namath. How about you?
P.S.: I found an athlete named Starkey:

Bobby Reese, @BuStA607: What current Steeler on defense if any could start for the Super Bowl teams of the ’70s?
Starkey: Joe Haden opposite Mel Blount would be nice (no offense to J.T. Thomas, Ron Johnson or anyone else). And remember, Mr. Reese, the Steelers’ personnel changed from the first two Super Bowls to the last two. By the late ’70s, Cam Heyward would have fit in nicely on the defensive line. T.J. Watt opposite Jack Ham, anyone?
Christopher Matich, @PghMatich: Why can’t Crick go more than one inning at a time? Can none of the Pirates relief pitchers pitch more than one inning, especially when they look like they’re lights out?
Starkey: They do go more than one inning at a time, Mr. Matich. I thought Vazquez was going to throw 90 pitches Monday. But I do agree Crick should have stayed in the game after one effective inning and just 12 pitches. Bullpen usage has been interesting in the first three games, I’ll say that. Definitely a conversation piece.
BustedLockerPodczst, @bustedlocker: I saw a lot of people gushing over Archer’s performance in the home opener. Saw one person even call it “brilliant.” Is this what we’ve come to in baseball? Have we gone from the days of Johnson and Maddux to 99 pitches in 5 innings being a great outing? Say it ain’t so, Joe.
Starkey: Brilliant? No. Definitely not. A five-inning start cannot be brilliant. However, Mr. BustedLockerPodcast, I’d take five innings of shutout ball every game from a starter — and striking out the side to end the performance was nice, especially considering the last two hitters Archer faced were Carpenter and Goldschmidt.
Put it this way, if you told Clint Hurdle and Neal Huntington they could either have five innings of shutout ball every game or take their chances otherwise, don’t you think they’d take the five innings and figure out the bullpen end of it?
PissedBurgh, @gameOFshane: Do you think scolding your Twitter followers over bad questions will result in better questions?
Starkey: Yes.
tchoumi, @tchoumi19: Kessel’s play on the second half of the season is quite worrying: do you see Pens management trading him in the offseason if things don’t improve for Phil?
Starkey: I could see them trying, Mr. t, but I happen to believe the offseason is a long ways away — and I happen to believe Kessel will rebound with a productive postseason. I remember the days when the Penguins went whole series (Boston) scoring twice and shot about 3-for-8,000 from the field against Henrik Lundqvist over two series. Kessel helped change all that. One bad playoff doesn’t change my opinion of him as a postseason game-breaker.

NoQuarter, @moxie1959: In your college days in Buffalo, did you and your drunken buddies ever think about getting in a barrel to go over Niagara Falls?
Starkey: Yes.
Ron Matthews, @RonMatthews82: Is this the worst defensive Pirates team you have ever witnessed?
Starkey: It’s not good. The errors are one thing. The Pirates have three, which actually isn’t even in the top 10 in baseball. The other plays that haven’t been ruled errors bother me, too. Josh Bell makes a bad throw to second, screws up a rundown and drops a pop-up in foul territory. (How was that not ruled an error?) Jung Ho Kang double clutches a throw to first, and the runner’s safe. Colin Moran allows a field-able past him at third. Every batted ball feels like an adventure.
NoQuarter, @moxie1959: Have you ever operated a forklift? If so, the results?
Starkey: Many, many times. Spoonlifts, too. And at last check the results are around 213 pounds.
Thank you, kiddies. Be sure to insult Sean Gentille. Also, send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com)






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.