Jameson Taillon has the profile of a pitcher who should want to reach free agency as quickly as possible. A former No. 2 overall pick who’s developed into a borderline staff ace, he’d be one of the most valuable players on the market the moment he reaches it.

For that reason, it would typically be hard for any team, let alone the Pirates, to lock him down into his free-agent years with an extension. Why negotiate with one team when you can negotiate with all of them and go to the highest bidder? The incentive for the player to sign just isn’t there.

At least that’s what logic dictated before this past winter, when baseball’s hot stove went lukewarm. Now, with dozens free agents including stars like Bryce Harper and Manny Machado unsigned at the start of spring training, the calculation among top young pitchers may be changing a bit.

Philadelphia’s Aaron Nola on Wednesday signed an extension for at least four years and $45 million with an affordable team option for a fifth year. Should the Phillies exercise it, they will have successfully bought out two of Nola’s free-agent years for an average of well less than $20 million per.

Advertise with us

This after Nola posted a fabulous 2.37 ERA and was worth 5.7 wins above replacement in 2018, according to Fangraphs.

That kind of production at the price Nola signed for would have been considered an enormous bargain just two years ago. Now, though, it may be his hedge against finding himself in the situation Harper and Machado are in now. Better, perhaps, to take $45 million while it’s on the table than merely hope that the market’s conditions improve by the time he reaches it.

Taillon, the Pirates’ union rep, is no doubt taking notice of the deal. Though he’s two years older than Nola, he’s about a year behind in terms of service time. Like Nola this year, he’ll be arbitration eligible for the first time next year, a natural point for player and club to start talking extensions for cost certainty.

If the Pirates can put something approaching Nola’s guaranteed payday on the table, perhaps they can entice Taillon to give up a free-agent year or two more easily than they might have previously. Something in the neighborhood of $38-$45 million may be less than he’d like, but it would set him up for the rest of his life financially and shift all of his injury risk to the club.

When you’re a pitcher who’s already lost two full pro seasons to injury and missed time in a third because of cancer, that kind of security is not insubstantial.

Advertise with us

The Pirates have enticed players including Andrew McCutchen, Starling Marte and Gregory Polanco to sign similar long-term deals in recent years. They were or have been successful in varying degrees, giving the team solid production at a lower price than they could have bought it on the free-agent market.

For that reason, they may want to be aggressive in locking up Taillon while market conditions are so tight. If they can buy out a couple of free-agent years, they could have one of the best pitchers they’ve developed in recent decades locked up at a reasonable price until his age-32 season. That’s a win for any smaller-market team that’s prone to losing young stars much earlier.

Team president Frank Coonelly has said that the team’s payroll is low in 2019 in part because it’s preparing to pay younger core players more as they reach arbitration and free-agent eligibility. This could be a chance for Pirates brass to show it in a big way.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.