Pirates owner Bob Nutting on Wednesday mostly followed the script that his top lieutenants have used this offseason in explaining the team’s plummeting payroll.
“We need to focus on the things we believe are controllable. Absolute payroll dollars are never going to define this club,” Nutting told reporters before being pressed to clarify.
"I think payroll scale and range, broadly, is not controllable. We’re going to have certain resources that we have, and I think that that’s the reality of a marketplace."
Like comments from general manager Neal Huntington and team president Frank Coonelly earlier this winter citing belief in the team’s young core as the reason the Pirates are projected to spend less than $75 million on their roster in 2019, here we have a kernel of truth wrapped mostly in obfuscating nonsense.
As this space has noted in recent weeks, it’s true that payroll is an inexact science. The constant churn of young players coming up through a system, veterans earning raises through arbitration and contract extensions and departures of other players through free agency make it difficult and typically inadvisable for a club to try to hit a fixed spending target in any single year.
Starters Jameson Taillon, Trevor Williams and Joe Musgrove, for example, are three proven young arms who will make the big-league minimum of about a half-million dollars this year because they lack the service time to earn raises. There aren’t a whole lot of clear upgrades over them available on the free-agent market, so therefore, it makes sense for the Pirates to save their money and roll with those guys as three-fifths of a relatively inexpensive rotation.
Read More
Put another way, the Pirates shouldn’t spend for the sake of it and are correct to argue that there are plenty of legitimate baseball reasons for a payroll to dip from one year to the next.
The point at which Nutting and his regime lose the thread of this argument is when they begin to deflect questions about their lack of spending to address obvious weaknesses. The team’s shortstop situation this season is the most vivid example.
Unproven options Kevin Newman and Erik Gonzalez will compete for that starting job this spring plainly because they will make the minimum and not because there’s convincing evidence that either will be productive. Newman is a well-regarded prospect but struggled in the big leagues last September, while Gonzalez is a soon-to-be 28-year-old who languished on the fringes of Cleveland’s roster for years before he was traded here earlier in the offseason.
While it’s certainly possible that either guy could surprise and have a productive year, it’s not particularly likely. Projection models have their contributions topping out at about one win above replacement, which means we’re likely to see them produce at the level Jordy Mercer did last year.
That wasn’t good enough. Neither was Josh Bell’s 0.9 WAR at first base. Neither was Colin Moran’s 0.7 at third. They’re young and cheap, too, and they appear poised to retain prominent roles despite their struggles last year, which means you should probably be sensing a theme at this point.
The legitimate baseball reasons to give these players critical roles aren’t nearly as apparent as the fact that they’re the cheapest passable options. Huntington’s weak advocacy for the general “variability,” or upside of young players, only underscores this point.
This is why the spirit of Nutting’s comments is disingenuous, even if they’re technically true. There is no magic payroll number that’s going to make the Pirates a winner, but their lack of commitment to spend on free agent solutions to their obvious shortcomings should define the 2019 team if, and probably when, it falls short of the postseason for a fourth consecutive year.
If Nutting wants his team to have a proven shortstop, he can authorize Huntington to acquire one, regardless of cost. In this regard, payroll range and scale is controllable, directly, by him.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.